Monday, February 26, 2024

A Year of Blind Spots: Fumbling Towards Ecstasy


Fumbling Towards Ecstasy
Sarah McLachlin
1993

I don't like the idea of an artist's body of work being reduced down to a fucking meme any more than you do. Pat could do a way better job at this than I could, but let's start there anyway—when I hear the name "Sarah McLachlin," I think about animal commercials that are meant to be maudlin and are meant to turn sadness into charity donations. I don't even know if I've ever actually even seen one of those commercials, but I know the general idea of them, and I know that the internet has shaped this mindset for me, to my detriment and to Sarah's detriment. Because if that's the case, then when you actually listen to the music (without being bombarded with pictures of dead dogs and cats or whatever), you have a realization that... this shit is kinda boring. And that becomes kinda sad, because if the most valuable contribution you've made to the general pop culture discussion is a goddamn meme, then what does that say about your art? Is it actually boring, or am I just being cranky about it?

It's probable that that's just me being cranky, because when I asked Pam about Sarah McLachlan, her first thought was not of memes, but of Lilith Fair. So that tells me right there that this is an artist who is in Pam's wheelhouse more than mine. This isn't the first Lilith-Fair-type artist we've covered on this blog, not by far, but it's the first one that actively bored me. I get that it's beautiful, artistic music, but it's just too slow for my tastes, I think. Like always, I can see where other music shoots off from here. Sheryl Crow makes it more rootsy, Tori Amos makes it more artsy, Indigo Girls make it more folksy, Alanis Morissette makes it more rocky, and even Z-list musicians like Emmy Rossum manage to latch onto the really dubious new age stylings of it. I like all of those artists (mostly), so maybe this is just me wanting something more, and not getting it here at the genesis of a bunch of different sounds. Whatever.

I don't know what I was expecting otherwise, though. The McLachlan songs that I know intimately are the infamously sad "I Will Remember You" and the song from Toy Story 2 that was explicitly designed to induce tears (but you're safe now, Jessie!!!). So I guess I put Fumbling Towards Ecstasy down as a blind spot because I was curious as to whether a full-album Sarah McLachlan experience would be any different, or could hit in a more upbeat or more interesting way. It's not true, but I got what I came for anyway. This downbeat balladry is no longer a blind spot. It's just a sad, slow hour spent with a sad, slow, now-known artist.

I don't have anything else to report. I tried! I even listened to it on a quiet Saturday morning to see if it would hit any differently! And it did not. I get the appeal of this music, I think, but I just know that it's not really the type of music I could even get behind. Oh well. Maybe you'll think differently.

(Addendum: The blogging gods have seen fit to hand me a a coincidence that I have no choice but to view as divine. About an hour after I finished typing this, Stereogum published an interview with Sarah McLachlan regarding her upcoming Fumbling Towards Ecstasy 30th Anniversary Tour. I don't think that the interview necessarily sold me on the album, still, but it did add some extra context, which I appreciate. For instance, apparently the album was recorded during sub-30-degree temperatures in a Canadian winter. The slow, sad music makes a little more sense! Doesn't make me like it, but it makes me understand it. Always read as much as you can before blogging about something, kids. Don't be like me.)


No comments: