Monday, February 19, 2024

Yearlong Song Challenge, Day 23: Zach

Prompt: "A song whose title asks a question"

Selected by Zach


"Why Should the Fire Die?"
Nickel Creek
Why Should the Fire Die?, 2005

Another band my brothers liked many years ago, only to ditch them for "better" and "cooler" bands later. I can't tell if Nickel Creek is cool again because Chris Thile is some kind of star now and Sara Watkins went solo and then they had a reunion, but even if they are, this album isn't the reason for it. There's a certain eye-rollingness to the album title (this song is the title track), a lack of irony, irony which seems to be the prerequisite for success sometimes.

I know the album decently well, but kind of forgot about this song, the last song on it. Now that I listened to it multiple times to write this—it's pretty good! It's a perfect song to end an album (or a live show) with. It's sweet without going for the emotional jugular. Nickel Creek feels innocent, and innocence is everything I wish I had right now.

1 comment:

Sara said...

Nickel Creek is Nickel Back's Appalachian cousin and I like it.