This is The First Time, a column where Zach either 1) writes about the first time he did something specific in his life and talks about any pop culture connections surrounding it, or 2) tries something for the first time ever in 2025 and writes about it—sees a new movie, eats a new food, etc. etc. etc.
We are now in the middle of my annual break from music.
We are now in the middle of my annual break from music.
Ideally, it would have happened twice a year. This year, though, I couldn't stomach it. Once a year is hard enough as is.
Jewish tradition dictates that there are two time periods per year when the community, as a whole, observes mourning rites. Right now, we are in a period called the Three Weeks. They last from the 17th of the Jewish month of Tammuz to the 9th of the Jewish month of Av. On the 17th of Tammuz (in 70 CE), the walls of Jerusalem were breached, a precursor to the destruction of the Second Temple by the Romans. On the 9th of Av, the Temple was actually destroyed. Strangely enough, the First Temple was also destroyed on the 9th of Av, this time by the Babylonians and King Nebuchadnezzar (cool band name). That was in 586 BCE. The Purim story took place between the two destructions.
We mourn the Temple's destruction during these three weeks. The 17th of Tammuz this year fell on Sunday, July 13, so until Sunday, August 3 (the 9th of Av). During that time, I won't be listening to music played with instruments. A cappella is allowed. But a cappella sucks. I'll be listening to podcasts instead. (Can I recommend the Girls Rewatch podcast with Lena Dunham as special guest that just came out? Lena Dunham is the voice of the millennial generation and is a genius.)
This is one of the restrictions that was instituted in the wake of the Temple's destruction. Other restrictions: No shaving, no swimming, and a few others. I'm not someone who cares if anyone does anything. You do you! I shave if I need to impress someone. People can listen to music if they want to. Everyone needs to do what works for them. If giving up music didn't work for me, I wouldn't do it. I really don't think religion should feel like it's choking the life out of you. Sometimes, if I'm being honest, there are things about religion and being observant that are so hard for me. I try to do them, and I don't. I can't feel about that for myself. I'm human, and I need to live my life. But the things that work for me? I embrace them, because they're good for me, often in a surprising way.
I started to get back into being religiously observant after that rough breakup during that late summer of 2017. It was a slow process. That's a topic for a different post. But in 2018, I decided to try giving up music during the other month-or-so-long time period that happens during the Jewish year, called The Omer (when many of Rabbi Akiva's students died in a plague, also thousands of years ago).
It was hard, but it felt good. And now I realize I need this self-imposed break, once a year, as much as I dread it.
I love music. I listen to it all the time. But giving up music for a little bit helps me get away from the dopamine casino rush for just a little while. I want it, and I deny it to myself. A little self-denial hurts, but in the end I think it's healthy. Like looking at my phone. I don't know how to deny myself when it comes to technology. I don't have a framework to do it. With the music restriction, though, I do, because I'm not the one who created it.
Sometimes a framework that's set up outside your own mindset—a framework that's existed for thousands of years—does just the trick. I always appreciate music so much more when the time period is over. It feels so good to jump back in, like diving into a raging ocean and coming up and feeling alive again.
So you won't see any album reviews from me during this period. Any songs I pick for any MMMs will be based on feel and feel alone. I hate it, but I love it at the same time.

4 comments:
If Puke on Your Birthday was a religion, or version of hell would be "two weeks listening to podcasts instead of music."
I'll make sure to describe your MMM songs to you in the comment section on Monday, like talking a blind man through a TV episode.
finally
i wonder if the break i'm craving is more from the endless and instant selection of music that spotify/youtube provide. listening to music never was this easy. it's a blessing...but is it too much?
Here's what I'll posit—and this is not something new for me, I'm annoying with this shit because I say it all the time, but—
It's not the quantity of music available that's the problem. The problem is how we allow these vast data banks of endless music to ALSO be the curators of that music. Yes, Spotify has 10 billion songs, but you can't trust Spotify to tell you which of those songs to listen to. You're gonna get a whole bunch of fucking slop. AI-recommended music, basically, and that's no fucking way to live.
Now, I'll avoid the joke of "Puke on Your Birthday has recommendations," but I will say that you need SOMETHING besides the algorithm to figure out where to turn in the endless maze of mediocre shit. Seek out blogs. Follow specific music critics whose writing style you like. Subscribe to substacks. Give money to Stereogum. Scroll through the daily message boards on the indieheads subreddit. These are all real human beings. You're not gonna love everything, but it's coming from a real place.
If you let a robot choose your next song, or build you a playlist, then music is going to feel devalued. And you're gonna get bored.
That's my theory, anyway.
Post a Comment