If you pick an album for Record Club, you will get an "exit survey" on Friday afternoon, after the reviews have been published. This isn't to add more to your workload; I instead just want to provide space for the album picker to have the final say, if they feel like they need some sort of closure on the week. It's totally and completely optional. But I'd say that this has been completed like 80% of the time so far? Which is real cool. Thanks, y'all.
~~~~~~~~~~
1. Was there anyone who convinced you to consider a different opinion regarding the album itself? I don't think anyone had a dramatically different opinion ("this shit sucks" or something), but the variety of thought certainly made me consider elements outside the pov which I approached the album, which only deepened my enjoyment.
2. Was there anyone who you felt did a good/bad job at presenting their own views, regardless of whether you agreed with said views? Wouldn't it be kind of dick to say someone did a bad job presenting their own views? Maybe someday. I enjoyed everyone's reviews. There's a nice mix of syntax—longer-form emotional takes, pithier dissections, layered bullet point lists like my favorite powerpoints.
3. Were the reviews varied, or did this album elicit same-y opinions? What about that album made that true? Or do you think that this answer is reviewer-dependent and not album-dependent? See (1), kinda. In one way, the album elicits same-y opinions—most folks have the same idea of "what's going on here" and I think that speaks to TL's accomplishments putting together a purposeful, quality product. But at the same time there's a good bit of variety in the reviews because of the reviewers. The Joe-Pam-Nate trifecta (which, by triangulation, is usually my go-to for summation of nearly any RC album vibe) here hit home. The nature of who TL is and when this album came out and our relative ages puts this right in the camp of "how you related to it in 2003 is going to matter a lot 20 years later," and I was extremely jazzed to see three varied perspectives from that. I'm clearly no exception. I also very much agree with Galia's observation that TL is an amazing lyricist, punching way above their weight class, and Dillon's that the structure to an album (esp a 50 min one) is vital, often being the difference between good and great.
4. Did the variety of reviews justify the album choice? Would you choose a different album (yes/no) based on the reviews received? I was between this and the new B&S, I'm glad I went with this. In my rotation of new pop album (e.g. AnCo, Killers), esoteric bullshit album (e.g. Kaiyote, Lattimore), and older decently known album, the latter usually brings out the good. I'll save my Negativland review for off-cycle writing.
5. What can Record Club do differently to make your RC experience (especially as a weekly captain) a worthwhile one? Keep doing what you're doing, gang. Have fun. Yo quiero tacobell.
6. Any other takeaways you have from this experience? You know this is the first week I really keyed in to the cover photos JMK digs up. You googling these? I notice the one band mate has the same Wisconsin shirt on in two photos. Eyyy go pack go badgers fuck the bears.

No comments:
Post a Comment