Monday, June 20, 2022

Never Seen It, #77 of 200: The Grapes of Wrath

Whenever there is a list of 200 movies that I've never seen, I'll be there.


The Grapes of Wrath
1940
John Ford

Back when the George Floyd protests were happening around the country and in Philadelphia specifically, maybe even the same day when cops trapped protestors on the freeway and assaulted them with pepper spray and then lied about it, I got a text from a friend, asking if I was participating. I did not participate in the protests, and the truth is that I could not. I back the cause in spirit, but I had to make a choice. It was either be on the front lines of fighting injustice, or stay at home with my family. Actually, no, strike that—there was no choice for me, not really. I chose family. I always do.

Think about my decision however you want (and keep in mind that there can still be work done from home, such as donating money and voting appropriately, both of which I do regularly). Despite my fears, I don't think it's a matter of "talking the talk, but not walking the walk," though I could see an argument in favor of such an accusation. I'm just saying that there is a choice here. You can be right on both sides of that choice, but that doesn't mean the choice can't cause conflict, cause inner turmoil, however you wanna describe it.

The Grapes of Wrath, released in 1940, speaks to that choice even today. The pivotal, and most famous, scene is between Ma Joad and her son Tom Joad. Tom, having witnessed his friend Jim Casy get beaten to death for trying to organize a union, decides to save his family the trouble and get out there into the field for the real work. Ma Joad hates to seem him go, but she understand why. She's heard his speech. She gets that shit is broken, and that we need people to fix it. The parting is bittersweet.

But she also understands that it's important to keep things together at home (or "home," since the Joads are basically nomads throughout the film). She knows that if the family falls apart completely, then there will be nothing to come back to if the battle is ever won. And so she stays. She supports her son, which is why her "we're the people" speech at the end still hits like a fucking fist to the face. But she has to let her son do his work while she does her own.

This is my personal takeaway. I don't know if it's a good one, but it's a true one. Oh, sure, I could ignorantly spout words about how Tom Joad represents the working class today, how it's no surprise that Bruce Springsteen sang about him (Bruce being the consummate self-appointed representative of the blue-collar worker), how things are the SAME today as they were in the 1930s west as they are now all over the country, if not in the details then definitely in spirit and in inflation-adjusted dollar amounts.

In other words, I am a democratic socialist, and so of course The Grapes of Wrath is going to land like a fucking kick in the gut, and is going to allow me to bridge the gap between an "old Old Hollywood movie" and my own modern sensibilities in ways that I never knew possible.

And yet it also served to highlight my own shortcomings as a person. I will never be a Tom, and I will always be a Ma, and I am clinging to the idea that The Grapes of Wrath is saying that it is okay to be either one, to choose to be a Ma Joad if that feels like your calling in life. For as much strong talk as I lay down on this blog, I really do feel that this is true about me—I am going to choose to stay at home. The Grapes of Wrath both made me feel better about that (we need all types of people in this fight) and also worse (but should I be doing more?!).

I also lament the fact that our country has become so twisted that people like the Joads are much less likely today to even understand the predicament that they find themselves in. It is significantly more likely that a family from Oklahoma is going to respond to similar financial burdens by yelling about libtards and guns in inner cities and the rights of trans high school athletes and how our president single-handedly raised the country's gas prices, and so on.

There was no talk about "who's fault it is" in The Grapes of Wrath. I fear that today, there wouldn't even be a question about it. A poor Oklahomian family gets displaced from their farm? The response would be to lay the blame on "Let's go Brandon!" and etc.

In many ways, the powers that be have won, especially since the days of The Grapes of Wrath. Ma Joad spoke the truth when she spoke about "the people," but those in charge have successfully split those same people into factions, against each other. I can say something is their fault, they can say something is my fault, and all the while, gas companies earn record profits. You feel me? Like, the whole movie I'm thinking we're on the precipice of a revolution, and we're finally going to see someone like Ma Joad explode, but it never happens. She chooses to endure. But if she wanted to, she could rise up like her son Tom. But now, we have been bamboozled into rising up against each other. The Mas versus the Toms. We're all in the same goddamn position, and yet still we argue about petty bullshit.

The fact that I don't see a way out of it, this predicament we're in, spells doom for our country, most likely. If The Grapes of Wrath were remade in 2022, then Tom would've snuck off in the middle of the night, but not before disconnecting the cable wire on Pa Joad's TV, and meanwhile Ma Joad is in the car spewing hatred for socialism and Hilary and lamenting the fact that her son got roped up in the great left-wing conspiracy.

There has never been a single blog post involving politics that I've gotten to the bottom of and thought "man, I did a really good job with that." I always feel like the dumbest person in the room spouting the most ignorant bullshit on here. I am sorry for that. And I'm sorry for getting away from myself while discussing a classic film that took great pains to not label itself "red" during its anti-commie 1940s American release. 

Still, though, The Grapes of Wrath spoke to me in a way that many of its peers—Gone with the Wind, for instance—did not. Sometimes I talk about whether a film has "aged well," and I'll say right now that The Grapes of Wrath has not aged a fucking nanosecond. It is timeless, because capitalism is timeless, and the slow decay of society as caused by capitalism is timeless as well. 

So for as ignorant and uneducated as I am about this subject and about politics and about sociology and American history in general, I will say that The Grapes of Wrath spoke to me. This is exciting because it's an 80-year-old movie and no voice, however loud, has ever bridged that near-century gap to reach my ears like this film has. This is also terrifying, because it means that we as a society have learned nothing, and likely never will.

And if that's because I wasn't able to take an active role in the war against the decay, then that's something I'm going to have to accept. It is also something that I feel like The Grapes of Wrath is saying is okay. It's roping me in too, into its mission, and comforting me, saying that it's okay, that I am doing my part, even if it isn't active, even if I feel like I'm consuming forever and never providing. It's saying that this is how capitalism is designed to make me feel. It's saying that there is room in this new society for Ma Joad, and that we need to do what we can within our own personal limits if that is the case.

Bottom line: if we're still stalwartly sticking with the hypothesis that good art makes you feel something, then the anger, the shame, the sadness, the righteousness, the grief, and the dim ember of hope in the deepest depths of my soul that I felt in the aftermath of this film all contribute to the fact that The Grapes of Wrath was an excellent film.
 
GRADE: 4.5 pukes out of 5
 
NEXT TIME: Whew, let's lighten it up and talk about The Great Muppet Caper.

No comments: