"I can't believe it, the blog looks perfect. You watched these 400 movies I've never seen before for me?" "It wasn't us. I mean, think about it mom, is this something we would do?" "Good point."
1988
Stewart Raffill
Group E chose to watch Mac and Me. It was... something. More thoughts below, and then meet us in the comments for the most intellectual discussion that's ever occurred on Puke on Your Birthday.
~~~~~~~~~~~
Allison
The range of emotions I experienced while watching Mac and Me could be compared to the five stages of grief. We start the film in denial. How bad could it be? Surely it's not as bad as everyone says. Then we move swiftly to anger as the film's eponymous protagonist, and his grotesque family is introduced. Didn't this movie have Coke and McDonald's money, so why does it look so cheap?! I hate everything about these aliens and their bug-eyed, jowly faces! Whoever designed them should be thrown in prison! Why do they walk like that?! Do they not have kneecaps on the moon?!
Then we replace bargaining with bewilderment, and we'll spend considerable time there. How did this movie get made? Why does this minimum security space center (somewhere between Chicago and LA) not have an alien containment protocol? Why is Mac drilling holes in the wall and cutting up the door? To what end, Mac? Are these aliens related to humans? A missing link we didn't know was missing and would prefer to un-know? They're human-shaped, after all, but graciously evolved without external genitalia; however, very unfortunately, with quivering butthole mouths with which to slurp up moon juice. And moon juice, we later learn, is equivalent to Earth Coke. Am I following this? The questions don't stop. Despite watching this film with what felt like laser focus, I missed the initial naming of Mac. Suddenly, everyone this naked whistling abomination has a name. When the fuck did that happen? It wasn't until the second viewing (yes, we watched it TWICE, the second time by way of the MST3K reboot) that we caught Eric describing him to his mom as "The MAC! Mysterious Alien Creature." Blink and you'll miss it. This movie demands your full attention.
From there, we'll skip over depression, it's a kids' movie after all, and transition suddenly and inexplicably to acceptance. It's a shocking shift, from revulsion to revelry, and it happens where all '80s dreams come true, McDonald's. In what I can only describe as the hyjinxiest of hyjinx, Eric stuffs Mac into a gutted teddy bear to bring him along to a stranger's birthday party (because he has to!), and at the McDonald's party, a full-fledged dance number breaks out. Stirred by the music and infectious energy, Mac shuffles and shambles across the counter, backed up by the most enthusiastic Micky D's cashiers ever recorded. It's a baffling, chaotic, incredible scene. From here on, I'm locked in. Whatever absurdist farce this film wants to throw at me, I'm game. A frenetic wheelchair chase scene, great. A whimsical road trip, let's go. A cave full of dying aliens, why not! A tense police stand off, wow! A dead kid, okay, this was a choice. A kid brought back from the dead with the power of alien magic and maybe friendship, fuck yeah! So confident were the filmmakers that this film would merit a sequel that, in the final shot, as Mac blows a big pink bubble with his puckered face rectum, it reads, "We'll be back!" Unfortunately not. Ah, there's the depression.
A confession, I've been stalling. How do you rate a movie like Mac and Me? Should I base it on the quality of the film? The script, the acting, the grotesque puppetry/animatronics? It's a bad movie, sure, but it's not unwatchable. Or do I go against my better judgment (and film studies minor) and base it on the experience and the lasting impression? I had a blast watching it (both times). I haven't stopped thinking about it. I've been using photomoji of Mac to respond to all my husband's texts. And if I'm being honest, I'd probably watch it again.
5 out of 5 cans of Coke, which, as we all know, mimics the liquid inside the moon.
~~~~~~~~~~~~
Pat
There is only one commandment in filmmaking: Thou shall not be boring. A movie must make the audience feel something, be it joy, sorrow, disgust, arousal, whatever. Measures of whether a film is "good" or "bad" are ultimately less important than whether it provoked a reaction—any reaction—in its viewers. The fastest way for art to find itself in the dustbin of history is to be unengaging and therefore forgettable.
By virtually all measures, Mac and Me is a bad, bad, bad movie. The story is plagiarized, the special effects are subpar, and the shameless product placement siphons out any goodwill the characters create. But holy shit, this is not a boring movie. It responds to the maxim "Fiction has to make sense" by boldly asking "But what if it didn't?" I'm going to be thinking about Mac and Me forever. I've already rewatched the McDonald's dance scene since I've started writing this.
What was the emotion I felt most while watching Mac and Me? You guessed it: fear! I've seen horror movies accidentally turn out as comedies, but this is the first time I've ever seen a family comedy come out as a horror. R.J. Louis seems to have assembled a team of horror auteurs while trying to make an E.T. knockoff for McDonald's. Imagine Hereditary if it was shot like The Goonies. That's Mac and Me. And Roland Emmerich owes somebody money, because Mac escaping from the lab is indistinguishable from the alien autopsy sequence in Independence Day.
The driving force behind this unceasing horror? The aliens. The aliens. The goddamn aliens!
I could not look away any time they were on screen. My eyes were glued to TV, from the acid trip version of 2001: A Space Odyssey opening, to the final scene where they're dressed like a mutant family from Fallout. These aliens are the visions I would see if I was doing a Jacob's Ladder. Everything about them is wrong, from the off-putting hip swivel when they walk, to the lifeless eyes, to the aneurysm-inducing whistle language.
Mac and Me doesn't just fall into the Uncanny Valley. It tries to jump it on a motorcycle Evel Knievel-style, crashes into the cliff on the far side, and plummets to the bottom like Homer into Springfield Gorge, hitting every unsettling nook and cranny on the way. All the dogs in the neighborhood chase Mac because they instinctively know that he stands in defiance of God's creation and must die. When I see the Mac family, two million years of evolution tells me that danger is afoot. It's thrilling.
The hideousness of the puppets is the Rosetta stone for understanding every other creative decision in this film. The team behind Mac and Me apparently escalated from "There are no bad ideas in brainstorming" to "The first idea we brainstorm is what we're doing, no take-backsies."
"What if the aliens look like the Christian devil, but with buttholes for mouths?" Done.
"What if we stage an elaborate dance sequence that both advertises our corporate sponsor and emphasizes how much the main character can't walk?" Absolutely.
"What if Coca-Cola brings aliens back to life?" Totally. Eat my ass, power of love!
"What if we kill the boy with a fucking shotgun?" Only if it leads to a massive explosion, which the Mac family can emerge from in one of the most chilling visuals ever committed to film.
![]() |
| "We've come to take his soul to Hell." |
The movie ends with the promise/threat "We'll be back." This is wrong on two counts. First, no sequel was ever made. But in a greater sense, the Macs can never return because they never left. They will always be with me. Mac and me are bound forever.
Pat's Rating: 👽👽👽👽👽
5 out of 5 alien faces burned onto the inside of my eyelids
~~~~~~~~~~
Joe
I was primarily familiar with the decades-long inside joke on Conan O'Brien's various talk shows. It is probably other people will mention this in their write-ups, but I'll continue just in case. Whenever Paul Rudd came on to promote whatever project he had worked on, he would tell Conan he wanted to show a clip, and then, instead of showing the promised clip, would show a clip from Mac and Me. The same clip, every time. I don't remember why I know about this running joke, because I've never sat down and watched Conan's show(s) on purpose. It was probably some reddit TIL whatever. I'm no fan of late-night talk shows, but I am a fan of the running joke, and I appreciate a good one when I see one. Maybe you've noticed a few on this blog. I don't know if any of them are as funny as Ant-Man showing Conan a clip of a kid in a wheelchair falling off a cliff, but they still make me laugh, and that's why I attempt to keep them going. So anyways, that's why I had Mac and Me on the list originally.
But as I watched it, a thought occurred to me that maybe I had read about this film before. Certain film moments that rang a bell in the deep recesses of my mind, e.g. when the alien family pulls a gun in the grocery store. I don't know if I've written about this anywhere before, but in the early days of the internet, I was a fan of a website that wrote these long elaborate essays on bad movies. They made me laugh. The website, if I recall correctly, was Something Awful. I don't know if the website exists anymore. I think I tried to look it up at some point (I remember, even more vaguely than the Mac and Me piece, that there was something about some background character in the CLASSIC 1993 film Super Mario Bros., and you can understand why that would interest me now, since it's a RUNNING JOKE on PoYB, that movie), and it was maybe a little more maga than I was comfortable with? Don't quote me on that.
Anyways, I found the thing that I'm 90% certain is what I read at the age of fifteen. I had a tough time reading it, because it's not as funny as I remember. If you're gonna go down the road of "explaining the movie while making fun of the flaws of that movie," then you gotta bring your A game. Why waste time on some bullshit that a stranger wrote about this film in 2002 when clearly our very own D. Pat is going to do the same exact thing, possibly in this very blog post below my words, here in 2025? I don't know for sure that Pat was a reader of Something Awful in the mid-'00s, but I'd put money on yes. There's a certain way of writing that is spawned from internet snark culture that Pat and this other writer both exhibit. I think it's hit or miss. I think that Pat is all hits. Shame Mac and Me isn't a meme.
ALL THAT TO SAY that I am typically a bit squeamish when it comes to the idea of "bad movies for fun." I think there are plenty of bad movies out there, and I think Mac and Me is one of them, but I just take pause at the idea of a critical dogpile, that's all. No offense to anyone who is relishing the opportunity to take a dump on this thing today, because I'm sure whatever you write is going to make me laugh. And who knows, on another day, maybe I'd be joining you. But for whatever reason, I can't bring myself to do it today. I instead feel this innate desire to defend the thing. Even though there's no defending this piece of shit.
It feels more interesting to me to name the positives of a movie, and it's frustrating when there aren't any. That's why, for moments such as these, I typically find myself saying that the reaction itself is the positive part of the experience. The fact that we can laugh at this movie means that we were happy, at least for a minute or so, right? When Mac came out of that house in a teddy bear costume, I almost fucking died. Just absolutely stunning plot workaround right there. Get this fucking alien into the McDonald's dance sequence, no matter what! We can agree that this is bad. The agreement, and the ensuing comradery, is something that I will argue is a POSITIVE about this film itself. Allow the context to prop up the text. There's no need to insist it sucks. That can't be true, because we're all having a good time watching it. And if you are huffing and puffing about how much you HATED it, then you gotta talk to your therapist.
Still, yeah, okay, sure, very bad. I most recently noted my feelings on this particular subject during the Jacob's Ladder discussion, but probably my most hated movie trope of all time is when a character sees something fantastical, and everyone around him thinks that he's CRAZY. Jacob's Ladder subverted my expectations in that regard, but boy, Mac and Me does no subverting of any kind. Just your classic story of a kid who sees an alien and spends 2/3rds of the movie being told that he DIDN'T see an alien. I hate it. There are so many fucking reasons that this mother should have believed her child, but she didn't; there are so many fucking ways to get the people around you to believe you, but the child attempted none of them. That's because the plot REQUIRED everyone to be an idiot. I hate it! I hate it!
See? That's not as fun, talking shit. Let's now play a little game of "pull thematic value out of my ass," which is the game I love playing with movies that most likely have no actual thematic value. Let's say a bowlegged alien held a gun to your head in the canned goods aisle of the local Shoprite, and made you say what the MESSAGE of Mac and Me was. What would you say? Besides yelling "he's not going to hurt anyone!!" over and over even though he's probably going to hurt someone, I would probably say something like: "this is the story of outsiders who form a bond."
Actually, here's something that's impressively underplayed in this film. Eric's physical handicap is treated very normally. This isn't a story about POOR WHEELCHAIR KID FEELS SAD JUST LIKE THE ALIEN BABY. But I do think that the implication here is that Eric feels some sort of empathy for the alien, because he too feels alien sometimes, surrounded by the able-legged individuals of his world. And maybe it hurts him, for his mother to consider him crazy, since that same mother has probably spent the vast majority of this kid's life impressing upon him that he is NORMAL even though he is in a wheelchair, don't you DARE think differently, son, you are normal, the world is your oyster, you can do anything that your peers can do.
But of course, none of this is made even remotely clear in the film, which makes me think that the filmmakers didn't consider it to be all that important, this particular theme. Which is a shame. Total missed opportunity, I think. So it goes with bad films. They are bad because they piss away any potential they had. There was potential here. Instead, we have to make up our own joy, by watching Conan compilations, and playing make believe with the cinemaspeak.
I can't go the full nine yards and stand up to defend this movie as misunderstood. It's not. It's bad. The misunderstanding comes from the idea that the ONLY reaction to watching this shit should be "wow, this is bad." This isn't Something Awful. This is Puke on Your Birthday. There's more to watching movies than that. Go out and find it.
GRADE: 2 pukes out of 5
I did it, ma! I got to the end of my write-up without mentioning any Spielberg film, any product placement, or the fact that this movie's wide-released edit tried to pretend that Eric wasn't killed by police officers, who no doubt faced ZERO repercussions for shooting an unarmed kid!
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
GROUP AVERAGE GRADE: 4 pukes out of 5
See you in the comments. Comment five times and I'll send you a free and delicious Big Mac®.
(NEXT TIME: Inglourious Basterds, which is purposefully misspelled, which means that the Film Club list has had the incorrect spelling this whole time—it is now fixed)



16 comments:
I actually never got into Something Awful. Though I did spend a lot of Obama's presidency reading Cracked, which was Something Awful's younger, woker cousin.
If I had gotten really deep into Something Awful, I'd probably be a totally different person. Like, Undersecretary of Homeland Security or some shit.
Celebrating 1500 days in a row of Puke on Your Birthday today. I can think of no better way to celebrate than to reflect on the major motion picture film Mac and Me.
Thank you for clarifying! I honestly don't know a lot about the world of the internet in the early 21st century, so I defer to the expert on this blog (you). Good to know that Something Awful was less woke, and good to know that whatever movie reviews I was reading back then didn't make a political impression on me.
I saw a political commentator one time say that sacrifices need to be made to protect the 2nd amendment, and that it was acceptable for kids to be shot and killed if it meant that we kept our rights to own guns. I wonder what that guy thinks about Eric getting shot by police and brought back to life by aliens. Somebody call that guy up and ask him! I forget his name, but somebody on here probably knows who I'm talking about.
Editorial note: I usually put these write-ups in order from least words to most words (it's just a matter of aesthetics, I think the blog post look nicer when the write-ups gradually grow as you scroll). I use wordcounter dot net to count the words for me. It originally told me that Allison's and Pat's write-ups were the exact same number of words, which is crazy. Then I deleted Pat's alien emojis, and that somehow increased the word count by two? Maybe the emojis blocked the two other words on that line ("pat's rating") from being counted? I don't know if anyone actually cares about the order of the write-ups, but this felt like it warranted an explanation. Two great write-ups, P.S.
I stand by my own personal grade for this movie, but I like the fact that I was the only person who didn't give it a five out of five. The grade scale is not standardized, and it doesn't have to be. If loving the act of laughing at a terrible movie is enough to push it up five pukes instead of two, then I back that decision completely. Will any movie we watch in Film Club ever earn a higher Group Average Grade than Mac and Me? Only time will tell.
Actually, I'm curious, let me quickly round up the group average grades for all the group write-ups we've done so far.
Mommie Dearest: 2.875
Barry Lyndon: 3
Alice Doesn't Live Here Anymore: 3.55
Coffee and Cigarettes: 3.1
Bridge of Spies: 4.33
Seven Samurai: 3.9
Pollock: 3.5
Dogville: 3.33
Jacob's Ladder: 2.875
Love & Basketball: 4
Deliverance: 3.16
Nashville: 3.88
Cooley High: 3.33
Okay, so Bridge of Spies beat Mac and Me, and Love & Basketball tied it. I forgot about those grades. This is Spielberg's revenge for the E.T. rip-off.
What are some good moments of this movie that weren't mentioned above? I'm partial to the scene where they attempt to suck Mac up in the vacuum and the little girl rides the vacuum on the walls and ceilings.
Tough to beat the teddy bear reveal, though.
There's a whole book about it if you want to know more.
Here's the same explanation in meme form
Oh WOW, what the fuck, man. You weren't kidding. If I expected a lot of people to read a blog post on blogspot about Mac and Me, I would be afraid that my mention of it was signal boosting that site.
I wonder if this is why I can't find any mention of the 1993 Super Mario Bros. movie's boombox guy meme on the internet, even though I am 99% sure I didn't make it up—maybe it was on Something Awful, but a lot of that site's content got wiped at a certain point due to the political circumstances?
The citizenship ceremony. What an insane detail to end on.
I just want to say that it's been quite some time since I've watched such a bad movie and been thoroughly entertained. They truly don't make movies like this anymore. Also, I want to shout out the score which was composed by Alan Silvestri, who composed the score for a few of my favorite movies (Who Framed Roger Rabbit, Back to the Future franchise). My last thought is, with such a presumably large budget (McDonald's Money), why are all of the effects and the alien designs so mediocre?!
That last question is a good one! I was thinking about this recently. If I win the powerball and took that $500mil post-tax lump sum, and wanted to make a movie, could I do it? I could, technically. But it might not be GOOD, because money only goes so far. You gotta be in the industry, you gotta know people, you gotta be familiar with which talent is gonna be a right fit for your project. I wonder if McDonald's and Coke threw a lot of money at this shit and thought it was enough.
They were immigrating "THE RIGHT WAY"
Hacksaw Ridge is a fairly recent (9 years old) terrible movie that I laughed all the way through. At one point Andrew Garfield David Beckham's a grenade and is relatively fine after.
Post a Comment