Wednesday, September 24, 2025

Never Seen It #255: The Watermelon Woman

That's what you have to blog about. She paved the way for kids like you to run around makin' blog posts about the past and how we lived then and 400 movies we'd never seen before. Please, PoYB, make our history before we are all dead and gone. But, if you are really in the blogging family, you better understand that our family will always only have each other.


The Watermelon Woman
1997
Cheryl Dunye

Now here's one I've been thinking about for a while since I've seen it. So many pieces of my own world were explored, and so many aspects to worlds I am absolutely not a part of were explored too, and the collision of those two worlds, for me, made The Watermelon Woman pop.

I'm talking about the Philadelphia-ness of it all. Cheryl Dunye (the film's director, writer, and star) grew up in Philly and went to film school at Temple. I didn't know this was the case prior to watching, but immediately discovered Philly in the opening shots of I-95, easily recognizable even from footage 30 years ago. And Dunye immediately revealed herself as of the same mind when she said, with wonder and amazement and sincere appreciation, "look at the urban decay," when showing footage of either North or West Philly. You could tell that she saw the beauty in these neighborhoods just like I do while I'm driving around this city for work. This wasn't tourism, this was showing a deep and very real appreciation for the best city on earth1.

I'm talking about its place in the New Queer Cinema canon. I loved how there was a focus on the protagonist's part on figuring out who in her life was "part of the family" and who wasn't. I didn't pick up on the term "family" at first, but eventually it hit me that she was referring to both LGBTQ in general and Black lesbians specifically. Being who I am, I would not necessarily be welcome in many of the spaces that Dunye's fictional counterpart inhabited throughout the film, which makes sense to me, but it also makes sense that I would be thrilled to have access to those spaces and explore through this movie. I got to learn more about my world by learning about their world, if that makes sense.

I'm talking about being passionate about movies, which, as shown in The Watermelon Woman, both reflects and refracts my own experiences. I know too well these days the idea of obsessively watching film and never seeming to get tired of exploring different worlds that movies provide. But I don't have any idea how that passion would unfold while working in a video rental store, and I never will. I love movies and I organize a film club and I'm still much closer to the start of my journey than the end of it, but I am nowhere near getting tired of watching movies and thinking about movies and writing about movies. I have no idea how this would be affected by being surrounded by movies constantly, to literally work in movies (rental store, not filmmaking, but that too!). Maybe the spark would arrive at an even more rapid clip, like it does for Cheryl.

I'm talking about the acting, and how it was kinda bad! But also, and much more importantly, how the acting felt real in a way that has more to do with context than text. There was a purpose to The Watermelon Woman, right? A tribute to Black actresses in classic movies, what it looks like to be curious and a little bit obsessed, an honest look into a niche community of lesbian women of color in a large city. I don't think good acting is necessary to achieve those goals. And I think that it would have even been antithetical to the purpose of the film to hire great actors. These are, instead, real fucking people, and even if the acting is bad, the fact that these are clearly real humans who are clearly struggling a little bit to act on screen paradoxically makes the acting good, or at the very least excusable.

I'm talking about the idea of being naturally curious about one's world, and finding joy in the dogged pursuit of knowing that world better. I made a joke in my Letterboxd review that "Grannies Gone Wild" featured all my Watermelon Women, in that I saw something in this piece of art that fascinated me for reasons that I couldn't at first explain, and made it a mission to learn more and more about this art, and apply the lessons learned to my own world, etc. It was sincerely exciting for me to see how excited Cheryl got the deeper she went into figuring out the story of Fae "The Watermelon Woman" Richards. And I empathized hard with the idea that she was going to find some answers but that she would also never, ever know all the answers, and she would just have to live with that.

I'm talking about the idea of this movie blurring the line between fiction and non-fiction. Cheryl Dunye made a movie called The Watermelon Woman, and in it plays a character named Cheryl Dunye who is making a documentary about the Watermelon Woman. Purposefully not knowing anything about the filmmaker or the film going into this thing, I sincerely did not know whether it was a documentary-fictional-movie hybrid or a straight-up fictional drama. I had no idea whether the Watermelon Woman was real for Cheryl Dunye the director or just Cheryl Dunye the character. The truth wasn't revealed until the end, but I absolutely adored the way those lines were blurry throughout. Were I to eventually make my own art instead of twist existing art to my own purposes on this blog, I would remember a film like this, and take heed on how to walk that line, and use my own experiences to make something that is both technically fictional but also very, very real.

And in that vein, I'm talking (again) mostly about how this film felt to me like it was breaking the rules of filmmaking. It was short, it was loosely structured, it involved real people performing as not-really-real people, it haphazardly switched tones between documentary and rom-com, it took place in a city where big movies don't normally take place, it took place in real spots within that city that movies don't normally show in any city. It was the first feature film directed by a Black lesbian! C'mon, this is an important movie by that metric alone, let alone all the other shit I wrote about in this blog post. I don't know if I actually loved it while watching it, but I was definitely appreciating what it was trying to do as I saw it happen, and I honestly haven't stopped thinking about it since. So: good movie.

GRADE: 3.5 pukes out of 5

NEXT TIME: We had the Sunrise: A Song of Two Humans Zoom last night! The discussion post is up tomorrow!

1 It's been still more days since I wrote this, and a thought occurred to me between writing it and publishing it. That whole deal with the urban decay thing has really stuck with me. I was contemplating it as I liked to post-rock and spent a whole El ride staring out the window at my city below. At first, I thought that the observation in the movie by Cheryl Dunye was somewhat of an aside, but now I'm thinking that maybe the thought was germane to the movie as a whole. "Beauty in urban decay" implies that something beautiful is springing forth from something ugly, right? Something about a crumbling abandoned building strikes you as new and unique and thus it appears beautiful, but only because you were looking for it, and you made it so. And maybe this is similar to what the quest for info about the Watermelon Woman entails as well. The fact that Black actresses in Old Hollywood were pigeonholed and given derogatory roles and lines of dialogue and in some cases not even credited under their real names, that's some ugly shit. But then you see a movie with one of these actresses, and you're captivated by their performance like Cheryl Dunye was, and the beauty that you see in that comes from a not necessarily beautiful situation, ya know? The Watermelon Woman does an incredible job examining the juxtaposition there.

No comments: