Saturday, September 20, 2025

RC@5: Purple by Baroness

Record Club covered this album five years ago. Joe and Nate gave it another listen this week. Here are their thoughts.


Purple
Baroness
Week 85: September 13-19, 2020

Nate

Five years since Purple and in that time Baroness has released its least important album (Gold & Grey, which sounds like it was recorded inside Lars Ulrick's drum set circa St. Anger) and its most medium album (Stone, which had some joints on it). Depending on how you feel about Yellow & Green, this is either a band with many great songs and no great albums, or a band with many great songs and one great album. 

So Purple has remained fixed in time. The shit that whips ass still whips ass: "Shock Me" is an all-time Baroness track, as is "Chlorine & Wine," and I remain moved and impressed by "If I Had to Wake Up (Would You Stop the Rain?)," but these are the only songs I can name from this album without looking. Going back now, that's three killers (and "Kerosene," which is also good now that I remember it) out of ten songs. Rounding up, that's a .350 batting average, and that gets you into the All-Star game.

When this album came out, I still held hope that Baroness would ascend to a higher plane of metal music and bring the world with it. That never really happened, but they did—and continue to—excel at mid-heft prog rock, and that ain't nothing. 

~~~~~~~~~

Joe

It's nice listening to this with fresh ears. Purple was one of those albums that forced the discussion into genre territory, i.e. "this is a metal album and so what are your thoughts about metal?" Nate was good to pick it, since it really was a good entryway for anyone who wanted to explore. I didn't hit the pedal immediately, but I've strolled down the boulevard of metal occasionally over the past five years, and I liked most of what I saw. Could I have loved Sunbather if I didn't like Purple first? Probably not.

I hadn't thought about Baroness in a while, and then I saw that this album was coming up for its RC@5 anniversary. And then I saw a sad headline—the original drummer of Baroness recently passed away. ("Shock Me"'s chorus might be appropriate here, for all Baroness fans who heard the news.) His name was Allen Blickle, and he was only 42 years old. I read through it to see if he was on Purple. It doesn't look like he was. He left right before they started making the album that we would eventually cover for Record Club.

I'm not sure if anyone's noticed, especially because it's nestled in on the Supplemental Archives about 2/3rds of the way down, but I've been keeping track of Record Club deaths over the past few years. Blickle won't be on that list, because he wasn't on this album. If I recall correctly, a Slipknot drummer was in the same position when he passed, i.e. a former member of the band but not on the album we covered. Feelies drummer Anton Fier is on there, though. And the list has gotten a few updates in 2025, first with Brian Wilson, and then Ozzy Osbourne. There aren't too many overall, mostly because the vast majority of our artists are either young or dead already.

Why am I doing this? I don't know. It's not like it's a time-consuming commitment. It's updated hopefully no more than two or three times a year. What I hope for it, I think, is to tell every aspect of Record Club's story. Every week, we add someone's story to our own. Sometimes, those added stories end. We need to track the endings too. I celebrate art every week, and I mourn when the artists leave this earth. It's all part of it, man. Even a drummer who I've never heard drum. Purple meant something different that he wasn't a part of it. And now Baroness means something different now that he's no longer here.

Pretty good album, by the way. Doesn't sound like metal music at all.

No comments: