Tuesday, September 9, 2025

Never Seen It #249: Catch Me If You Can

Two little mice fell in a blog. The first mouse quickly gave up and drowned. The second mouse wouldn't quit. He struggled so hard that eventually he watched 400 movies he'd never seen before and crawled out. Gentlemen, as of this moment, I am that second mouse.


Catch Me If You Can
2002
Steven Spielberg

I attempted to explain this in my Bridge of Spies write-up, but I remain unsatisfied. I have this overarching feeling about Steven Spielberg that I find that I have a tough time describing without sounding like a snob, or sounding like I hate Spielberg movies. It's quite the opposite. I've now seen thirteen films that he's directed, and I either really like or straight-up love all of them. There is a "but," but it's a soft "but." I just... I never get the sense that Spielberg is operating on any level under the surface. The surface, as he constructs it, is beautiful, and occasionally awe-inspiring. There is no one better at creating movie magic based purely on the visuals on the screen and the lines of dialogue being performed.

I was thinking Spielberg when I was watching the Billy Joel documentary (you can find other thoughts about this rock doc elsewhere on the blog, I won't pull your chain too much in this Catch Me If You Can blog post). Someone in the doc said, as neither a compliment nor as a criticism, that Billy Joel always writes lyrics exactly how he means them. It might have been Joel himself, now that I think about it. He said that he doesn't write in symbolism, he writes the story exactly how it is. That's bang on. Listen to something like "Allentown." There's nothing working below the surface there. The themes are obvious. It's a story. It's not symbolism. There are rich descriptions of the characters and time/place, but nothing has a figurative meaning. It's all literal.

I think Spielberg works in the same way. The story doesn't show something but refer to something else, or mean something else. The story is the damn story. I'm not saying that it's completely devoid of symbolism, of images that mean something deeper. "Allentown" had a line that goes "Filling out forms, standing in line." The line isn't about standing in line, it's about the willingness to sign up to enter a World War as a soldier, so restless is life in a small town. But you don't have to work for that shit, you know what I mean?

You can compare this to any number of things in a Spielberg film, but since we're supposed to be talking about Catch Me If You Can here, then, I dunno, let's use the Christmas phone calls as an example. DiCaprio's Frank Abagnale Jr. is half clear and half shady when he's mumbling to Tom Hanks's Carl Hanratty on the phone, talking about his crimes on an "anonymous" call. Clearly, the scene is meant to show that Abagnale is lonely, that he subconsciously feels bad about what he's doing, that he's searching for something and all those fraudulent checks aren't scratching the itch. It's not a phone call literally about the New York Yankees, ya know? But then here's the thing: the deeper meaning isn't for the audience to figure out. Hanratty himself immediately figures out the deeper meaning. "He wants to be caught!" Hanratty announces to the viewers of the film. It's all right there on the surface, all the answers, thrillingly delivered to you.

And like Billy Joel and his self-assessment of his own lyrics, I am saying all this about Spielberg as neither a compliment nor a criticism. It's just an observation. And it something that allows me to radically adjust how I have recently been watching movies, and put myself into a lower gear. I really like when I watch a deep, dense film, and get to parse through it and figure out for myself what the fuck it all means, and then take what I think it means and apply it to how I feel and I how I view the world. That's a cool process and I like it and I get the most satisfaction from movies when that happens. There are other times when I can adjust that gear and coast along watching Leo and Tom chew scenery. Both ways of viewing film make me happy. I liked Catch Me If You Can, maybe even loved it. It was so goddamn fun! But at the end of the day, I feel like Spielberg movies are by and large out of step with the type of films that I have been trying to watch in this project, Never Seen It, where I attempt to teach myself how to get the most out of the Film Watching Experience.

Or... maybe Steven Spielberg is just so goddamn good at what he does that he's simultaneously making these entertaining popcorn flicks that appeal to the widest possible audience while ALSO leaving lots of room to dig deeper than I normally would have to to find that emotional meaning, if I really wanted to do it. Pam said she listened to a podcast the other day for the 50th anniversary of Spielberg's first blockbuster, Jaws, and on it (she tells me, since I would sooner get bitten by a real shark than listen to a podcast), they tried to discuss anything that they believed had never been discussed before (Jaws, being a classic, has had a lot said about it already). I appreciated that. I appreciate the effort that the audience is allowed to make to pull meaning from a film. We saw that in the Zoom meeting about the thoroughly average Wise Guys, in which we eventually turned to having a deep discussion about friendship and luck and achieving the American dream, even though I'm not really sure that the film itself intended those subjects to be in the text of the thing.

And I could do it here, if I wanted to. And I definitely want to. I want to get to the point where I can have these sorts of thoughts (and, later, discussions) about any fucking movie that passes through the PoYB film ecosystem, regardless of quality, and regardless of intention of the filmmaker. I think if this were a Zoom, and we finally got through the weeds in terms of "was the acting good" and "here is some interesting IMDB trivia" and "#3 on the Hanks Ranks is pretty accurate here, maybe a little high," I'd probably want to talk about...

...how this is a movie about trying to find your place in the world. There's the obvious example of Abagnale, who is clearly pretty brilliant, but learned all the wrong lessons from his father about how to apply his brilliance in the real world, and who eventually stumbles into a good career path anyway. But this also applies to Hanratty, maybe even more so, since he's good at what he does but seems adrift in the world, and his relationship with Abagnale (first antagonistic, then eventually grudging respect, and finally comradery / mentorship) pulls his life back into focus, and gives him purpose. I liked how this was not a romantic film at all, but that it painted the picture of two people who were clearly meant to be together in some (non-romantic) way.

...or how deep the bullshit goes, even past the cement floor that the film constructs with its opening message of "inspired by a true story." This is a movie based on a book written by a man named Frank Abagnale Jr., who committed many frauds in his lifetime, and who then wrote a book about it. And we're supposed to take the movie at their words that it was inspired by true events, but then say that the author who is stating that these events are true spent the first twenty years of his life lying out of his teeth? There are, of course, allegations that the story of Frank Abagnale Jr. is completely bullshit, and why wouldn't there be? Honestly, I would love if this guy came out and said that none of it happened, that he completely fabricated the book. That would be incredible! Making bank off lies about making bank off lies! Now all we'd have to do is make a Catch Me If You Can 2 in which Tom Hanks is trying to catch a man who wrote a completely fictional book and stole all Steven Spielberg's money with it.

...or how this was so popular with audiences (itself possibly not true, and only based on the fact that there was a billboard with this movie poster on it in my neighborhood from 2002 until like 2006 at least, and I always just assumed it was because audiences loved it), and what that says about our bottomless interest in clever criminals and the various ways in which they get away with their crimes. Subconsciously, perhaps we're all jealous of Abagnale, in that we want to escape the droll humdrum of our lives and act out fantasies of being a jet pilot and a doctor and a lawyer with practically zero consequences.

In other words, how it doesn't really matter how "deep" it gets with Steven Spielberg, and how maybe just making a fun as hell movie to distract us from our daily lives and woes is really all we ever fucking need out of a movie, and nothing more.

GRADE: 4 pukes out of 5

NEXT TIME: Group E has acted like Abagnale and flimflammed us into watching Mac and Me.

No comments: