Wednesday, September 3, 2025

Tramps like Us: Darkness on the Edge of Town


It's interesting to explore classic rock discographies, especially for the really really big classic rock stars, because you have to sort of lean into the narrative a little bit. There's not much you can personally do to affect it in any way, it's already written in stone. There's a different thrill in discovering a modern-day artist for yourself and watching them grow; in this way, you're seeing the story written in real time, and can choose for yourself what words are used to tell that story. When you're exploring the music of someone like Bruce Springsteen, it's different. It's like you're examining ancient scrolls. There's room for interpretation, but most of the basic information is already there, permanently. (It will be interesting to flip this narrative when we get to Springsteen's 21st century output, but we're like a year away from that in this column.)

I got around to Darkness on the Edge of Town way later than you would think. It was only five years ago. The story of Bruce Springsteen was already established in 2020, so much so that Springsteen himself was on Broadway charging money to hear that story. I felt a certain way about the tone and structure of Darkness, but in terms of what that meant for the narrative, well, that's easy to find out, because it's all there already. Yes, this is the album in which the tales told switch from endless possibility to crippling despair. Yes, it was another make-or-break situation for Bruce, even after the wild success of Born to Run—the label fuckery, the motivation to prove he wasn't a flash in the pan, some mental health stuff probably. Yes, all of that stuff factored into how Darkness on the Edge of Town sounds.

That all comes from what I read about the album, though. In a vacuum, I don't know if I would've described this album as "tough and mean," because, even though the stories told are cynical, the way they are presented aren't necessarily so. You know "Badlands" even if you've never heard this album, and so you know already that this, a live concert staple, sounds almost celebratory, despite the lyrics. It's like "Thunder Road" in a dark mirror—there is hope here, but it's not on display, but instead buried deep, deep down.

What I'm saying is that I have trouble knowing the narrative just from the music, and it becomes harder to impose my own narrative on an album the further entrenched it is in the rock 'n' roll canon. There's no room for irony here. Like if some cherished indie rock star released a lyrically downcast album tomorrow, there's room to say "oh yeah, this is party music," and make it legitimately so, even if the artist didn't necessarily intend that to be the case. But I can't say that with Darkness. It would be too weird. It's all subjective, but music criticism moves toward objective the longer is sticks around. Opinions become facts. Tough to say that "Adam Raised a Cane" is a fun tune, when clearly, clearly it was not intended to be.

I think where I struggle is the idea that music can feel large and cathartic while also being sad music, and if that's the case, I usually focus on its largeness, and not the sadness. "Something in the Night" sounds huge to me. It's a ballad that swells during the bridge. It's desperate but it feels important too, Springsteen's pain palpable. That pain comes out like a scream during the outro. I'm acknowledging that it's not happy music, but I hear epic music and I become happy anyway. If that makes sense.

"Sad music played in a happy way" is not a new concept. I don't even know if that's how I'd describe even the biggest songs here. Would you call "The Promised Land" a happy song? It makes me feel good—it's almost like a compact "Jungleland" with harmonica taking the place of any former dramatic silence. But it might be a bridge too far to call it happy. I think it's just that fucked up way that an artist can be telling you something, something real bad, but you feel good because you get to witness the storyteller tell the story. To witness art, that's great! And that feeling can be all twisted up with the feeling of "this is a sad tale." That's where I'm struggling, I guess.

Not that it's a "struggle" to listen to Darkness on the Edge of Town. Not at all. I actually really appreciate what Springsteen is trying to do here. He's sad, right? He achieved success but he's looking back at where he came from and realizing that his success doesn't mean success for everyone whom he came up with. Everyone's still struggling back home, and the factories are closing. So, in response, he's trying to take the music that made him successful, and applying it to stories that look different, that look darker, because of that failure still surrounds him in tangible ways. Songs like "Factory" and "Streets of Fire" are odes to this juxtaposition. They are big songs, and they are about how the big songs won't save your soul.

Springsteen splits the difference just enough that I both love this album and also appreciate what he's trying to do. I'll always love Born to Run more, simply because it's more wild-eyed and innocent and celebratory. But Springsteen doesn't abandon that completely here, and that's what makes it special. You can still hear a song like "Prove It All Night" and connect it, musically, to all the tunes that came before it. But then also hear the dismay that permeates every song on here. My appreciation for this splitting-the-difference thing will make more sense when we get to Nebraska, and album that makes no such attempt to split any difference whatsoever.

But do you see how I'm locked in here? That's my main point today. There is no other way to write about Darkness on the Edge of Town than to write that it's musically full but still strips a few parts off in order to make the sadness sting. The established narrative makes this important. If this was Springsteen's last album, maybe we'd view it differently. But as it stands now, this is a step in the journey, and that journey is already pretty well known, and so if I'm listening to it 47 years after it comes out, then there's not much room for me to know anything other than that journey, and how I am able to view it. 

Song for the "Tramps like Us" mixtape: "Candy's Room"

No comments: