This song of the Man and his Blog is of no place and every place; you might hear it anywhere, at any time. For wherever the sun rises and sets, in the 400 movies you've never seen before or under the open sky on the internet, life is much the same; sometimes bitter, sometimes sweet.
1927
F. W. Murnau
Zoom: September 23, 2025, 9 PM to 10 PM
Participants: Allison, Brianna, Catherine, Frank, Joe, Sean E., Sean G.
There are some movies that are both—enjoyable to watch, enjoyable to discuss. Then there are other movies that are one or the other. (There are some that are neither, of course, but as we saw from our Wise Guys discussion, I believe that any movie can spur a good conversation.) I was curious to see whether Sunrise was going to be one that people enjoyed watching. There wasn't really any question whether it was going to be enjoyable to discuss. We had a good discussion, as always.
My own personal thought it that you probably need to be at least a little knowledgeable about how a movie is made, what makes the way the movie was made interesting and important, i.e. you gotta be in the know about film cinematography, to appreciate, in the moment at least, the beauty of Sunrise: A Song for Two Humans. The way the camera moves is something that you either see or you don't. I didn't, not at first. That's why I walked away from watching this movie thinking it was just okay. Reading about it and talking about it with my friends, I definitely appreciate it a lot more.
Here are some other thoughts shared during the discussion:
- But for real, how did they pull off some of these shots? Some examples given / wondered about: the scene with the cars in background and foreground as the couple walked across the street; the man walking through the marsh; the woman from the city appearing as a ghostly apparition; the pig, drunk.
- German Expressionism—how the focus is on the human emotion and what that means, as opposed to appealing to reason and logic and reality as we know it
- How we can forgive certain aspects of the plot—she sure did forgive him pretty quickly—because of that Expressionism, how it's not that she forgave him quickly, but that this is tracking the sequence of emotions, with no regard for time
- But that maybe it still rings false, despite that. Maybe we're not supposed to empathize with this dude, who pulls a knife out at a stranger during he and his wife's supposedly carefree youthful time together in the city
- Is this supposed to be a happy ending?
- Lots of other great technical aspects to this thing, e.g. the soundtrack matching up with what was happening on the screen, and the sound effects too
- The acting felt more real than what you might typically find it older movies, since it's usually an issue since old actors overacted by design, since they had to emote without dialogue
- Was the second half of the movie overkill? There was a climax in the wedding scene, and then a whole lot of fucking around.
- Was the man's violence "a sign of the times"?
- Who lived longer in real life, the baby or the pig?
- #11 on the BFI Sight and Sound list, #82 on the AFI Tenth Anniversary list. Is this a case of a film entering the canon and being gradually lifted higher and higher by critical gatekeepers, or is it really that good?
Sunny couldn't make the Zoom, but sent this in for the discussion today:
"Sort of weird and maybe a little overplayed as "universal" but I guess for 192x it's fine. Seeing a silent movie and the acting within makes things like Sunset Blvd and Baby Jane? have more cultural context. The dressing of the money lender slash witch lady was hilariously dated. The plot was sort of stupid but of course some lessons are universal: don't trust money lenders, don't trust flapper women, don't go on a 1-1 boat ride, don't trust barbers. Hope you guys have a nice zoom."
I feel like there is a lot more to say for this one, and if you feel that way, please hop in the comments. Operators (me) are standing by.
JOE'S GRADE: 3.5 pukes out of 5, probably bumped up a half a puke after talking about it and reading about it. That's how it goes sometimes. How about you? What are you grading this thing?
Thanks to all those who were able to make the Zoom! I really feel honored that people are there and into the discussion. I have a really good time doing this shit, and I wouldn't be able to if other people didn't care. So thank you! And if you couldn't make but still watched the movie, I'll see you in the comments.
(NEXT TIME: Only doing one solo movie next week, so it's gonna be Bride of Frankenstein.)

7 comments:
I will say that I am glad we didn't even have to touch on the "old movie = bad" point this time around. And I don't think that was just because Sunrise was critically acclaimed. I think Film Club is just growing and evolving. I think that's cool.
I missed out to attend a Phillies rain delay. But I did watch and enjoy the film! I'm sad I couldn't participate in the baby v. pig debate (I'm team baby but maybe I should let go of reason).
This movie left me technically impressed in the same way that "Citizen Kane," "Vertigo," and most James Cameron movies do. I guess it's more like the latter category in that the plot is whatever, but I'm fine to just be astounded by top-notch film making.
My letterbox thoughts if you wanna see:
https://letterboxd.com/samfrans/film/sunrise-a-song-of-two-humans/
https://letterboxd.com/samfrans/film/sunrise-a-song-of-two-humans/
Not sure if it came up in the zoom, but early films used a lot of practical effects and film manipulation. This is a great post of you aren't familiar with some of the techniques used at this time:
https://imgur.com/a/how-some-cool-silent-film-effects-were-done-wUAcl
I am happy to report that the baby, by all accounts, lived for a robust 70 years longer than the pig, so you're on the winning side there.
Yeah, agreed that it was technically impressive. Something that I talked about was feeling a bit behind on what even is "technically impressive" and being able to recognize it during a viewing of a film. I think that maybe I'm going to try to choose a movie at some point because of its reputation as a technical wonder, and really focus on that shit while watching.
These are all so cool! Wild how much you can do with some creativity. Really makes you hate blockbuster Marvel films' dependence on cheap-ass CGI bullshit.
I don't know (or don't remember) if we talked about specific effects, just kinda marveled at 'em. The Ebert review is surprisingly deep about all that. I think he watched the movie with film commentary by a guy who studied cinematography history of silent films or something like that, which is why that was his focus.
I think there is something to be said about some of the tracking shots in this STILL being impressive feats. Like it's not like it's become old hat used all the time in movies now. When it happens in a Boogie Nights, or Goodfellas, or 1917, people still marvel. 100 years later and it is still a technical accomplishment is just awesome.
Something that I never really think about that I read in relation to this movie was: the camera is fucking heavy! Or at least was 100-50 years ago. We as the audience probably take for granted that the camera can move around, but really, these fucking guys were somehow maneuvering a 100-lb contraption, and cranking that shit all the while.
Post a Comment