Tuesday, February 24, 2026

Tramps like Us: The Rising

A complete run-through of Bruce Springsteen's discography, written every once in a while by Joe.


In this column, among other lofty blogging goals, we are striving to provide the context for each Bruce Springsteen album. In the 21st century, Springsteen starts to make that task pretty easy. 

Not that I am personally familiar with all of his output from this current century (yet), but I have gotten a general sense, just from putting this column together, what lies ahead. I know that many, perhaps even most, of the official studio albums from here on out, are in response to something that was happening in the country or the world. We can thus easily label each LP with a statement like "this is the ___ album." I'm not presenting this as a good thing or a bad thing. It's just a choice in the art, to create meaning by using the art as a mirror, or a bullhorn, or as a thoughtful observer, or as a fist in the air, something like that.

That doesn't start here, and it doesn't stop here. If it stopped today, it would end with "Streets of Minneapolis." We would say that perhaps it started with... Darkness on the Edge of Town, and its fictional songs based on real-life pain, borne of societal ills? I don't know, let's put this question on ice, and let's just say that The Rising is an important step in the journey. Here, the music as a cultural and/or political response becomes explicitly so. The Rising is Bruce Springsteen's 9/11 album.

If you are a long-time reader of this blog, then you already knew that. The Rising has already been covered in this space, though in a different context—through the eyes of the music critic, as opposed to the anthropologist. I stand by most of my thoughts from my own review, mostly in that I think it's a great album, that it models its sound on The River, and that—crucially—it finds Springsteen in the thick of things for perhaps the first time in his life. In other words, Springsteen was singing about other people up until now, but because he was mourning those lost on September 11th just the same as the rest of us, The Rising ended up being truer to the core of his being than basically any other album so far.

The difference in today's blog post is where the story is positioned. Record Club is designed so that the artist's story is filtered through the blogger's own personal experience, and so the story of The Rising in that context becomes the story of getting drunk in Wildwood and talking about the greatest pre-COVID tragedy in our nation's history. Tramps like Us is designed to keep the focus and spotlight on the artist and his story, and so we now view The Rising through the lens of what we know about Springsteen's discography so far.

Equally as important to this being a 9/11 album, this is also a reunion album. Over the last four Tramps like Us entries (Tom Joad, Lucky Town, Human Touch, Tunnel of Love), we have traced Springsteen's exodus from the cocoon of the E Street Band. As we've noted, the separation was intentional. It's not that he needed to know whether he could exist on his own, he just needed to shake some mental cobwebs away, and the only way to do that was to become a different person. Step into another role. He couldn't be the bandleader, he needed to be the only guy (Randy Jackson doesn't count). The hero often wanders into the desert or forest alone in the second act. It is in the third act that he is reunited with those supports that he needed the most.

And so on this album, the E Street Band are folded back in. Something I think I misinterpreted about the reunion was that it didn't actually happen on The Rising. The reunion happened a couple years prior, during the official Bruce Springsteen and the E Street Band Reunion Tour, running from April 1999 to July 2000. It wasn't like I had previously supposed: Springsteen sees the Twin Towers falling to the ground and suddenly decides that he needs to gather back together his own personal Avengers to save the city and the nation, and so they all get back together and cut an album together. Nah, they were already friends again before the planes hit.

I think it's okay to bend the narrative a little, however. What's true about The Rising is that it was needed at this particular moment in our nation's history. Not literally, and not by everyone, but there was a certain type of human being that needed strong hopeful rock 'n' roll songs that were inspiring enough to feel like they could heal. The story that everyone knows (though who really knows if it actually happened) was that Springsteen was watching the smoky ash from across the river on 9/11 or 9/12 or whenever and someone rolled down their car window and yelled, "We need you now!"

Perhaps this fan could not get tickets to the tour a couple years prior. I'm kidding! No, I know what this fan meant. Not literally, Springsteen is not a firefighter, just a musician. But we need Springsteen and artists like him to inspire us in times of great sadness or hopelessness. It makes total sense that you'd feel like the world is crumbling around you and then you see Springsteen sitting on a bench by the river and you're like, holy shit, yes, this is what I need, I need music, I need art, I need this specific art by this specific musician, because it's made me feel a certain way in the past, like this bard speaks truth, and so why can't he too save us from the horrors that destroyed tall buildings right over yonder? I get it.

Not only that, but I think the idea of "coming back together" and "reunions," specifically in the context of Bruce Springsteen reuniting with the E Street Band, is especially powerful in light of the tragedy that they are singing about. These are songs about a nation who finds it within themselves to unite for a common cause, to together bravely face tomorrow. While singing those songs about unity, Springsteen and his band are exemplifying the very ideals they are singing about. They too have come together. The album ends with a plea to "come on, rise up, rise up." Such sentiments would feel empty if these artists didn't not come back together, after a long time apart, to make those sentiments.

The idea that Bruce would get the band back together for a reunion could, in some ways, be seen as a crass way to boost sagging ticket sales. The strength of The Rising is so that it retroactively justifies the commercial endeavor and twists it into artistry. Sure, they made money, but then they made art, and one probably wouldn't have happened without the other. On top of that, the strength of The Rising also retroactively justifies the critically vilified albums that came before it. There are many who heard Human Touch and couldn't understand why Springsteen was doing this with a bunch of scrubs, making a clearly inferior product. What The Rising proposes is that the bright vigorous homecoming of The Rising could never have happened without the quixotic journey through the dark woods of Lucky Town et al.

It even manages to explain The Ghost of Tom Joad, which is by far the farthest stylistic outlier of the discography so far. Like The Rising, Tom Joad speaks to heavy subject matter. Unlike The Rising, Tom Joad allows the heavy subject matter to drag it down into the murky depths. We mentioned last time how some of the music of Tom Joad had later been transformed in live concert settings. Almost certainly this is because of a revelation that Springsteen must have had sometime between the release of that album and the reunion tour of '99-'00—that most of the time, there is more power is loud joyful bombast than there is in quiet hurt sinistry. The Rising confirms it. "May your strength give us strength, may your hope give us hope, may your love give us love"—this is the chorus of an uplifting song about 3000+ bodies burning to the ground after an act of terrorism on home soil. And it is my opinion that his strength really does give us strength in that way.

For this reason, I'd like to offer a correction to my RC review, in which I named "Mary's Place" as a great song but a strange outlier, due to the fact that it is impossible to retrofit this banger into a song thematically speaking to the September 11th attack. It's just about a party! Where does it fit? In examining The Rising across the story of an artist and his band, and in the way that these leaders came together to save us from the horror that we felt within ourselves, and in the process turned themselves into heroes that would for now on address whatever ailed us as a nation through the power of song, together, I can now see that a song like "Mary's Place" fits perfectly. This is an album about resistance, it is an album about resisting together, strength in numbers. And joy is an act of resistance. Nothing says we're okay more than getting together with your loved ones and having a party.

When I previously said in that review that The Rising remakes The River, I meant it aesthetically. But now, I mean it thematically too. They have the same theme, it's just that the intention behind the theme is different. The River is a party because these people like to party. The Rising is a party because these people know that partying is the only thing that's going to save us.

I'm not familiar with the next four albums, and I'm very excited to see where this party takes us next.

Song for the "Tramps like Us" mixtape: "Further On (up the Road)"

3 comments:

Anonymous said...

I have enjoyed reading this series Joe, especially this entry. Looking forward to the final 4. Will you be breaking down Secret Garden from the Jerry Maguire soundtrack? I'm old enough to remember the radio edit of the song where they had dialogue from the movie "you had me at hello", etc. added between the verses. They did that shit all the time in the 90s, after the Oklahoma city bombing in 1995 they had a radio edit of "lightning crashes" by Live with news clips from the bombing added. Crazy times.

Anonymous said...

Oh this is Jeff J, FYI

Joe K said...

Thanks for reading, man! And thanks for keeping me on my toes about the ins and outs of this discography. It's a beast! I have seen Jerry Maguire but somehow missed the part where Springsteen has a song in there. I see now that "Secret Garden" is only on a Greatest Hits compilation, which I had no plans for in this column. But I probably should do something with the various loosies that the artist has scattered over a career. I have some time to figure that out.

I guess I remember those radio edits? Man, I'm going deep into the memory banks for that one. I have to keep this in mind when I come across it again. Thanks for the tip!