Saturday, December 13, 2025

Tramps like Us: Human Touch


I am told, by various sources, that Human Touch is Bruce Springsteen's worst album. However, since "worst" is relative, and this is Bruce Springsteen we are talking about, there was always going to be two scenarios that played here, listening to Human Touch for the first time. One, it was going to be really fucking bad. Or two, it was going to be lacking as compared to some of the best albums of all time, but still a decent album. I am happy to report that, with enough time, Human Touch has revealed itself to be the latter. It's fine. I like it. If it's the worst, that's only contextual.

I have a feeling that at least part of it—not all of it, I'm not being a fanboy or a contrarian here—is that this album is the first in which the E Street Band completely go away, and people are, like, offended by that. I get it. There is a secret sauce that makes Bruce Springsteen's best music so enjoyable, and it's hard to understand why the chef would purposefully fuck with that recipe. And it would be one thing if Springsteen was trying something different with his sound (maybe if the full album Streets of Philadelphia came out in 1992 instead of 2025, and in 1992 instead of Human Touch, people would've been more forgiving of the lack of E Street), but Human Touch largely sounds like Springsteen trying to reattempt the formula except with Randy Jackson in tow instead of his trusty cohorts. (Yes, that Randy Jackson.) It's not nearly as bad as it sounds, but it's also not the best decision that anyone's ever made.

In one of those same sources that claimed that Human Touch was the WORST, the description of Human Touch was that the songs largely sounded like parodies of Springsteen songs, in that every song had a chorus to shout out loud, that chorus was also the title, and that chorus was basically the entire song. E.g. "All or Nothin' at All" is a song that features Springsteen cathartically yelling "All or nothin' at all!" over and over. Or, an even worse e.g., "Man's Job" being comprised of Springsteen frantically yelling "Lovin' you's a man's job!" while Sam Moore of the R&B duo Sam & Dave also yells "It's man's, man's job!" in harmony. Once I heard this description of Human Touch, I couldn't get it out of my head.

But I'm also not necessarily complaining. I think "I Wish I Was Blind" is a good song, even though the title made me laugh out loud, after it was revealed that the chorus was "I wish I was blind / when I see you with another man." This actually does sound like a parody, but if someone did a parody like this, I'd be like, "oh fuck, this parody is frighteningly accurate." And I like shit like that. I met a new friend recently whose mom is the world's biggest Greta Van Fleet fan, so that kinda shit's been on my mind again recently. Does a parody cease to be a parody if the accuracy is so sharp that you can't tell the difference? Is Human Touch being accused of sounding like a parody because it's the same thing but weaker, or because Springsteen is actually trying something slightly new?

Maybe a little of both. Honestly, I think the big headline here is that Bruce Springsteen was just struggling with himself, what kind of artist he wanted to be, what kind of person he wanted to be, what his music should sound like versus what it could sound like, etc. There's value in this as well. It's pretty understandable that even if wild commercial success, Springsteen might feel like he's stuck in a rut, artistically. Jettisoning the E Street Band (and only temporarily, we now know) makes sense. He's trying different versions of himself. Not unlike shaving your head bald after a decade of receding hairlines. Maybe you don't like the look of baldness either. But it was worth a try. We are all performing micro-experiments on ourselves constantly, in a never-ending quest to answer the almighty question of "Who Am I?" Chalk it up to an experiment, this album. Its success or failure says nothing about the worthiness of the attempt.

So, the bottom line here is that you're gonna like Human Touch if you love Springsteen's art. It's not so far askew that you start asking questions. It's fine. It's good. I like it. Let's talk more about it when we reach Lucky Town, an album similarly derided, and released on the very same day as Human Touch.

Song for the "Tramps like Us" mixtape: "Roll of the Dice"

No comments: