Wednesday, February 18, 2026

Never Seen It #292: Oklahoma!

I don't know what to make of you! You've seen 400 movies you've never seen before! You're too purty to be a skunk! Too thin to be a snake! Too little to be a man, and too big to be a mouse! I reckon you're a blogger!


Oklahoma!
1955
Fred Zinnemann

Welcome to the box social! Let's see what everybody (except Jud) thought about this movie.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Stef

Let me just get out of the way that while trying to write this, I realized how boring this movie is. It's not a bad movie, and it's not that I didn't like it, but it was boring. The two most boring aspects: the plot, and the dance numbers. The plot was very basic, no real dynamic characters, no internal conflicts, and honestly pretty icky though unsurprising. But the function of the story wasn't to capture the audience, it was just the vessel for delivering the art, which this movie had a ton of. Maybe too much of. The dance scenes were good, the choreography and the performers were all clearly skilled. I just think if you cut the amount of dancing in half, there would still be too much dancing in this movie. Like, I get it, but I just got bored.

The music, the vocals, obviously slap sincerely hard. But what was good about this movie, the reason why I do think this is a good movie, were the visuals of the movie. The set design, costuming, and cinematography (and even the choreography, as greedy as the dance sequences were) were all really outstanding. The movie does a really good job of portraying vast and beautiful landscapes. The use of color in costumes and set design were a really nice contrast to the natural landscapes. The overall visuals didn't disappoint, and it was what kept my interest the most about the movie.  3/5

~~~~~~~~~~~

Sunny

♫Oh, what a beautiful MORNING!
Oh, what a beautiful day! ♫

OKLAHOMA! (©) 1955
[Press Start]

>You walk into Jud's cabin. It stinks worse than most things around here. It's dark but you can make out pinups on the walls

- [PERCEPTION] Comment to Jud about the nudie pics
- Ignore it.

>"Boy gee Jud this here girl's totally naked!"
>Jud nods. It's clear he doesn't know why you're here

- [INTELLIGENCE] Argue to Jud his prospects would be better in the next town
- [CHARISMA] Convince Jud everyone would like him better if he killed himself
- [ENDURANCE] Challenge Jud to a pig-hauling contest
- [STRENGTH] Fight Jud

>"Wow Jud, you own such nice rope! And look at the quality of this hook and rafter! Yeah, that'll do. Hey bud, have you ever considered how everyone hates you around here? But if you died tragically, we'd all be mourning you real hard"
>Jud looks at you incredulously. However, his face does soften, perhaps something from earlier in the day has weakened his resolve.

- [Heroic CHARISMA] Try singing a song about how nice it would be if Jud killed himself
- Try another approach

>"Oooooh Pooooor Jud, you're too young for the mud! Ooooh Jud your heart of gold, how can he be cold? Oh Jud, you're so serene!"
>"so serene..."
>(He's starting to sing along. It seems to be working!)

- Leave and let the song sit with Jud
- [STRENGTH] Strangle Jud as he's looking wistful
- [Heroic CHARISMA] Continue the song while subtly insulting Jud's way of living

> You and Jud get deep into the verse. The momentum of the spontaneous kill-yourself tune takes over all your facilities. Jud seems convinced. He also seems impossibly sad.

- Leave and let the song sit with Jud
- [Legendary CHARISMA] Launch into diatribe

> You start tearing into Jud, insulting everything about his appearance, odor, actions, totality of being. The zigzag of emotions over the last ten minutes is too much to bear and he becomes enraged. He shoots his revolver into the air. Sensing you pushed too far, you leave his cabin.
> Jud will remember this.

PURCHASE the full version of OKLAHOMA! for this and more including:
- Over two hours of action and music!
- Photorealistic Oklahoma land and sky graphics
- Made for console original score and adapted soundtrack
- Playable farmer and cowhand characters
- Sidequests including "Jud Hell" ballet dream
- Realistic prairie courtroom and peach picking physics
- Award-winning ostensible Americana plotline

Finally, a chance for mega fans of R&H and the Great Frontier to see their favorites come to life on the screen! Critics are giving it 2.5 out of 5 stars! Pre-order today!

~~~~~~~~~~~~

Kait

Oklahoma cowboy fashion

Surprised to say I enjoyed this film. Bit of a bright and wholesome spot in the long string of Sopranos episodes I've been watching. I had heard of this Rodgers and Hammerstein musical before, knew some of the songs, but never seen it on stage to have really any idea what was going on beyond being in Oklahoma and singing and dancing.

Even after watching it, the source of enjoyment is from that simple premise—here we are in Oklahoma, singing and dancing. I was a bit distracted, so didn't follow the plot too well. There's a dance, there's some contentious love triangles, there's beef between the farmers and the cow wranglers? Are those just cowboys? That's enough for me. More dancing please! 

The singing and the dancing regardless of the plot were so good and so fun to watch. I especially loved the dream ballet sequence. Such talented dancers and a creative and effective set design to illustrate the tension in Laurey's head. I do, however, find it a bit crazy that she needed to sniff that Egyptian elixir and experience an entire trippy dance dream sequence to realize Jud wasn't the right choice. I did enjoy, though, what this 1955 film used to show Jud as a deviant bad dude: nudey photos of women in his house, can-can dancers, trying to light the newlyweds on fire. Why did they let Jud even enter the auction for Laurey and her basket? Do not auction her off to a scary, violent man to raise money for a new school house. Aunt Eller eventually got her shit together with that and wouldn't stand for it. Curly for the win.

I loved the cinematography, the wide-open shots and the bright saturated colors throughout. The costume design was also wonderful. I especially enjoyed the cowboys' outfits at the dance because of the mixed patterns and textiles. Seemed like bold choices for 1955 that I wish I was wearing today. 

Finally, I think Ado Annie might be polyamorous. She's "just a fool" when the lights are low, can't say no to all these boys who wanna kiss her, and I'm pretty sure she said kissing is her favorite food. She's proudly smooching all the boys and sees no issue with it. In the song "All or Nothing" with her beau Will, he makes his intentions very clear—all or nothing with him, no other dudes. And she pushes back on that not sure she can commit to just Will. What a solid example of a relationship check-in, huh? Ado Annie also has an iconic line "I never think of nobody unless he's with me." As a chronic overthinker, oh how I love and long for that type of free brain space! What a fun little movie.

4 pukes out of 5

~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Joe

I don't know why I'm so harsh on musicals. Look through the film archives on PoYB and you'll see that I consistently rate movie musicals lower than any other genre. I usually lean on the idea of "was this necessary?" when considering the padded lengths of musicals to be the reason that I dislike this kind of stuff. I felt those old familiar pangs again while watching Oklahoma!, the desire to enjoy the fun, light foibles of sexually frustrated early-20th century farmhands but perhaps in 90-minute packages. Oklahoma! was the longest movie picked out of the dozen in Film Club Q4. Why? So we could watch Jud stalk Dream Laurey for like 20 minutes? It doesn't seem worth it.

But there I go again! For real, is that kind of thing worth it? The whole dream sequence? I think if another non-musical movie attempted such a thing, I'd be tripping over myself to praise that movie, but if it's a musical, then what, I'm all of a sudden worried about how economical it is? If I found a way to take a step back, I think I might find that I could find beauty in the dance sequence, all the set changes, the old-school movie magic of the soundstage reflecting how it must've felt on the actual stage of 1940s productions of this play, etc. "Kansas City" was similarly "unnecessary," and yet all that tapdancing was pretty joyful.

I think I just need to be able to see musicals through the lens of "we're just having fun here" better than I usually do. It really ain't that deep. There's no grander purpose beyond constructing a bare-bones plot as an excuse to do some elaborate singing and dancing. The song about cowboys and farmers getting along is fucking stupid, but the fight that it spawns is hilarious, and Aunt Eller's gun-totin' doubly so. It's not actually a matter of what is necessary, not when you consider shit like this. You could probably cut the entire character of Aunt Eller out, if we're talking what's "necessary" to the story, but a movie without Aunt Eller is a much worse movie. Or, like, did we really need Curly and Jud to pontificate on Jud's funeral for so long? Absolutely not, but if that didn't happen, then you wouldn't have had the immortal line of "He treated the rats like equals."

And if we're really leaning into the "we're just having fun" line of reasoning, then perhaps we don't need to think about the iffy sexual politics too much. Women were treated like property in 1906, who knew! 120 years later, we're required to understand that it was a different time and appreciate what has changed and improved, and what hasn't. Still doesn't make it any less discomforting, though. Laurey spends all day sleeping on her porch, her subconscious telling her very clearly which man she would prefer to be with, and yet the auction seen renders Laurey's feelings on the matter moot. Who cares what she wants! She's gonna go to the highest bidder anyway! Poor Annie's got it even worse. She would've really thrived in non-monogamous swinger scenes if she was alive 100 years later, but as it stands now, she's saddled with a doofus who wants to kiss other women but doesn't want his woman to kiss other men. The choice to make Annie have the worst singing voice was to label her as a slut, right? That's messed up. I say let Annie kiss as many boys as she wants, even after marrying Kansas City boy!!!

We're just having fun with it! I was surprised how many songs I was familiar with in this movie/play. Pam tells me that she was in a production of Oklahoma! at one point. She's not here as I'm typing this paragraph, so I can't ask her, but I'm assuming it was in middle school. But she is definitely to blame for why I was even a little bit aware of these songs. I know the phrase "Surrey with the Fringe on Top," but never once gave thought to what those words actually meant until now. Then I saw a surrey (light four-wheeled carriage) with the fringe (decorative border of hanging threads) at the top of the surrey, and it all clicked.

Did Curly need to sing so much about a surrey and its fringe? Probably not. But this kind of thing brings joy to those who like musicals, and as the years go on, I'm finding it harder and harder to deny their charms. Musical numbers don't need to exist in order for a movie to tell a story, but still, it's fun when they do. Movies don't need to exist either, ya know? When you start talking about what's necessary and unnecessary, you start to miss the point. We're all just trying to have a little fun. This was a fun movie. Bloated and too-long, but fun, for sure.

GRADE: 3 pukes out of 5

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

GROUP AVERAGE GRADE: 3.125 pukes out of 5

I didn't give the verdict yet! Not till the comments!

(NEXT TIME: Zoom for Blood Simple next Tuesday, 2/24, 9PM!)

12 comments:

Joe K said...

If you're seeing the pic of the flamboyant cowboy garb sideways, you're not the only one. When I edit the blog post, it looks correct, but the published blog post (on desktop and mobile) looks sideways to me. I don't know how to fix it. I am assuming that google's AI bullshit is "fixing" it or something. Enshittification comes for everything eventually, including blogspot.

Joe K said...

I appreciated that I wasn't the only one who thought it was too long but looked good. I appreciated that I wasn't the only one who thought that singing about the benefits of a man's suicide to that man himself was absurd in all the right ways. I appreciated that I wasn't the only one who thought that Annie should be known as cinema's first polyamorist. Good to know that great minds think alike here.

Frank said...

I hate that I would play the Oklahoma! RPG

Joe K said...

A line that I thought was pretty poignant that I didn't work into my write-up was from Aunt Eller, something along the lines of: "You gotta get used to all kinds of things happenin' to ya... ya gotta be hardy." Basically saying that you take the good with the bad, don't let the bad drag you down. I dunno, that felt earned, when she was saying that to Laurey.

Joe K said...

Saw this on Letterboxd, thought it fit in well with the thoughts here about the ickiness of women being bought and sold in a movie with fun singing and dancing:

"The contrast between Jud and Curly and Will and Ali is a blend of masculine tropes, somehow blending patriarchal views with a wiser understanding, but still coming out of it expectedly reactionary. At least Jud's the villain. Stripping away these gendered divisions, viewing this solely as color, movement, and song, it's a celebration. Still, it's overshadowed by its place in the canon of a genre glorifying the white conquest of indigenous lands, of individualistic ideals, of macho double standards."

Joe K said...

I was googling "oklahoma rpg" and accidentally came across this reddit thread instead. Apparently in a recent Oklahoma! revival, they focused on how Jud's loneliness was reinforced by Curly's bullying, and how his murder and subsequent sweeping under the rug were an indictment on the U.S. judicial system. Interesting stuff!

Joe K said...

Also, I confirmed with Pam that she was in a middle-school production, and that she played the part of Gertie Cummings, who is the girl with the laugh and whom Ali eventually marries. I would kill to have seen middle school Pam do that silly laugh on stage.

sunny said...

Boring but looks and sounds great is not the worst consensus opinion to land

sunny said...

It probably speaks to my naivete and lack of social more knowledge, but I couldn't not apply my modern idea of a bachelorette auction? We watched the movie and read "lunch with a girl" as just "lunch with a girl," despite the contextual implication being you're buying "lunch with a girl forever" and I found that confusing, yet, I guess, more true to life in a way.

A guy giving away his entire life savings (second only to the Iranian merchant), thousands of dollars in today's money, just to have lunch with a girl and getting the new schoolhouse built needs context to be seen as right sinister

Joe K said...

That's probably a good point to consider: what the actual intentions of the literal auction were. But underneath that, at least in my reading of it, was that there were implied intentions, and that there was plenty of implying and inferring amongst the characters. Curly and Jud inferring that whoever wins the lunch wins the girl, even if that wasn't literally the instructions of the auction. It was more like symbolism that everyone—characters and audience alike—are buying into.

My apologies if I'm misinterpreting your comment. My problem is that I'm not familiar with actual bachelorette auctions outside of pop culture, and so maybe didn't even think about what they are like in the real world, if they exist(ed), etc.

Sara said...

This post made me look into more R&H movies since baby E is very into Sound of Music. I watched South Pacific this week and I think Oklahoma will be next

Joe K said...

Pam was convinced that the kids were gonna be into The Sound of Music, but it never stuck! Maybe their dad's ambivalence toward old musicals wore off on them. I would never, ever say this to a child, because I think talking shit on art in front of them while they are still developing that part of their brains is one of the most harmful things you can do, but: I fucking haaaaaaate The Sound of Music.