Saturday, February 21, 2026

A Year of Blind Spots: Phrenology

Joe is working through a list of albums that he considers "blind spots," i.e. albums that he's never heard but feels like he should.


1001 Albums You Must Hear Before You Die:

The Roots had taken several blows throughout their career. Initially part of Philly's highbrow hip-hop set, they relocated to London in the mid-1990s to reciprocate acid jazz's flirtation with rap.

Nothing, though, could prepare for the knuckleball that was Phrenology. A look through the guests might suggest a backslapping pop-rap session (Nelly Furtado, Musiq Soulchild, Jill Scott, Talib Kweli), but Phrenology actually dips into experimental electronica, post-punk, and distortion, with a dominant rock theme. "Thought@Work" manages to make the world-weary "Apache" loop sound original, "Rock You" is a hip-hop take on the Stooges, track three, "!!!!!!!!," is a nod to thrash metal, while lo-fi rap-rock maverick Cody Chesnutt leads a blinding rework of his own track "The Seed." At Phrenology's heart are two lengthy tracks. "Break You Off" shifts from the nu-soul stylings of Musiq to string-drenched drum 'n' bass, while the ten-minute epic "Water" starts with a stomping Timbaland shuffle before shifting into an avant-garde ambient territory, featuring free-jazz guitarist James "Blood" Ulmer. The smorgasbord of inspirations is neatly mirrored in the cover art—a wealth of ideas, but all contained in the one consciousness.

Even the samples are employed with wit—"Water" samples British post-punkers the Flying Lizards, while "Quills" recontextualizes "Breakout" by the Bacharach-inspired Brit jazzers Swing Out Sister—amusingly credited on the sleeve as the Swingout Sisters.

Joe:

I've had a tough time with the Roots, both in this column and outside of it, but you can reasonably attribute that to life's circumstances. I.e. not being knowledgeable enough on the genre to appreciate a dense version of it, or not being physically well enough to appreciate anything, or being too stubborn to admit that the house band of a bona fide sex trafficker TV host is worth a deeper look, far away from television employment. Rare that a band with deep Philly roots would have this much of an issue connecting with me, and yet here we are, giving it one last try.

1001 Albums nails what makes Phrenology instantly the most accessible Roots album I've yet heard. It's the breadth of sounds featured, yes, but more than that, it's the deep appreciation for the breadth of music in general. I find kinship in that idea, that Questlove or the Roots in toto would be just poring over techno or thrash or art rock albums for inspiration, and then using that inspiration for their own art. There's something special about not being so boxed into one genre or idea, but feeling the freedom to like what you like and do what you do. I love that, and I love it for the Roots.

I was listening to this at home, and Pam had that look in her eye and that energy about her that's been described in this column and on this blog so many times, the feeling of "what are we listening to," and it was for "Water," of course, the song accurately described above as devolving into some CAN-like chicanery. Thus went the conversation: "This is the Roots, and they do some experimental stuff for a few minutes, and as always I can skip to the next song if you need me to." "Yes, please." "But, like... isn't it cool that the Roots even can do this type of shit?"

It is indeed cool. It's cool that they can easily switch from hard-beat bars about the drug market in South Philly to an insane thrashcore interlude and make it sound normal. There is no talk about credentials allowed here whatsoever. I won't do it. I don't see it that way. I see it only as a bunch of musiophiles doing their fucking thing. It's the first time in my life I can see the Roots as something special, doing something that's actually worthy of attention, instead of just taking up room. It's the first time I can relate to the music. But who knows if that was my fault or theirs.

No comments: