1984
The Coen Brothers
Zoom: February 24, 2026, 9 PM to 10 PM
Participants: Frank, Joe, Sam, Sean E.
Wait, is Blood Simple a dudes movie? This is not something that was mentioned during the Zoom for even a second, it's just purely me thinking about it afterward. I think I'm a little sensitive to the fact that a lot of the stuff we do on the blog here is majority-male, not to mention my participation in two separate book clubs that are all guys. This isn't a conscious decision, which is why I'm sensitive about it. There was an incident a couple years ago in which one of our female members of Record Club sent out an email exclusively to every single other woman on the Sunday email, asking for women to write an album review that week, and not a single person responded... so this is definitely not me saying "guys only," ever. If anything, I'm working my ass off to balance the gender disparity, and am honestly at a loss on how to do it at this point.
At the same time, I know for a fact that at least two female members of Film Club watched Blood Simple and just simply couldn't make the Zoom, which is fine! That's what this post is for! And for the record, I don't think Blood Simple was a "dude movie," even though, sure, most of the actors were male, and maybe "violence" is typically seen as "male" or whatever. I'm getting way off track here. We didn't talk about any of this.
Here's what we talked about:
- Most importantly, that Blood Simple was the Cheshire Cat of Coen brothers movies
- There was an appreciation for how compact the movie was, a brisk 90 minutes, all killer no filler
- Those among us who were well-versed in the Coen brothers' filmography** found joy in seeing some of the Coen tropes employed here for the first time***
- **I (Joe) have now seen seven of the eighteen films. That was the lowest of the four of us, I think. There was a question as to whether which number this is for you might affect what you thought of it.
- ***Did they know it was a first time? In other words, did the Coen brothers say "hey, we're gonna try something new," or was it "hey, remember when we did something like that for Blood Simple? Well, let's try it again, with a twist"?
- These are all characters actors (even McDormand, technically, since this was her first role). Is that to the film's benefit or detriment? Should Walsh's PI have been as prominent as he was?
- I remember thinking "hmmm" after seeing Joel Coen's name in the credits for The Evil Dead, and it was cool connecting the dots here, seeing the movie he/they made after that. Does this movie have the same sort of feel as The Evil Dead?
- "In Texas, you're on your own." This quote starts the movie. Sam talked about the rule in literature in which the statements at the beginning are establishing world rules, and what that means for the actions in this film, how everyone really is acting on their own.
- Big discussion on how these characters are not fleshed out. There was a general question of: do they need to be fleshed out? Or can not fleshing out characters be a conscious filmmaking choice?
- There was a general feeling of "anything could happen" throughout the film, which made more effective the use of the PI's fake photo. Could this movie kill its main characters in the first half hour?
- Lots of tricks in this film calling back to Hitchcock.
- What is "blood simple"? It's the reaction you have in the moment after intense violence.
- Do these characters, specifically the male characters, believe that they are "tough guys"?
- The theory that this is when you pull characters out of a different genre (sitcoms), and place them in this one (thrillers), and what happens to those characters when that happens.
- How visceral were some of these scenes? The hand-stabbing, the empty bullet chambers, and especially the dirt moving slightly after Marty is buried alive.
I would personally probably give this movie 4 pukes out of 5, but I think that grade for you is gonna be determined by how much you are willing to invest in a movie that has no interest in investing in its characters. At least that's the sense I got during our discussion.
But what say you, reader who watched the movie but couldn't attend the Zoom? What did you think? See me in the comments, let's hear it.
(NEXT TIME: Film Club takes a brief detour as Joe considers the life's events that brought him to Yaadein.)

5 comments:
I'm in an all-day training, so this thought is probably not as coherent as I want it to be. But I've been thinking a lot about that opening mini-monologue from the PI. Mostly just how sad it is, I think. The person saying that humans are alone and can't form bonds is the same guy who had a huge hand in starting/continuing all the violent misunderstandings. Maybe if he didn't feel so pessimistic about human connection, none of this would have happened.
In other words, I think Blood Simple the movie is making this point. That humans need to trust each other and form bonds. You might even be able to connect this with the discussion on how the characters weren't developed! Because none of the other characters allowed any space for development!
Blood simple ... you'll get caught up in the ... blood simple, blood simple!
Took me some intense googling to guess that this is to the tune of........ the old Crossfire commercials???
Sorry, missed this chat!
I actually own Blood Simple of Blu Ray, only saw it once a few years ago. Wasn't able to get around to re-watching it recently, but I do remember how interesting it was to watch what seemed like a "practice movie" for the Coens since there are a lot of story elements and stylsitic flourishes that they revisit and perfect in their later movies. FARGO especially, I think, runs because this movie walked.
Post a Comment