A discography like the Beach Boys' is perplexing to me. I still try to figure out its levels, its twists and turns. You have the early era that sounds primitive to me, beautiful but "classic" and sort of corny in that way. Then you have the middle era, in which they go weird and earn lots of critical acclaim, somewhat because it (at the time) went hard against their reputation (think about how confused I was knowing the Beach Boys as the pop band obsessed with surfing and then learning about Pet Sounds). Finally, the late era, in which there is a slow decline in critical appeal as the band ages (though, weirdly, the Beach Boys found commercial success here too, with "Kokomo" hitting #1 twenty-plus years past their peak). A band's career can't actually be categorized this neatly, but this is how my mind works.
So I suppose that Sunflower is, what, that secret space in between the middle era and late era? It's post-Pet Sounds. It's way before "Kokomo." Everything I read about it says that it was a time when "the Beach Boys had never been as unpopular as they were then." It was only 1970 though! Four years after Pet Sounds (but five albums after Pet Sounds). Did that much really change over that short period of time?
What I'm proposing here (for myself, as this is probably not a unique thought) is that there are three lanes to success. You have commercial, critical, and legacy. Commercial is immediate. They had commercial success with the surfing music, whereas Sunflower was very much unsuccessful, commercially speaking. Critical appeal has a smaller impact, and can be affected in the moment by commercial appeal (whether critics want to admit it or not). Legacy comes decades later, and often finds way to counteract both the commercial and critical appeal of the times. We can say something like "critics hated it and it didn't sell well, but modern audiences are still finding their way to it, and finding something to love and cherish."
That's all I ever wanted from the Beach Boys. I want something that I can hold and call my own. I can't get that with Surfin' U.S.A. or Surfin' Safari, too cliché. I can't get that with Pet Sounds, since that would also be cliché in a different way ("oh, you like the album that lists you saw growing up had at #2 all-time? cool......."). I can't get that with 1992's Summer in Paradise, because critics don't get it wrong all the time. So listening to Sunflower was an attempt to find a space in between, to discover something new for myself, to help build a legacy that goes against whatever the critics and the buyers in the general public have said over the years.
I don't know that I found it here. Sunflower, to me, sounds like a band in search of a sound. It still feels like they are asking themselves "what next?" in the aftermath of the explosion that was Pet Sounds. I didn't get that sense with Wild Honey, which was one year and two albums after Pet Sounds. Wild Honey had a sense of purpose, or at least its legacy has affixed a purpose onto it (that it invented bedroom pop). Sunflower, on the other hand, feels like a collection of songs. Which is nice to listen to, but doesn't fit neatly into any narrative that I concoct in my mind.
The other thing I read about Sunflower is that this was the most collaborative the Beach Boys ever were in the studio, in that all members contributed equally to the songwriting process—or at least more equally than usual, I don't know, I'm actually not familiar with the dynamics of the band pre- or post-. My assumption was that Brian Wilson was writing the songs and the other Wilsons and Mike Love et al. were singing them. I guess it's a lot more complicated than that. I'm cool with complicated. I think it's good when bandmates feel like they are working together. I also get pretty skeptical when the thesis statement of an album is "everyone worked together on this one!" But it is what it is.
Probably what they meant was "members were working on other members' songs," which makes sense. You can still separate the songs by writer. You have the sappy love songs from Carl Wilson, like "Our Sweet Love." You have the wild left turns into non-Beach-Boys-sounding songs like the gospel-esque "Got to Know the Woman" from Dennis Wilson. You have Brian Wilson still pushing pop music into hitherto undiscovered territory—"Did you know the Beach Boys invented [insert music genre here]?" is a fun game to play, and you can play it with "All I Wanna Do" and dream pop. And then you have "Add Some Music to Your Day," which isn't my favorite song on the album, but definitely has a theme that is near and dear to my heart (music is fucking awesome), and is the only one on here credited to the whole band, so it acts at the de facto thesis statement for the album.
I don't mean for my statement above about this sounding like a collection of songs to be a criticism. I actually don't know if there are any albums by the Beach Boys that sound like a cohesive artistic statement. I didn't feel that way about Pet Sounds; I think that the artistic cohesiveness comes retroactively from critics deeming it a work of genius. I don't need that from the Beach Boys anyway. I grew up thinking that they were a bunch of brainless surfer pretty boys with nice voices who sang about girls on the beach in the most sophomoric ways. Anything beyond that is well exceeding my expectations. I like Sunflower a lot, and it is complex and satisfying, if not necessarily cohesive.
No comments:
Post a Comment