1953
Yasujirō Ozu
We're trying something new this quarter in Film Club. Instead of solid small groups, we've assigned certain movies to random small groups of friends in a sort of round robin-type thing. Thanks to those who were assigned Tokyo Story and chose to participate and watch, and thanks to Sean G. for picking the movie in the first place.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Sean G.
"Isn't life disappointing?"
Life is full of pain and beauty and stillness, but it always ticks by. For as beautiful as life is, it inherently is not what we fully want it to be. You never have enough time, you turn into people you don't want to be, tragedy strikes whenever it feels like it. But that's such a simplified way to look at a movie as layered and full and nuanced as Tokyo Story.
I love Yasujirō Ozu. I've loved his movies for years. I don't know of any other filmmaker or artist who can sum up the complicated feelings and experiences of human life as beautifully and heartbreakingly as he can. Similarly with Tokyo Story, when I watch An Autumn Afternoon, Late Spring, or any of his many other films, I immediately reflect on the choices and relationships I've made in my own life. His ability to empathize with seemingly all aspects of the human experience is astounding. Entire books have been written about this film alone. I could watch, discuss, and try to analyze this movie for an entire lifetime and will always have a changing point of view or a new experience to relate to. This movie is life.
Tokyo Story, of course, makes me think of my own parents and grandparents. I'm lucky that my parents are still living, as are three of my four grandparents. I was talking to my mom about her parents last week and their loneliness came up. "They stare at the walls and at each other all day" is what she said. It's never easy to acknowledge the loneliness that others—especially loved ones. It made me feel sad: one, because they're getting older and may feel lonely most of the time, but also because I do not see them or even talk to them enough on the phone. They live in New Jersey and I live in Texas. Recognizing that no amount of time is enough time is even harder when I know that I could be spending more time with them if I lived closer. Still, it would never be enough time. We never know how much time we have on this Earth or with others in our lives. No matter how much time, it never feels like enough. That is disappointing.
Man, there is just so much to say about this movie. Ozu uses the same cast in most of his films, and they play similar roles each time. The incredible Chishū Ryū (the father) is one of my all time favorite actors because of the beautiful work he does across Ozu's filmography. His performance and the performances of the entire cast—especially, for me, Chieko Higashiyama (the mother) and Setsuko Hara (Noriko) cannot be discussed properly in a written review. The characters they breathe life into are so real. Hara is a legendary Japanese actress who retired from the spotlight early in her career. I CANNOT RECOMMEND ENOUGH Satoshi Kon's Millennium Actress—an animated masterpiece based on her life.
Fuck, I wish I had more to say in a thoughtful way. It 100% makes sense why this is one of the greatest movies in the history of cinema. Ozu's camerawork invites us to be an observer to the lives of these characters: to feel them, sit in their loneliness, feel their pain. His movies relax me and are transcendental. They are the human experience created for us to reflect on and express in ways that we cannot. Everything about this movie is incredible.
Ozu is truly THE MASTER. Please watch his other movies. I would start with An Autumn Afternoon, Good Morning, Late Spring, and Floating Weeds.
GRADE: 5 out of 5
~~~~~~~~~~~~
Zach
"Life is disappointment.""Nothing but disappointment."
One might think this is the thesis of this movie. As could its final line, which goes something like "yes, you'll be lonely." But they're not. I don't think so. I don't think this movie thinks all roads lead to disappointment. It can be, certainly. But it perches all of us on the edge of things, those of us who have what we have right now, but who still have the power to change the future, rather than regret it when it's gone.
I'm a healthy person. My parents are healthy. They just came to visit me. I'm planning my next trip to the U.S., trying to juggle expensive flights and find the most efficient/right one. There's no specific reason for me to come to the U.S. right now. It's just for the Passover holiday coming up. But there's no specific occasion or life event that's being marked. I don't have to go.
The thesis statement of this movie, then, hinges on moments like this, which we all experience, even when we live around the corner from our parents or other loved ones. Even when our own children are inside the house, I imagine. The time goes fast. Did I do enough? Was I good enough? Should I go, should I spend time, even when it's disruptive, even when things are good, even when nothing specific is being asked of me?
The movie yells its answer from the rooftops. And it is this: Go. Go now. Travel to the U.S. Even though there's no occasion. Go, even when there's no reason. Go, just to sit at breakfast with them, reading the newspaper, saying nothing. Just be there. And be good to them. Don't look back at the past and wonder what if. In our movie's case, don't go to the "baseball match" instead of staying longer with your lonely father.
I don't think the couple's Tokyo children were entirely bad. They are complicated, just like all of us. Shige certainly seems, on the surface, to be the worst—asking for her mother's mementos, having the idea to send them to the hot springs, and so on. But she cares. She cares a lot. She just doesn't know how to square the reality of time and her aging parents with her day-to-day life, which feels the most pressing.
I can relate. I get anxious when my parents come to Israel, that they will disrupt my life, too. I spend lots of time with them, though, and I try to go out of my way to care for them, to honor them. But I ask myself the same question. Do I do enough? Do I have my Shige moments?
One of my biggest fears is that I am more like Shige than like Noriko, who goes the most out of her way to honor her in-laws.
(The Osaka son seems to have even fewer redeeming features, and yet he walks out of the funeral ceremony, unable to see his mother becoming smaller and smaller, as he says, but he can't find a way to escape his own evil inclination, to care more about his day-to-day than the eternity of his loved ones.)
And yet even Noriko feels like she doesn't do enough. Like she's selfish. Can any of us escape our own self-judgment? The father, too, saying that he should have been kinder to his wife while she was still alive. We are our harshest critics. And yet there is truth to Noriko and the way the father criticizes himself. There is always more we can do, more we have to do.
I have it all right now. I can take any job I want. I have a good family around me. People are healthy. I can marry anyone I want. And yet I can't stop thinking of how I have it so good. How do we act, when we have it good? Do we take it for granted, like the Tokyo/Osaka children seem to? Or do we push more, push harder to love the ones around us, love our parents the way they deserve, and honor them, give to them, endlessly and without a second thought, even when they trigger us, even when that seems like the hardest thing in the world to do?
I can't remember the last time I watched a movie that felt so much a part of me, that spoke so closely to my life. But I don't think that's because it specifically speaks to me. I've never been to Japan. It's more about the way the film touches a basic element of humanity that we all experience, if we're lucky. It has the uncanny ability to speak to everyone's lives because it is so close to the lived human experience, for all of us. That's why it is so powerful.
I don't see any reason why I shouldn't give this movie a perfect score. I can't say anything bad about it, can't find a specific flaw. Nothing man made in this world is perfect, but we should honor the things that come close.
Just like our parents.
Grade: 5/5
~~~~~~~~~~~~
Joe
The idea that Barry Lyndon could be described as a "painting" really opened my eyes to another way of watching movies. I think about that all the time. If I had the time, I would probably rewatch Barry Lyndon to determine whether I liked it any more than I did the first time, now that I knew to look at it like a painting. I don't have time, though. Too busy watching other movies for Film Club. But I can take what I've learned from previous movies and apply those lessons to the next ones. While watching Tokyo Story, I quickly realized that this was a movie that was meant to be seen as a painting.
I'm just going from the gut here. I don't actually know the craft. But in my gut, it feels like there was something special happening in Tokyo Story. I noticed it maybe ten minutes into the film: the camera didn't move. Long scenes would take place in homes where people were moving from room to room, and the camera didn't follow them. Instead, there was a camera in each room, low to the ground (subservient, much like the family members who chose to hang out while kneeling on towels), and they remained stationary as our characters moved about here and there. It had a way of making it seem like we were peeking in on something private.
I would have to start from the beginning to see if there were any camera movements at the beginning of the film, before I noticed what was happening. I clocked it otherwise, and it took until the 61st minute of Tokyo Story for the camera to move. It was a scene when Mother and Father were sitting outside, and the camera moved to meet them where they were sitting. (The movement was a "truck," I believe, which is a term I only know because I just looked up a guide to camera movements.) I suppose there should be a question of why this is the one scene when the camera moved. Logistically, maybe they briefly had access to equipment that allowed for it to happen on this 1953 movie set. Spiritually, maybe something else was happening. Maybe this was supposed to be a shift in the movie from petty family drama to serious family drama, like a camera movement mark the exact moment Mother gets sick.
That's it, though. No more movement. Stationary cameras throughout the entire rest of the 135-minute movie. That's assuming that you don't count when the camera itself is stationary on a moving vehicle, like a trolley. I guess that's technically movement too, though it's supposed to make you feel like you are with the passengers of said trolley, who are technically stationary as well, but also moving. It's a new feeling in the film, that movement, which I suppose is mirroring how alien being on a big-city trolley must feel to Mother and Father, who are only visiting.
That's it, though. No more movement. Stationary cameras throughout the entire rest of the 135-minute movie. That's assuming that you don't count when the camera itself is stationary on a moving vehicle, like a trolley. I guess that's technically movement too, though it's supposed to make you feel like you are with the passengers of said trolley, who are technically stationary as well, but also moving. It's a new feeling in the film, that movement, which I suppose is mirroring how alien being on a big-city trolley must feel to Mother and Father, who are only visiting.
I have not looked up this movie online yet. I probably do that in between the credits and sitting down to write on the blog for about 95% of the films that we watch in this club, but there are certain films that are so bursting with ideas and so effective in moving me (ha) that I rush off to write before I lose that feeling. I don't think Tokyo Story was perfect, but only because no movie is perfect. There were, however, so many moments when it felt perfect. It was simple and beautiful. There was no trickery here, the film just plopped us into a moment in time for this family, and allowed us to watch their small drama unfold. It was touching, both in the ways I felt empathetic, and in the ways the film's structure enhanced that empathy.
Something else filmmaking-wise that I noticed early on was the decision to have some of the characters speak directly into that stationary camera for many of the conversations. E.g. Father would be talking to Mother but the camera would be right in Father's face, and then Mother would respond but the camera would be right in her face. A note I made early in the film speculated that this was bad acting, but a note toward the end of the film made sure to reverse that thinking. It was a feature, not a bug—Father comforting Noriko with a big smile on his face, speaking calmly to the camera, that all had a way of comforting the audience to. I felt comforted, like he was speaking to me, tell me not to be so sad. I wonder if this was an intention of the filmmaker and actors, or if it's just something I needed to feel from the film.
I appreciated too the fact that there was no melodrama in this film. The first half of the film seemed like it was building up to the idea that Shige and maybe Kōichi were going to be the villains of the story, doing something to screw up their parents' lives. And while there was a small tension that remained there even after Mother's death, it never fully bloomed into something extraordinary. It was a very ordinary, banal drama. Father, even after Mother dies, shrugs it off: "you're very busy, don't mind me." Even after all the discussion about children being disappointments or how kids change as they grow up, and Mother's worries about Shige not being as nice as she was when she was younger... I mean, all of this matters, but they don't add up to anything sinister.
Which felt truer to real life! I wonder sometimes what my parents think about me behind closed doors, and I have to imagine it is something like the conversation between Mother and Father here. "Joe was such a nice kid... what happened... haha we still love him though..." Mother dies, that's just how it goes. No one is blamed. Father doesn't try to say that it was the trip to Tokyo that killed her. He also doesn't call out anyone for trying to ditch their parents for the entire week they are there. Shige can be kind of a dick and still be very, very sad at the passing of her mom. That's just how it is. Human beings are complicated, interfamilial relationships even more so. Nothing is black or white.
Which felt truer to real life! I wonder sometimes what my parents think about me behind closed doors, and I have to imagine it is something like the conversation between Mother and Father here. "Joe was such a nice kid... what happened... haha we still love him though..." Mother dies, that's just how it goes. No one is blamed. Father doesn't try to say that it was the trip to Tokyo that killed her. He also doesn't call out anyone for trying to ditch their parents for the entire week they are there. Shige can be kind of a dick and still be very, very sad at the passing of her mom. That's just how it is. Human beings are complicated, interfamilial relationships even more so. Nothing is black or white.
I keep thinking that maybe it all seemed beautiful in its ordinariness because of the camera, though. There were emotions rippling through each scene between different combinations of characters, and I could feel them, sometimes very strongly, but never once did I feel like I was being told how to feel. The camera didn't suddenly zoom in when a character expressed surprise. It didn't track a character to show that this character's feelings were most important. Nothing like any of that. It just stayed put. It invited us to remove our sandals, and take our spot on the floor, allowing us space to watch the story unfold. I was indeed watching a painting, come to life.
GRADE: 5 pukes out of 5
~~~~~~~~~~~~~
GROUP AVERAGE GRADE: 5 pukes out of 5
Meet us in the comments to let us know what you think! I have so many more thoughts!
(NEXT TIME: Another group of Film Club members assemble to watch The Adventures of Buckaroo Banzai Across the 8th Dimension!)

23 comments:
It's been a couple years since I've seen this; total GOAT movie just like you all accurately rated. Glorious Nippon!
The most magical week of Film Club thus far. Amazing we all gave it 5 stars. Amazing all our reviews intersected in really specific ways (starting with the "disappointment" line, how it touches on all elements of the human experience, questions of perfection). Amazing that we got the chance to watch such a classic movie.
I have a bunch of spare thoughts about this one that I couldn't fit into the write-up above, so I'm gonna share some of them in the comments. I will first say that I appreciate the idea of three different people all separately rating a movie with a perfect score. I don't know if that's ever going to happen again in Film Club. I think it's really important to have a good balance of movies in this thing, and I think things would get boring if we didn't have pretty good / imperfect / extremely flawed / hilariously bad movies in the mix too. But it's nice to occasionally come across something that can be universally beloved.
I'm hoping I can get Brianna in here too, even though the deadline for her to submit something has passed. The film assignments were mostly random, because I didn't know what these movies were about so I couldn't have planned it anyway, but it would've been cool to write about this movie alongside my actual real-life sibling. I wonder if she has a different perspective of my parents than the one I briefly shared in my own write-up. For the record, Brianna is totally Kyōko, the loyal youngest sibling. She would have to share her own opinions about who is the Shige in the family.
I also noticed the closeup thing. I also thought it was a case of bad acting at first. But if you look at the movie as a whole, you realize it's not. I don't exactly know what it means, exactly, but I think it lends a certain sense of empathy to the characters, especially with Noriko, who looks like she is touching your heart when she looks at you like that.
This is the dumbest question but I'll ask it anyway. Tokyo Story and Toy Story has similar names, only two letters off. I wonder if this was intentional, or just coincidence. I'm thinking about the camera shots in Tokyo Story, and how they were still and low to the ground. Are there many shots like that in Toy Story as well? I can imagine that the camera is low to the ground a lot, because they are toys. I'll have to make the kids rewatch that one soon.
Yet another sign that this is a good movie is that forces you to adjust what it is doing. If we're all approaching this as 21st century Western-centric filmwatchers, then something that Eastern-centric 1953 filmmakers are doing is going to seem abrupt and weird at first. But if it feels natural by the end, maybe that means the film did its job.
Something that we didn't touch on in any of the write-ups was some of the cultural gender stuff happening in the background. Like how the oldest son told his wife that she wasn't allowed to leave the house without him, or how everyone said that little shit grandson was just "spirited" instead of being a little shithead boy, like if he had been a girl, maybe that behavior would have been looked down upon. I thought these elements were going to play into the story more than they ended up doing. I know it's a "that's how things were then and there." I also maybe only noticed because my 7yo watched 20 minutes of this movie with me (I was reading out loud the subtitles) and talked to her about how weird the patriarchal shit was. I also don't this has anything to do with the quality of the film, just something I was thinking about as I was watching.
There was also something about smiling. Father, Mother, Noriko were always smiling, the whole movie. Especially Father. I really noticed it. Even when they were upset. I wasn't sure if this was a Japanese culture thing, or my ignorance, or an acting/directing choice. But I noticed it.
I thought the line "Losing one's children is hard... but living with them isn't much easier. A real dilemma" was a good one. Mainly in that it was said in a funny way, like I think the character intended it to be funny, but also it felt pretty poignant in the grand scope of the movie.
In a different movie project I did, everyone also gave this film 5 stars. Other stray thoughts -- the post-war Japan stuff is never discussed but kind of haunts everything. Grappling with the past of the country as the new generation plunges into the modern era.
Also, it's a miracle this very slow, static, ethereal film is no way boring at all. Many of his films are like this and touch on similar themes, but they all push through. Just great stuff.
Yeah! The disappointment line that you both quoted was said with a huge smile! I gotta imagine it's a mixture of 1) cultural, and 2) choice to show that Mother/Father are decent people and are trying to stay optimistic in this cruel-ass world.
I did find myself wondering what happened to the grandkids. Did they care at all about their grandparents dying? Was it relevant? Was there more depth to them, other than being shitheads? I nearly knocked my score down to 4.75 because of this question but, I mean, eff it. It deserved a 5.
The war stuff (or lack thereof) is a good point. I appreciated how there were breadcrumbs leading to the revelation that their son had died in the war (part of the process of figuring out who all these characters were, clicking into place that Noriko was DIL and not daughter), how they were looking at his photo, and using past tense verbs. They didn't have to outright state it at first, it was all part of the unspoken story of this family and many other families.
No one discussed the scene where Father gets drunk with his old buddies...such sadness, such reality about how they spoke about their children! I would love to be a fly on the wall hearing my parents get drunk and talk about me, as Joe alluded to; on the other hand I'd be terrified to know what they might say.
Agreed. Amazing how it's a post-war movie that isn't really about the war at all but is also so, so much about the war.
And the way Shige discussed with her husband where to put Father after he passed out drunk...it felt like a very real couple conversation, one that plays out every day in modern times and has probably played out every single day in various forms throughout history (see: the stories of Noah and Lot from the Bible to know how eternal it is!).
Something I'll put out is the significance of the title being Tokyo Story, and not you know, Parents and Children. Is there something about a modern, quickly westernizing Tokyo (less than a decade removed from being razed down from the fire bombing) moving forward and leaving behind old Japan? Like this trip for the parents is double fish out of water because this city is completely different culturally from even the city they would have gone to ten years before. Also it was already said but Setsuko Hara is just so good in this. Could she be the bridge of grieving a culture that was lost in the war?
Also I'll second Late Spring as a great watch if you liked this
Glad this scene was brought up, so excellent
I liked how there was a lot of spoken and unspoken tension between Shige and Father in this moment. She had said earlier that she remembered there being issues with Father's drinking when she was a child, but that the younger children don't remember. And Mother said something like, yeah he used to drink a lot, but he took care of that. I was viewing these scenes through the eyes of Father, thinking about my own kids. I don't think they'll have any memories of me being shitfaced, due to age, but they might. And I hope that Pam will eventually speak to it like Mother does here: he had issues, he addressed them, we're good now. So I dunno, I don't think that I viewed the Father as having "relapsed," per se, and I think I made that choice as a defensive mechanism of some sort.
Anyways, I appreciate you pointing out the Shige/husband interaction. You're right, that felt very true to life. Especially if Shige is bringing to the table a whole host of emotions re: Father's drinking that go unspoken in that moment.
That's a good call about focusing on the title of the film. I interpreted it as "a presentation of this family's story, but this story is not unique, it is happening all over the city." But you're right that it's more specific than that.
Wait, it's been a while, and the PoYB write-up is not helpful—why was that other movie called Philadelphia Story?
If someone were to create another, concurrent Film Club, one that focused on follow-ups, sequels, movies adjacent to, or movies by the same directors or within the same genre as, to films in this Film Club, then I would totally join that Film Club too.
Post a Comment