Wednesday, February 11, 2026

A Year of Blind Spots: Madman Across the Water

Joe is working through a list of albums that he considers "blind spots," i.e. albums that he's never heard but feels like he should.


1001 Albums You Must Hear Before You Die:

Elton John was so dedicated to his art, or so contractually bound, that he released five albums in eighteen months from April 1970—although one was a movie soundtrack and another a live effort. Madman Across the Water, which started with two tracks recorded in February 1971 and was completed that August, was his fourth studio album, and included no major hit singles, yet remained in U.S. chart for almost a year; by contrast, it was one of his least successful in the U.K. It was also the first Elton album to feature Scottish guitarist Davey Johnstone (ex-Magna Carta), who became a permanent band member in early 1972, and more than 30 years later, is still in Elton's band (as is drummer Nigel Olsson). Among the session musicians helping out here are Rick Wakeman (keyboards), Herbie Flowers (bass), and Chris Spedding (guitar). Unsurprisingly, given Wakeman's involvement, there is a whiff of prog rock about the proceedings, while Paul Buckmaster's rich string arrangements serve to further expand the sound.

The best songs here are at the start: "Tiny Dancer" was written about Bernie Taupin's first wife, Maxine Feibelman, and both this and another ballad, the lyrically abstruse "Levon," were U.S. Top 40 singles—no mean feat given their uncommercial length.

Taupin has stated that the title track—an unnerving portrait of insanity, hinting at an introspective streak which pervades much of this album—has the dubious distinction of being his most misunderstood lyric. Many people have presumed that it is about the disgraced U.S. president Richard Nixon. While dismissing this idea, Taupin has not provided an alternative explanation.

Joe:

"Taupin has not provided an alternative explanation" is fucking hilarious. I unsarcastically love hearing lyricists attempt to explain their work. It's a fool's errand, because, one, they don't have to explain, two, the meaning can change depending on who's listening, and three, the meaning can change for the lyricist over time. I looked up "Levon" to see if it had anything to do with Levon Helm, member of the Band. First, Taupin claimed the song was named after Levon Helm. Then, Levon Helm said he hated the song ("Englishmen shouldn't fuck with Americanisms"). And then, decades later, Taupin tried claiming it had nothing to do with Helm. No one is bullshitting here, not even Taupin. He probably used the name of Levon Helm as inspiration, and then, over the years, that negative opinion from Levon Helm wore away that explanation, to the point that it was no longer true for Taupin. It's just funny to think that "songs change" applies to even the songmakers.

It happened to me with "Tiny Dancer," once upon a time. I probably would've dismissed it as corny schmaltz were it not for Almost Famous (I went back and checked, and it looks like me and Mandy ran out of time before talked about this song particularly, but it made me giggle that she made it a point to claim that Elton John did NOT write these songs). I'm not uncomfortable with that happening, and it happens a lot, that moment when a good movie rescues a classic rock song from my undying hatred. Robot Dreams did it with "September." We just watched a movie last night called Troop Zero, and I think it's gonna rescue "Space Oddity" for me. I like "Tiny Dancer." Good song, and so what if that's because of a movie?

Zooming out from the first track on the album, I'll say that Madman Across the Water is probably gonna be the album that pushes my opinion firmly onto the pro-Elton side. (I'm talking about the music, obviously—I've been unabashedly pro-Elton John as a person ever since he took a piss in the corner of a French sneaker shop.) The 1001 Albums blurb above isn't off-base about Side A being better than Side B, but I think this is because Side A goes buckwild on the orchestration. I'm big on that shit. Strings like this make music feel important. Also on Side A, we have "Razor Face," which is not necessarily top-tier Elton, but does sound suspiciously like something Levon Helm's the Band would've come up with, which I thought was just plain ol' good sequencing, coming right after "Levon."

Flip the entire tracklist—yes, even put "Goodbye" as the first track—and I think you have an all-timer here. As it stands, this is the first Elton John album I've listened to since Goodbye Yellow Brick Road that made me think that this dude deserves his reputation as one of the classic rock legends.

No comments: