The artist cannot save you. Not even Bruce Springsteen.
You'd like to think that they are on your side, the people who make the art that you love. And sometimes—maybe most of the time—you can convince yourself that they are on your side because that's what they say, and that's how the art presents itself. If, say, you find yourself living in a time in your nation's history when the working class is being murdered in the street by the hired thugs of the ruling class, then you might turn to an album that presents a story based on the working class epic of the 1940s. I felt drawn to The Grapes of Wrath in 2022, and Bruce Springsteen felt drawn to it when he happened upon it on TV (57 channels and there's something on) sometimes in the '80s or '90s. He, Springsteen, the consummate self-appointed hero balladeer of the working class folk, singing the songs that we need to hear. It makes sense to see ICE shooting innocent U.S. citizens in the head in broad daylight and think, hmm, yes, I need an album of Springsteen folk songs to make it make sense.
It makes sense, when you hear it. It makes a lot of sense, but the reason it makes sense is not the answer that will save you. It makes sense because regular people like you and me have been murdered in the streets for as long as humans have existed. You can draw a line from the fictional character of Tom Joad to the nonfictional human being of Alex Pretti and that line runs right through this Bruce Springsteen album. Move the line backward and forward and connect the dots throughout all of human history, from the beating of Rodney King to the crucifixion of the socialist immigrant Jesus Christ. Listen to the stories as Bruce Springsteen presents them, here on this album. It all fits. But what I'm saying here is that this isn't going to save you. You will not find redemption. Don't even try.
The Ghost of Tom Joad is like Nebraska in tone, in that there is sparse instrumentation here. The Ghost of Tom Joad is like Nebraska in that I don't really like it all that much, for the same reasons. But I can't deny that Springsteen was successful in what he was trying to do. He wanted to get to the root of some pretty universal issues, and he got there. I just wonder—as many people have over the past few decades, this isn't a new thought, I am not unique, I am part of the hoi polloi—if The Ghost of Tom Joad might have been more effective if this had been a full-band effort. I get the feeling that Springsteen has wondered that too—"Youngstown" in blown-out live form is an E Street Band concert staple, and we'll be seeing the electric version of the title track when we get to High Hopes in this column. But still, we consider here what we have, not what we could have had.
What we have is an album whose volume is often so low that I constantly find myself adjusting my iPod so I can hear what the fuck is going on. Maybe it's begging for my attention? The subject matter is important enough to warrant attention, this is true. I think I'm just the type of person whose attention is drawn to big musical moments more so than serious storytelling. The ideal is that you combine the two, and Springsteen has done that plenty of times throughout his discography, so it's not like he can't. It's just that sometimes he won't. Which is fine. That's a conscious decision. I actually appreciate the fact that the guy mixes it up sometimes, even when trying a different sound is to his detriment, which this is.
It's such a tough needle to thread, though, so who the fuck am I to talk shit on it? If you try to meet the moment in history with advice or platitudes, it might come off as condescending. If you try to remain optimistic with bright pop music, then you could be reasonably accused as ignorant. And if you try to tell simple stories as a way to empathize with those in pain, like he does in The Ghost of Tom Joad, then you have people like me who are starting to wonder what the point of it all is besides making me feel more like shit. I find myself distancing myself from this album in the same way I tend to avoid any and all videos coming out of Minnesota in 2026. I stand on the side of justice, and empathize with those downtrodden featured, but I don't need to inundate myself with proof.
I'm not saying that I'm being purposefully obtuse. There are so many people in America, perhaps even a plurality of Americans, who don't read the news at all, and don't care, because that's easier. That's true. I sometimes envy the ignorance, because life would be happier if I didn't care. But I do care, and I am aware of my surroundings, and I am painfully in tune with the decay of my nation and the pain that decay has wrought. I think it's just a matter of balancing knowledge with self-care. I know that if I watched a video of a murder or listened to nothing but The Ghost of Tom Joad around the clock, I would feel like shit, and it wouldn't shift my perspective at all. I'm already here, I'm already scared, I'm already ready to fight in the small ways that I can. If I can do that without feeling hopelessly depressed, I'm going to do that. Other people need it this way, need art like The Ghost of Tom Joad to move them in beneficial ways. I can't do it. There's nowhere leftward to go.
But I honestly have no fucking idea if I'm typing all this because this is how I feel, or I'm just using it as an excuse for the musical sparseness of the thing, which I don't really like. It's probably helpful that I wrote about this for Nebraska already, because that shows consistency in my opinion on the matter. Will we have to address this again? Probably. I know that there's a Pete Seeger cover album eventually (three albums from now, to be exact), and I am assuming that's all acoustic stuff, just only from knowing Pete Seeger and his own work. But I am also assuming, based on my (limited) Seeger knowledge, that those songs are going to be about hope, which will contrast nicely with Tom Joad's despair, despite the similar lack of depth when it comes to the instruments.
I actually remember reading the Inquirer back in 2006 (in the back of a church where I was selling those same newspapers), and specifically remember reading that We Shall Overcome was Springsteen's first acoustic album since Tom Joad. I didn't know either album, or even that much about Springsteen at all at that point beyond Born to Run under Wildwood skies. Perhaps the coincidence of that small memory can be used here, though. The ignorance of youth, not knowing anything about the breadth of this man's music nor the depth of human misery. I was excited to watch The Grapes of Wrath because that was a piece of the large-scale story that I'm slowly learning as I grow older and become more radicalized.
I too am excited to finally hear The Ghost of Tom Joad. I don't think it's a good album. It might even be my least favorite Bruce Springsteen album so far. But I uphold its purpose and its message, and I am glad it exists. No one can save me, but I sure as shit appreciate Springsteen for trying.
I too am excited to finally hear The Ghost of Tom Joad. I don't think it's a good album. It might even be my least favorite Bruce Springsteen album so far. But I uphold its purpose and its message, and I am glad it exists. No one can save me, but I sure as shit appreciate Springsteen for trying.
Song for the "Tramps like Us" mixtape: "Across the Border"

No comments:
Post a Comment