This is a complementary Blind Spot to Cowboy Junkies' The Trinity Session last year, because these are the two bands mentioned in a tossed-off (but critically essential, according to many professional writers) lyric from the National's Matt Berninger: "What about the Cowboy Junkies? What about the Afghan Whigs?" After exploring Black Love, my second Afghan Whigs album, I am no closer to figuring out why Berninger chose these two artists. Maybe they just fit the rhyme scheme. That's okay, baby. We're not here to unravel the mysteries of the universe. We're just trying to listen to some good tunes.
I described the Afghan Whigs as having a "gruff and grungy sort of alt-rock" musical palette in that last blog post, and that is true even after I put another album of theirs under my belt. I have a weird feeling that I needed to alter that description I gave them at the last minute to make it true. Why do I have a suspicion that I originally accused them of being alt-country? Because that's what I usually do. I think I get them mixed up with the Black Crowes, who are more southern rock, I guess, in the Skynyrd-Truckers pipeline, contrasting with Afghan Whigs, who are more like Smashing Pumpkins by way of Dinosaur Jr. or the Replacements.
Really, this is all to highlight how short a shrift I've given Afghan Whigs (and Black Crowes) in my lifetime. I've been focusing artists I'm already at least a little familiar with in this year's Blind Spots column, but this one is stretching the definition. Yes, Gentlemen (Black Love's predecessor) has been on my iPod for a while now, but it's been so under the radar that I barely even remembered it existed (or thought it was a Black Crowes affair). I do not understand why certain albums connect with me and some don't. Can't tell you, never could. That's just how music is.
The million-dollar question, then, is: did Black Love connect with me? Yeah, man. That might be the power of the blog (i.e. "oh shit I better pay attention, I have to write something about this"), but even so, it wouldn't happen if the music wasn't good. I like this album because it wasn't afraid to be dark and foreboding, which I feel like is not what I expected. Wikipedia makes it seem like a turn toward dark subject matter was fait accompli, but who the fuck am I to say? That's something an Afghan Whigs acolyte would know for sure; I'm just some fucking guy wondering who the hell the Afghan Whigs are.
But it definitely is dark, in interesting and definitely never boring ways. It feels like a murder mystery movie, in which the pace picks up as the mystery begins to unravel, and thus so does the tempo. (Apparently the Coen brothers' film debut Blood Simple was a big influence, which is probably the factoid I needed to lock Blood Simple into the Film Club Zoom slot for February.) These are dynamic songs, but never bright and happy. Even something like "Going to Town" manages to turn a seriously funky synth line into something spooky and dangerous. Or like "Bulletproof"'s swirling guitars and desperate vocals paint a dire picture of the protagonist's lot in life. There's a huge difference between dark-slow-boring and dark-dangerous-exciting, and Afghan Whigs nail the latter.
I suppose if I were to really make a wild guess here and assume something about that National lyric, I'd say that Cowboy Junkies and the Afghan Whigs each present two opposing visions of what it means to be "sad and depressed" in the bold rock 'n' roll way that the National aspire to, with Cowboy Junkies wrapping hope around the bleakness of the church they recorded in, and the Afghan Whigs blowing out the darkness to full widescreen proportions. They are the angel and the devil on Berninger's shoulders. Which one is which, though, is a question I'm still not ready to answer.
2 comments:
This is my favorite Afghan Whigs record and it unlocks when you realize it was basically their attempt at making a Prince album that is as much about drug crime as it is about having sex. "Faded" is basically an attempt at "Purple Rain." "Crime Scene Part One" is an all-time great song about getting ready to do mob violence. Greg Dulli gets a lot of mileage singing his ass off without every really sounding good at singing. The slide guitar all over this thing gives it a weird country/blues element that serves the songs well. This is the good stuff here.
This definitely felt like a Nate album, and not just because the only other evidence of the Afghan Whigs on the blog prior to this was a Nate YSC pick. Thanks for the additional remarks, they color in this album for me even more.
Post a Comment