(Round 1, Round 2, and the Sweet Sixteen can be found by clicking on those links.)
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
QUARTERFINALS — THE ELITE EIGHT
![]() |
| CLICK TO ENLARGE |
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
"Don't Call Upon Me" by Music Band VS. "Waste Your Time" by Ex Hex
I know I joked about Music Band being ungoogleable last week, but dudes, this is so true. I feel for their manager, having to endlessly explain the joke to venue bookers. At the same time, I guess this adds a veil of mystery to the band; if you can't instantly pull up a list of interviews on the internet, then you're left wondering... who the fuck ARE these guys? "Don't Call Upon Me" answers the question as best it can. Music Band are a fun-loving punk rock band who love bashing guitars and chugging along at a fast clip. "Don't Call Upon Me" is a song that deserves to be shouted along.
Ex Hex is a little cooler than Music Band, because they keep their emotions a little closer to the chest. This is not to their detriment. Ex Hex is the cool chick at the bar, giving off vibes that she is way cooler than you but probably still approachable for a nice chat. Ex Hex brings the guitar riffage hard and heavy in "Waste Your Time," and while not as fist-pumped exciting at "Don't Call Upon Me," it's still a song that you can bang your head to.
The heart wants what the heart wants, however, and this heart is beating significantly faster after I hear the winner.
WINNER: "Don't Call Upon Me"
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
"Be Good" by Black Prairie VS. "The Execution of All Things" by Rilo Kiley
Black Prairie, as stated before, is the Decemberists minus Colin Meloy, so the vocal duties fall to Annalisa Tornfelt. She mainly plays fiddle in her main gig, and is described in multiple publications as the "reluctant vocalist" of Black Prairie. The alleged reluctance, to my ears, is pointless, because her honest singing hits the mark so goddamn well in most of the tracks on this album, "Be Good" especially. I can't imagine Meloy being able to capture Tornfelt's same earnestness on display here. Is this song simple? Absolutely. It doesn't rewrite the book on country folk songs. But for what is ostensibly a side project, Black Prairie knows its craft, and does it really well.
Rilo Kiley probably needs less of an introduction. They are an indie rock institution. And though they don't exist as a unit anymore, frontwoman Jenny Lewis continues the Rilo Kiley tradition in her solo work (new album tomorrow!). "The Execution of All Things" is the title track to one of the greatest albums of the aughts. No, the title track is not the best song on the album. It's probably not even close. But the song holds its own, all low bass and Lewis' confident and pissed off vocals, and it barrels toward a thrilling finish line, complete with fun guitar solo.
This is a tough one. I think I gotta go with the song that was such a surprise to see in the Elite Eight, a song that continues to surprise me every time I hear it during this exercise.
WINNER: "Be Good"
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
"untitled 05 | 9.21.2014" by Kendrick Lamar VS. "Radio Silence" by Shearwater
Kendrick Lamar compiled a bunch of throwaway tracks for his 2016 compilation untitled. unmastered., but because it's Kendrick, there isn't very much that a normal rapper could conceivably consider "throwaway." "untitled 05" was first performed (kind of) at the 2016 Grammys the previous month. It's an outtake from To Pimp a Butterfly, so it's all about social inequality. I am woefully unqualified to speak to its veracity in that regard, but the song has made it all the way to the Elite Eight because the raps are over this smooth-as-fuck jazz groove that gets under my skin every time.
You probably couldn't engineer a match-up with more different songs than these. Whereas "untitled 05" slinks along and makes you nod your head right along, "Radio Silence" makes you want to rip your shirt off. Shearwater was originally a side project of Okkervil River, but Okkervil River keyboardist Jonathan Meiburg eventually quit to focus on Shearwater. At this point, I don't think there are many similarities between the two bands, besides the fact that each can reach those fucking heights that make me know why I like music in the first place. When Meiburg shouts out "Disarray!" you really feel like the whole world is in disarray at that moment.
So really, this comes down to a question of what music means to me. Kendrick says more, but Shearwater makes me feel more. It's a tough decision, but I'm a sucker with my heart on my sleeve.
WINNER: "Radio Silence"
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
"Tombstone Shadow" by Creedence Clearwater Revival VS. "White Crosses" by Against Me!
Creedence is probably the only band in the Elite Eight that would need no explanation to a casual music listener. They have a bunch of hits on classic rock radio, you know the ones. "Tombstone Shadow," however, is not one of them. CCR was a prolific band, and they have a lot of worthy deep cuts, and "Tombstone Shadow" can definitely be counted as worthy. Essential? Probably not. It's a by-the-books southern-tinged rock 'n' roll. But that's what makes it so great. You find comfort in this type of classic rock. That's why it's called "classic"!
Against Me! is not a classic rock band, but they've been around long enough that they might as well be considered classic. This, except for the fact that they've reinvented themselves a few times, and so each Against Me! era seems fresh and original. They are currently the world's most kick-ass LGBTQ punk band, and they started with DIY anarchist roots, but in the middle era, they were a somewhat radio friendly, politically involved pop punk band. This is where we find "White Crosses," a pro-life anthem sung with mean hooks and Laura Jane Grace giving it her all. Dismissed at the time, I'd call this Against Me! song integral.
Both are great fucking songs. Even though both songs have the specter of death hanging over them, only one of them is a song that we absolutely need.
WINNER: "White Crosses"
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
ELITE EIGHT RESULTS / FINAL FOUR
![]() |
| CLICK TO ENLARGE |
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
"Don't Call Upon Me" by Music Band VS. "Be Good" by Black Prairie
In many ways, comparing music is a lot different than comparing basketball teams. Two basketball teams may have different ways in which they run an offense, but at the end of the day, each team is still trying to shoot a ball in a hoop, and successfully complete that task more times than the other team. With music, two songs can be trying to do completely different things, and both can achieve what they set out to do by creating the song. How do you determine who completes their task better if the tasks are completely different?
"Don't Call Upon Me" and "Be Good" each try to be a certain type of song, and each is very successful at it. "Don't Call Upon Me" is a punk rock ripper that gets in and out and shouts along a chorus during its brief time on the stereo. "Be Good" lingers and tugs at the heartstrings. To say that one song is better than the other would be insane. They are both great.
But in lieu of just flipping a coin, let's examine if either of these songs achieve more by what they set out to do. Let's assume that Music Band wants you to not think too much about "Don't Call Upon Me" because it's supposed to be fun and worry-free. Let's assume that Black Prairie wants you to really let "Be Good" sink it, wants the song to fucking mean something, even if that takes away from any excitement one might get from it. If we assume both of these two things are true, and both bands are successful in doing what they want, then this means that, at the end of the day, only one song is sticking with me.
Penalizing Music Band for this reason is unfair, because they didn't create a song to last, they created a song to make your emotions flair up, briefly. But fuck it, man, I have to pick something, so this is what I'm going with.
WINNER: "Be Good"
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
"Radio Silence" by Shearwater VS. "White Crosses" by Against Me!
Unlike the other Final Four match-up, I think Shearwater and Against Me! are going for the same feelings here—let's get pumped the fuck up!—but both go about it in completely different ways.
"Radio Silence" is a musical journey. The drums click at a constant pace, but the guitar theatrics around it drop in and out to build suspense, to release that tension, to build again. "Radio Silence," as its title suggests, has parts that are soft and quiet, but it's the type of song that you know only has quiet parts so the loud parts stand out. The lyrics are cryptic and full of symbolism, and mainly serve to heighten the drama of the music itself. And it works!
"White Crosses," conversely, rests on the merits of its lyrics. It paints a picture of a protagonist who is strung out, at the end of her rope, so angry and distraught that the only release she can find might just be to smash some church property. Meanwhile, the instrumentation wrapped around the lyrics are as tight as ever—Against Me! is really underrated as a punk band, to be honest.
I'll stick with the metrics of the previous match-up. Which song is sticking with me at the end of the day? Both songs make me want to smash shit, but only one song really makes the case as to why smashing shit might be the right thing to do. Both songs have layers, but only one holds a layer that really makes me consider myself and my own actions, and that's a powerful fucking thing for a song to be able to do.
WINNER: "White Crosses"
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
CHAMPIONSHIP ROUND PREVIEW
![]() |
| CLICK TO ENLARGE |
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
See you Saturday as we name the ultimate winner of PoYB's inaugural March Madness Shuffle!












No comments:
Post a Comment