Thursday, March 14, 2019

A Non-Review: Leaving Neverland


I only have a few things to say about the harrowing documentary Leaving Neverland that you wouldn't be able to read in more established and worthy online publications. I don't necessarily need to rehash the details and history of Michael Jackson's sexual abuse toward young children—a four-hour documentary is right there if you need to know more. And I don't need to make a case for "believing the victims." If you have watched Leaving Neverland and you still don't believe that Jackson sexually abused children, then you are either an insane conspiracy theorist, or so incredibly lacking in human empathy that you are qualified to be a Republican congressman.

But I do have a few observations, and they are unique because, as always here on PoYB, we turn our eyes inward, and self-reflect. This doesn't make blogging fit for mass consumption—who the fuck wants to constantly read about a blogger who is this obsessed with himself?—but it's the blog you are reading now, and so, we continue.

OBSERVATION ONE

Leaving Neverland is split into two parts. Part one focuses on the abuse itself—how it came to be, and the sick details of the acts themselves. Part two focuses on the aftermath for the victims—some of how the Jackson trials affected his victims, but mostly how those victims came to terms with the fact that they were indeed abused.

After we finished part two, Pam said that she thought that part one was the more affecting of the two. I think that's the normal reaction, because hearing about the intimate details of a man sexually abusing young boys is tough. But I disagreed with her assessment. I handled part one fine, but part two had me in tears. I think this speaks to my strengths and weaknesses as a social worker.

And this might even speak more to my weaknesses as a human being, but the fact of the matter is, I'm fucking numb to hearing about abuse at this point. The gory details (that I will not repeat here) of Jackson's abuse didn't really phase me. I'm not saying I felt nothing. I'm not a fucking monster. I'm saying that I was able to handle hearing about it without much issue. I unfortunately hear about all kinds of child abuse and neglect all day, every day.

When part two started delving into how these sexual abuses affected these very real human beings, and how the allegations practically tore families apart, that's when I start to feel like I couldn't handle it. I feel as helpless as the victims and their families. It's a feeling of: I don't know how to make this better; I'm not qualified to even try to help; I am worthless.

My current role as a social worker is on the front end of the response to child abuse, and, based on how I reacted to the various parts of this documentary, the front end suits me just fine. My job is to go into homes, assess if there was abuse, get the details, and then delegate to the appropriate professionals. When a little boy tells me that his stepfather punched him in the face for no apparent reason, there's no moment where I put my hand to my mouth in horror or gasp or anything like that. That's not how I'm built. I get the details as best I can, and start contacting the appropriate long-term case managers. My first and only reaction is: "this family needs assistance."

But I can't be the person to give that assistance. I wouldn't be able to work with a family for weeks, months, years after the abuse. I can't help them pick up the pieces. It would fucking break me. I feel so much for the Robson and Safechuck families that I am almost crying now, typing about it.

I'm talking in circles. Suffice it to say that my first thought after watching the entirety of Leaving Neverland was how fortunate it is I get to be a cog in society's machine designed to get abused children help, but how equally fortunate I am that I became the appropriate cog in that machine right from the start of my career.

OBSERVATION TWO

At various times in the past few years, I've struggled with the idea of "art vs. artist," i.e. whether the actions of the artist should affect how you view their art. My thoughts have evolved. I think I'm at a place right now where I'm comfortable saying that it's a case-by-case basis. I'm also pretty comfortable in saying that, in this particular case, after watching Leaving Neverland, that I will never purposefully listen to a Michael Jackson song ever again.

That's easier said than done, of course; I have a few things to consider. What about Jackson 5 material? "I Want You Back" and "ABC" are two of my favorite songs of all time. They are perfect songs. And Michael Jackson was eleven years old when he sang the fuck out of those songs, well before he started abusing any children himself. But are any of these excuses? How can I ever possibly listen to "I Want You Back" ever again without knowing the monster who sang it? Or how about even supporting the family who called these victims "liars" and that they "just wanted the money"? I don't even know if I can listen to Alien Ant Farm's cover of "Smooth Criminal" anymore. That band did nothing wrong, but the song was written by an actual criminal. The worst kind of criminal. I just don't think I can do it.

What pains me the most is that I am going to hear plenty of Michael Jackson songs in the future. I'll be on the wedding dance floor and "Don't Stop 'Til You Get Enough" is going to come on. I can't dance to that.

But people will dance to it, and this will be my biggest struggle. Ultimately, I need to come to terms with the fact that the people who remain on the dance floor, those who keep Thriller on the turntables, etc., that these people are not the monsters here. I disagree with their decisions, but it's their decision to make. Some people want to separate completely the art from the artist. I can't do that, but what am I going to do, unplug the DJ's speakers? That's called being an insufferable asshole. I don't want that either. 

I just want to listen to some music and appreciate that the music was made by someone who didn't commit unspeakable crimes. This means that I have to never purposefully listen to Michael Jackson's music again. It's not even a fucking choice.

OBSERVATION THREE

Puke on Your Birthday has actually written about Michael Jackson before. During its nascent days, I offered a rather flippant response to Jackson's death. I actually forgot that I had written anything at all until after I started watching Leaving Neverland, and so after I finished watching, I went back and read it again for the first time in a while.

There's a decent amount that I still agree with—mostly, the parts about how social media trivializes death. But I was fucking aghast that I had actually mentioned Neverland and child molestation in this essay, and it was almost played as a joke. Holy shit. This is bad, folks.

What's concerning to me is that I knew so little about Michael Jackson in 2009, and yet I was still aware enough of his crimes that I could mention them in a blog post. I wrote it, it's right there. I knew about his abusing of children. But I didn't do shit about it.

Neither did anyone, apparently. It took a horrifying four-hour documentary beating us over the head with it for America to wake the fuck up to the monster that Michael Jackson was. I offer no excuses for myself. I'm not going to say "it was a different time" or that I was ten years younger and less mature. There's really no excuse. Something had been known since I was five years old—that Jackson was credibly alleged to have molested young boys—and I didn't even give it space in my brain until I was thirty years old.

We need to believe victims of sex abuse. I know that now. And I'm ashamed that I didn't know it then.

No comments: