This review is a tough one to write, because I'm battling my own preconceived notions of Foals. This is all my fault, it has nothing to do with the band. They sound how they sound. That Foals sounds like an I HEART RADIO 104.5 band is not their fault. That I am enjoying this album immensely gives me pause. Maybe I have been wrong this whole time about that radio station (haha, nah, fuck Twenty One Pilots, fuck Bastille, fuck Imagine Dragons, fuck that one Portugal. the Man song, fuck 104.5, ahem, ANYWAY).
Once I got over myself, I found Foals' newest to be perfectly palatable dance rock that got better with each listen. Everything Not Saved Will Be Lost is commendable as an exercise in a band fucking going for it. The "Part 1" should tip you off that they have grander ambitions. The cinematic scope of many of these songs should confirm it for you.
But do they go all the way? It's hard to say by the time we reach the end of the final track. There are some fucking jams on here, for sure, songs that reach for the heights that Foals are going for, and then actually fucking reach them. "White Onions" is the best example, a swirl of chiming synths and crunching guitars, with a chorus that just fucking pummels you. Or maybe "Syrups" might be a better example, I dunno. That song starts low with a slinky groove but eventually builds into an absolute burner.
If other songs don't reach those same towering heights, then at least there's enough here to keep things interesting. Basically anytime those sixteenth-note synth loops show up (it happens a lot), I appreciate it; you know, the rhythmic synth loops that they stole from LCD Soundsystem, who themselves stole it from a lot of older bands that I'm not as familiar with. E.g., I wonder what the Talking Heads would have to say about Everything Not Saved. But fuck it, I like it all the same. It keeps things moving.
I love the claps at the end of each verse in "On the Luna." I love how "Exits" employs a stuttering, almost Wolf Parade-esque hit hat rhythm. I love the vibraphones and xylophones all over "Cafe d'Athens." The thing of it is, I could keep going. There's a lot to like, and I could eventually probably convince myself that this is a all-caps GREAT album.
But I can't quite bring myself to do it. I can't quite bring myself to believe that this album's whole is more than the sum of its parts. Maybe that has something to do with the fact that it is indeed a "Part 1," and I'm not seeing the whole picture. Maybe it has something to do with the fact that the final three songs are fucking Coldplay-lite bummers, and completely derail the momentum that was built so skillfully during the first 2/3rds. Maybe it's because the name of the album comes from a fucking meme.
Or maybe I'm just a shitty music critic who refuses to believe that there are albums out there that can just exist and be joyful and not have to meet some subjective standard. If I'm a shitty music critic—likely—then consider the fact that you might love Foals. If you believe me—for whatever backwards reason—then you'll like this one a lot, but in a few years, you'll jam out to "White Onions" in your Kia Sportage on some road trip, and you'll have no subsequent desire to revisit this album.
For now, though, fuck it, let's give it a good grade.
GRADE: 3.5 pukes out of 5
Once I got over myself, I found Foals' newest to be perfectly palatable dance rock that got better with each listen. Everything Not Saved Will Be Lost is commendable as an exercise in a band fucking going for it. The "Part 1" should tip you off that they have grander ambitions. The cinematic scope of many of these songs should confirm it for you.
But do they go all the way? It's hard to say by the time we reach the end of the final track. There are some fucking jams on here, for sure, songs that reach for the heights that Foals are going for, and then actually fucking reach them. "White Onions" is the best example, a swirl of chiming synths and crunching guitars, with a chorus that just fucking pummels you. Or maybe "Syrups" might be a better example, I dunno. That song starts low with a slinky groove but eventually builds into an absolute burner.
If other songs don't reach those same towering heights, then at least there's enough here to keep things interesting. Basically anytime those sixteenth-note synth loops show up (it happens a lot), I appreciate it; you know, the rhythmic synth loops that they stole from LCD Soundsystem, who themselves stole it from a lot of older bands that I'm not as familiar with. E.g., I wonder what the Talking Heads would have to say about Everything Not Saved. But fuck it, I like it all the same. It keeps things moving.
I love the claps at the end of each verse in "On the Luna." I love how "Exits" employs a stuttering, almost Wolf Parade-esque hit hat rhythm. I love the vibraphones and xylophones all over "Cafe d'Athens." The thing of it is, I could keep going. There's a lot to like, and I could eventually probably convince myself that this is a all-caps GREAT album.
But I can't quite bring myself to do it. I can't quite bring myself to believe that this album's whole is more than the sum of its parts. Maybe that has something to do with the fact that it is indeed a "Part 1," and I'm not seeing the whole picture. Maybe it has something to do with the fact that the final three songs are fucking Coldplay-lite bummers, and completely derail the momentum that was built so skillfully during the first 2/3rds. Maybe it's because the name of the album comes from a fucking meme.
Or maybe I'm just a shitty music critic who refuses to believe that there are albums out there that can just exist and be joyful and not have to meet some subjective standard. If I'm a shitty music critic—likely—then consider the fact that you might love Foals. If you believe me—for whatever backwards reason—then you'll like this one a lot, but in a few years, you'll jam out to "White Onions" in your Kia Sportage on some road trip, and you'll have no subsequent desire to revisit this album.
For now, though, fuck it, let's give it a good grade.
GRADE: 3.5 pukes out of 5

No comments:
Post a Comment