Wednesday, September 1, 2021

Never Seen It, #57 of 200: The English Patient

Looking back over the pages of my life, thinking about all the movies I've never seen, trying to die with some dignity and watch as many as I can.


The English Patient
1996
Anthony Minghella

Is Katharine Clifton a Manic Pixie Dream Girl? Let's check the official definition, and see if it fits: a MPDG "exists solely in the fevered imaginations of sensitive writer-directors to teach broodingly soulful young men to embrace life and its infinite mysteries and adventures." Hmm. I don't know if it quite fits. Katharine definitely teaches Almásy how to "embrace life" in their relationship, but she exists as her own person too, with her own struggles (or, as Winslet's character in Eternal Sunshine says: "I'm just a fucked-up girl who's lookin' for my own peace of mind."). And the whole "embracing life" thing comes part and parcel to the relationship itself—Almásy embraces life because being in love is his life—whereas a typical MPDG is more of a stepping stone to the male's understanding of himself. Plus, Kristin Scott Thomas plays her as pretty grounded, and I always feel like MPDGs should be a little more whimsical, right? (Though Dionna was right—Scott Thomas is beautiful, MPDG or no.)

Alright, so that's bullshit. That's just me grasping at straws here. I'm trying to come up with something more interesting than "this was another epic love story across the ages," because we just fucking did something like that. (Even Ebert eluded to Lean in his English Patient review.) And so what else is there to really talk about, as far as theme goes?

We even already talked in Doctor Zhivago about how the main character's infidelity was not really addressed by the film, and whether it should be, a question I have for The English Patient as well. Look, I'm not here to play morality police, obviously. But the subject interests me in film, and so I want the film that features something like a romance like this to at least attempt to tell me what the film itself thinks about all this. Is the film trying to say that it doesn't matter whether Katharine Clifton was married already, because she was in love with Almásy and their love seemed true? Or should we be weary of their romance, because it started under such shaky circumstances? I don't get a sense of any of this in The English Patient.

Which is a shame, because then it would at least thematically mirror the romance that's going on in the framing device between Juliette Binoche's Hana and Naveen Andrews' Kip (goddamn, it was good to see Sayid again). Hana explicitly worries that their romance is doomed because she is "cursed," with tension added because we're wondering whether that curse is going to kill Kip when he is defusing a bomb. Say we try to find a metaphorical "bomb" in Almásy and Katharine's relationship. What is it? Katharine's marriage? Does it blow up when her husband attempts murder-suicide-by-airplane? Was their relationship always doomed?

I don't know if I just talked myself into it just there, or if I feel like I'm just grasping at straws. It's okay for a movie to be unclear, and maybe this one purposefully was, but the whole "I wonder what it all means" doesn't really work when there is a framing device of the main character telling his life story. He's had plenty of time to think about what he believes it all means, so why not share it with the audience?

I guess the framing device is really the only difference between this and Doctor Zhivago. It adds a little extra to the movie (plus, we get to see Ralph Fiennes in proto-Voldemort makeup). But not much. It's an epic romance, right? And so all the stuff with the other romance happening in the present, plus all the thumbless Willem Dafoe stuff, kinda seems extraneous, thinking back. I dunno, Binoche won an Oscar for her role, so maybe I'm missing something.

Or maybe I just need to take a longer break in between epic war romances. Three weeks was too short.

GRADE: 2.5 pukes out of 5

NEXT TIME: I assumed that Erin Brockovich was a rom-com, but Pam tells me I am mistaken, so I will report next week how mistaken I was.