Thursday, September 9, 2021

The Villain of Puke on Your Birthday

I had to go back to the '80s to find a picture of Charlie smiling

The death of Charlie Watts a couple weeks ago was pretty impactful for Puke on Your Birthday, because he was closest thing we had to a "villain" character on the blog. That's why I felt the need to rush a blog post within the hour that the news broke, even though in retrospect it feels a millimeter on the side of disrespectful. I've made my supposed dislike of Charlie Watts pretty clear over the past few years, and so I thought it was important to grapple with the fact that a so-called nemesis was no longer with us, and the complicated feelings one has when something like that happens.

I can also see how such an in-joke might seem profane and sacrilegious to passersby visiting the blog for the first time in a while. If you aren't familiar with the running gag that I hated Charlie Watts for increasingly inconsequential reasons, then reading about how he "sucks ass" on the same day that he passed away might make me seem like the worst person in the world.

And maybe I am! I got that sense when an anonymous person commented on the blog post: "wow, joe." Her/his cutting brevity makes me think that maybe I have been misunderstood, or maybe s/he is rightly pointing out that the post was mean-spirited. I got incredibly defensive when I saw that someone had anonymously commented on the post, which I have a history of doing, but also I was completely ready to own up to anything I did wrong, if that were the case. Anonymous (okay: Rusty Rucker) never responded, though, so that was that.

If it was weird to rush off to a blog to write some petty bullshit immediately after someone died, then I'll contest that it would've been even weirder if Puke on Your Birthday didn't comment on Charlie's death at all. What, I'm supposed to spend three years yapping about Charlie Watts and then not saying anything when he's dead? That doesn't ring true. If there really is a heaven and/or a hell, I truly believe that Charlie is up or down there, realizing that some no-name shit blog had a tag entitled "Charlie Watts Sucks Ass," and is laughing his ass off, probably harder than he ever has in his life (since the bar is not that high).

See, that final dig should reveal how much is actually at stake here: nothing. The Charlie Watts on Puke on Your Birthday is a character, and any wisecracks directed toward him were in a joking matter. It goes beyond punching up; Charlie's stature is so much taller than my own that not even Stretch Armstrong could land that punch. My expressed opinions are based on true opinions—yes, I do think that Charlie Watts is overrated as a drummer, and yes, I do think that being a stiff unpleasant asshole behind the drum kit is not something to be celebrated—but when I say that I want to beat up Charlie Watts, that's using exaggeration for effect. It's supposed to be funny, because you're not actually supposed to think that I would ever try to beat up Charlie Watts.

The fact that I need to explain this means it was a bad joke (and explaining it only makes it worse), so I'll take the blame in that regard. But I don't take back anything I've ever said about Charlie Watts, because the tongue was mostly in cheek. I get why that might not have come through in my obituary for him. If you just clicked on a Twitter link because you were curious, then maybe you thought I was a monster. I took down the Twitter link; maybe it also seemed like I was promoting my blog on the back of someone's death? I don't know, man. It's all pretty complicated. It's at least twenty times as complicated as Charlie Watts' drumming.

No, see... I gotta stop doing that. The man is passed away. I can't take any more cracks at him, that would be wrong. Charlie Watts is officially retired as the villain of Puke on Your Birthday.

That leaves us with a different problem, though: the space Charlie Watts vacated now leaves a vacuum where the Puke on Your Birthday Villain should be. If we can't use Charlie Watts as the whipping boy on this blog, then who could possibly fill his spot?

I don't know if there is an easy answer to this, because Charlie filled such a unique roll in music history and pop culture.

For one, he was, by all accounts, very good at his job. His job was something I am intimately familiar with for multiple reasons (music is a current hobby, drumming is a former hobby). I was in the 0.01% in terms of having a negative opinion about him, which checked one box for me (having opposing opinions is cool), but also my opinion wasn't just for the sake of my joy in arguing. I also really believed that Charlie Watts was overrated, and had x, y, and z reasons in believing so. However, those reasons were still, in the general scope of things, pretty unimportant, i.e. Charlie Watts was not a criminal, sex abuser, anything like that. He just seemed generally stuck-up and unpleasant, and there aren't many celebrities or musicians that are able to thread that needle. It's usually either "he's a good guy," or "he should never work again," and to have a guy for whom it was just like "he seems like a deeply unpleasant person and I never would actually want to grab a beer with him" was very strange and, honestly, make it even more off-putting to think about him.

Okay, so who could possibly fill these shoes on the blog? I could only come up with three people who would even come close. There aren't many celebrities that I regularly diss on here (and "regular" meaning "more than once").

Post Malone was the person I thought of first. He's been brought up in a negative light plenty of times over the years, not even including his week of Record Club. He is still my go-to example of hookless, unpleasant modern pop music. But that's the difference between him and Charlie Watts—my issues with Posty stop at his music. I have zero evidence stating that Post Malone is anything but a genial person, extremely fun to be around, with a winning deadpan personality, and self-deprecating when the time calls for it (remember when his fans wanted him on Queer Eye?). Post Malone would laugh a lot if he read the harsh criticisms I throw his way on the blog. Even though I joked above about Charlie laughing in hell, if he were still on earth and read Puke on Your Birthday, he would take it waaaay too seriously. So Post Malone is not a villain. If his music were more my speed, he might even be the hero.
 
There's also Jimmy Fallon, but as we discussed last week, the man has been revealed to be more than just a pest at this point. When you're facilitating child abuse, then the fun and games immediately cease. In fact, this is one of those case when I am less inclined to even mention him on the blog, now that shit is really serious, and he is exposed as a true menace. Things were a lot better when he was just an annoying turd! Charlie Watts sucks ass, but he's never, ever, ever done anything like that (hopefully!).

Finally, I guess Bill Murray could be up for debate. I feel like he's been mentioned a lot fewer times than Watts, Malone, and Fallon, but there's still multiple instances of me expressing my "humorous" disdain for him. There's evidence that he's not really that great of a person in real life, but it's just run of the mill asshole stuff, i.e. nothing criminal, but also nothing that is so outrageous that it becomes funny. Watts had a lot of the latter. Also, I feel the opposite about Bill Murray's acting than I do Charlie Watts' drumming. Both are average at best at their chosen craft, but Murray's performance could be elevated to great heights with the right director, script, production, whatever, whereas Charlie did nothing but drag the Stones down.

I can't think of anyone else who could fill Charlie's shoes here on Puke on Your Birthday. Maybe it's better that we don't have a villain at all. Maybe it's better if we try to spread peace and love instead of spreading disdain for those who may or may not deserve it. Maybe all of this is just taking the blog way too seriously. I'm gonna guess it's that last option.

No comments: