Thursday, September 30, 2021

Jimmies


Mister Softee drove down our street last night for what was probably the last time this season (unless the F.O.P. is still trying to Fire Krasner, but the ice cream would this time be promoting a Republican who murdered his girlfriend in the bathtub... I digress). That got me thinking about the rumor that I hear at least once a summer, while eating a soft serve cone with sugary toppings—is the term "jimmies" racist?

The urban legend states that chocolate sprinkles are called "jimmies" in some regions (including the generally racist Northeast Philadelphia) after Jim Crow. The myth explains that this is why all-chocolate sprinkles are jimmies, and rainbow-colored sprinkles are just "sprinkles." As someone who has called the topping "jimmies" for as long as I can remember (for real—one of my earliest memories is eating a sundae with jimmies at Grandpop's house in Lawncrest, it must've been like 1992), the first time I heard this urban legend, it gave me pause. Was it racist?

There are three paths to take when considering the veracity and impact of this rumor.

One: it's not true. There is no evidence that it is not racist, but there is more importantly not a single piece of historical evidence that proves that it is racist. If the burden of proof lies with the accuser, then we can take this as truth: the term "jimmies" has never been racist. Snopes did a whole article about the claim, and they uncovered nothing (indeed, a majority of the write-up covers who invented the term, but the conclusion is that, whoever invented it, it has nothing to do with Jim Crow or racism or race at all). So there is nothing to feel bad about, if you used "jimmies" to describe ice cream toppings, and still continue to use it.

Two: who the fuck am I to say what is and isn't racist? Ultimately, if someone is legitimately offended by something, then the burden falls on me to respect that, and to do my best not to offend. What is deemed "offensive" (or, more specifically, "racist") is not for me to decide. It's like when streaming services pulled the Community episode with Chang painted as a dark elf, and the joke was that it wasn't supposed to be blackface, and yet Shirley and Pierce both assumed it was blackface. The character didn't intend it to be blackface, and the context indicated that it definitely wasn't blackface. But it doesn't matter. If someone is offended by the portrayal, then it is racist. End of story. A better example is the "OK" hand signal (index and thumb together, other three fingers out). This was never racist in any way—it literally meant "OK"—but since white supremacists have adopted it as their own signal, it is indeed racist to make the OK sign. So I dunno, I guess I'm saying that if there comes a time that a P.O.C. is offended by "jimmies," then ya gotta respect that. No room for any "um, actually"s.

Three: it's probably actually racist at this point to bring up the urban legend at all. Think about it this way—is there any benefit to white supremacy if this rumor continues to spread? The one I can think of is that it gives racists an excuse to mock something that is so-called racist. This is called reductio ad absurdum, or an "appeal to extremes." It's a logical fallacy that states that if the most extreme example is false, then all of it is false. Just because it is wrong to call jimmies "racist," doesn't mean that there aren't plenty of other terms that have a racist history, and that we shouldn't use them. Though it's easy to imagine a racist uncle bringing this up, right? "Oh man, we can't even use the word 'jimmies' now?! Black people have gone too far!" It's the use of an extreme example (and in this case, a false extreme) to make the rest of the argument look stupid. It's like when the rumor about Paw Patrol getting rid of their cop dog started spreading around the same time as the Defund the Police movement started picking up steam. "What? We can't even have fictional police dogs on children's television now? If this is what 'defund the police' looks like then I don't support it!" and so on.

Basically, you don't have to be worried about what to call tiny milk chocolate confections on top of your ice cream, but you do have to be worried about who is telling you this urban legend, and why. If someone is genuinely worried that a childhood term means that they are being inadvertently racist, then there's plenty of evidence to correct them and allay their worries. If someone is saying that the term "jimmies" offends them as a person of color, then there is much less room for correction—though hopefully some room for fact-based understanding, in this particular case. And if someone is using this urban legend as a bad faith measuring stick for racism, then it is on you to correct not only the falsehoods, but also the faulty logic behind believing that falsehood in the first place.

And then when you're done all that, grab an ice cream cone, and pretend that another great Philadelphia summer isn't over.

No comments: