![]() |
| (not too many pics of the two of these guys together, hence all the cartoons and splitscreens this week) |
If you're into gimmicks—which, I am, clearly—then the first thing you're gonna notice is that this album—A Beginner's Mind, by Sufjan Stevens and Angelo De Augustine—is comprised of fourteen tracks, and each of them are inspired by a different movie. With such a gimmick, I am under the assumption that in order to fully "get" this album, you would have needed to see, or at least be familiar with, all the movies on the list. If that's true, then the flaw in A Beginner's Mind's plan is manifested in me, not in the album itself.
One of the main sources of tension on Puke on Your Birthday is between my admitted ignorance when it comes to film, and my insistence on documenting my thoughts about film anyway. There's the whole Never Seen It project that exists for this purpose (one film that inspired a song is already on that list, and about a half dozen more should have been). But now it's interesting to be faced with the prospect of exploring an album that exists as a meditation on a whole bunch of movies that I've never seen, because I am still at the point where I feel far, far away from being a "film buff," and so if Stevens and De Augustine are trying to say something about these films, then it's going to go completely over my head.
Or maybe that's not the point. Maybe the point is that the artists here are simply using the films as a jumping-off point to explore more nuanced topics. I can't imagine that Sufjan Stevens would be involved in anything as pedestrian as "Here's a song about Keanu Reeves in Point Blank." Of course it's going to be more than that. Maybe saying A Beginner's Mind is about movies is akin to saying Tommy is about blindness, or The Monitor is about the Civil War. There's another level at work here.
Still, I do think that it might be easier to uncover that level if I at least had seen a few more of the movies on the list. Maybe it's a coincidence, but I don't think it is—what I perceive to be the two best songs on this album are also the two songs based on movies that I've already seen. "Back to Oz" is the one song that finds its groove, and it tries to get into the headspace of Dorothy in the truly frightening 1985 sequel Return to Oz. The Silence of the Lambs tune "Cimmerian Shade," meanwhile, pulls the same trick that "John Wayne Gacy, Jr." did sixteen years ago—"let's examine this irredeemable monster, because right now I feel so low about myself that I might as well be on their level."
Now, the emotions explored in these two songs—the feeling of unease as you return to the place you thought you had escaped; the sickening exploration of your own darkest flaws—could be considered universal, and yet I'll ague that it was helpful to understand the specific reference points that Stevens and De Augustine were starting from. On the other hand, heard in a vacuum, these really are two of the better sounding songs on an album of slow, sad songs.
I would say that about one-third of A Beginner's Mind is completely forgettable, no matter how many times I listen to it. If we're talking raw numbers, that's a better ratio than most albums. I'm looking at the tracklist now... have I ever even heard "You Give Death a Bad Name"? Or "Lost in the World"? As you may well know by now, my own personal tastes tend toward faster, louder music, and there's a line you can cross as an artist who specializes in slow/sad. Sufjan has historically toed that line better than pretty much any artist I've ever loved, but that doesn't mean he can't occasionally cross it. Like, there's a reason that "Back to Oz" is gonna show up on the year-end Best Songs list, just like "Should Have Known Better" was the obvious highlight of Carrie and Lowell—these are the songs with the most energy on their respective albums, full stop.
At the same time, there is plenty to mine from these certifiable slow songs. They may lack my preferred tempo, but there's still a pulse. "Lady Macbeth in Chains" has some movement to it, and ends with a electro-ambient outro that feels like "vintage" Sufjan, whatever that means. "It's Your Own Body and Mind" has our guaranteed prettiest-vocals-ever performance (I love the way he stretches out "She's got a habiiiiiit"). "The Pillar of Souls" is a bombastic reach back into The Age of Adz. "Olympus" feels like it could've been on a Sufjan Christmas album with some lyric changes. "Murder and Crime" sounds like De Augustine doing his best Elliott Smith impression, and succeeding.
Okay, that reminds me, we really should talk about the equal billing aspect of A Beginner's Mind. I suppose it's inevitable that people are going to see this album through the lens of their feelings about Sufjan Stevens. (E.g., Angelo De Augustine's name was nowhere to be found on the website where I illegally downloaded the album.) I kinda feel bad about that! Because this otherwise seems like a true collaborative effort, and as "Murder and Crime" confirms that De Augustine can hold his own. Still, the shadow of Sufjan Stevens is just too large.
It's probably because they have similar sensibilities as musicians, from what I can tell here. Indie folk with a quasi-religious bent and slight experimental tendencies. I mean, that's kind of their shared label Asthmatic Kitty's whole thing, right? I remember listening to an A.K. compilation back in the day, and buying an album from one of the artists based on his featured song alone. It ended up being an album that was literally about the Bible. A little too much! But Asthmatic Kitty seems to have a "type," which means that two artists collaborating is going to seem too much of a like-and-like situation than generating any meaningful friction. At least A Beginner's Mind isn't about the Bible. (That aforementioned song, by the way, was "Can't Even Breathe on My Own Two Feet," which, despite the lingering Jesus-twee aspect to it, still slays me.)
Don't let any of this distract you from the biggest caveat here in my review: I am a huge Sufjan Stevens fan, and so my opinions of this album are absolutely going to be refracted through my already established opinion about the undisputed "lead artist" on this album. More so than discussing the merits of the album itself, I'm interested in exploring where A Beginner's Mind falls in the Sufjan canon, i.e. how it compares to previous masterpieces and flops, what that says about the artist himself, and so on. Hopefully, if you don't like Sufjan Stevens or don't give a fuck, you've already checked out.
Look, I love Sufjan Stevens. But to love an artist means to understand his flaws. The way I see it is that at least 50% of the music that Sufjan produces is going to be undesirable, but that other 50% is so goddamn genius and towers so high that it almost doesn't even fucking matter that there exist some truly middling and even terrible Sufjan albums. And that's okay! It's just a matter of knowing where to turn when you need a hit. For example, did anyone listen to Convocations earlier this year? It's a five-album collection of ambient noise, so if you said "yes," you're a liar. I don't mind, though. The best part about bad music is that you don't have to listen to it (unless it's picked for Record Club, but thankfully Convocations was ineligible due to it being two and half hours long).
A Beginner's Mind is similar to something like Carrie and Lowell, in that it features mostly sparsely-instrumented but pretty ballads sung softly and intimately, which isn't quite my speed, but definitely hits me a certain way when done right. This actually brings me back to my first point—the movies. The more I think about it, the more I believe that an album like this comes at the perfect time in the Sufjan discography. I imagine Sufjan thought of it like a challenge: "Okay, people liked Carrie and Lowell, but I wonder if that was because I was singing about the personal pain experienced in my childhood. If I applied the same musical template to, say, a fucking straight-to-video Bring It On sequel, would people still appreciate it as much?"
Again, it's never been quite my speed, and I feel like I'm missing something because of my film ignorance, but still, it works well enough that I enjoyed visiting it more than a few times this week. So yes, I'm sure people will appreciate this as much as they do some of the other Sufjan classics. As for myself, I'm trending in that direction, and I might get there. But I might not. Oh well. Good enough.
GRADE: 3.5 pukes out of 5

No comments:
Post a Comment