Wednesday, October 20, 2021

Highlight (a reevaluation)

Four days of reevaluating blog post ideas from the '00s. The original HERE.

~~~~~~~~~~~~


I don't even disagree with anything that Nick wrote in the original PoYB assessment of the Twilight series. This is silly stuff, and I probably didn't need to watch a movie to know it.

But, at the same time... maybe I did need to watch a movie to know it? I don't like forming opinions about things that I'm not familiar with. If I'm going to back up all the jokes that I made about Twilight in high school, then I'm going to have to watch at least one movie, right? Or else I'm just one more fucking internet nerd blasting some pop culture without knowing anything about it. If I'm going to be an iconoclast, I wanna know the icon I'm knocking down.

Or maybe Pam just wanted to watch the first film and I was cool to go along for the ride. Either way.

I am definitely going to take Nick's word about the books. We don't have a copy of any of them in the house (anymore), so I can't definitively say one way or the other how good/bad they are. But I will say, after having watched the movie, that if the books are a lot better than Nick describes them to be, then the movie did a truly awful job of translating that to the screen. The movie was bad. If the book is good, somehow, then we can safely say this is the worst adaptation of all time.

Occam's razor says the books are bad too, though.

Let's start with a slight defense before we move onto the travesties. An apologia: there is no set standard for what the idea of a "vampire" is. Sure, traditionally, they are monsters who kill, and sure, to portray a vampire as a sensitive teenager who glistens in the sun and falls in love is pretty silly on the surface. But who the fuck am I, the keeper of monster story law? Who the fuck says a vampire can't sparkle? If that's what they do in this world, then that's what they do. In fact, I'd almost be inclined to say that anyone who seeks to maintain the status quo in any arena, be it monster mythology or otherwise, can go fuck themselves. Let fiction be fiction and let it be whatever the fuck its author wants it to be.

Now that we have that out of the way, let us some wade through the many criticisms. Where to begin? I can probably just spend a paragraph or two naming some at random. Anything more than that would be beating this already dead horse, and as we all know, horses cannot rise from the dead to become vampires. Or can they?

The bad: the dialogue was truly embarrassing, to start. Pattison and Stewart have since turned into pretty good/great actors, but even they can't carry the water here. For another, the motivations were obtuse—wait, why was Bella cool with dating a vampire? Why was Edward all of a sudden cool with dating a human? Why was that other vampire so keen on murdering Bella? Why was everyone at the school okay with a bunch of pale foster kids who were clearly vampires just keeping to themselves and ostensibly fucking each other?

Speaking of which, why was it only clear to Bella that these folks were vampires? Seems like there were enough clues that someone would have figured it out before Bella did. And that really feels like a big picture problem with the movie too—every single goddamn person is going into the Twilight experience knowing that Edward Cullen is a vampire, and yet it takes Bella a FULL HOUR of the movie's runtime to figure it out and even say the word "vampire." C'mon! Get to the fireworks factory!!

I mean, there's a scene in which Edward gets frustrated with how slow Bella is walking, so he puts her on his back, and then speed-runs up a mountain via terrible special effects. Can't get much better than that.

There's nothing I can write right now that no one has already said. This is a movie made to face a lifetime of criticisms. It almost doesn't even fucking matter who says what where or when or how many times (total PoYB count now: 2). All that matters is that women find 2008 Robert Pattison attractive enough (and 2008 Kristin Stewart enough of a nonentity) that they are willing to pay money to see him swoon palely.

Reevaluation? Not really. I dislike Twilight about as much as Nick does, I assume (I'll have to ask him at his wedding in exactly 24 days). What I suppose I am really reevaluating is Twilight's right to exist. I have no problem with its place in our reality. It's like pop culture's speed bag—hit it 80 times a minute and it keeps coming back for more. There's a certain comfort in knowing that something is bad and that everyone you know thinks it's bad too.

Fuck Twilight? Nah. But I wouldn't watch the movies if I were you. Though it did end with a couple of great songs, not gonna lie.


No comments: