Listening to this album, I am taken back to the height of my pop-punk emo phase circa 2001-2008. Now in TYOOL 2021, I ask, "Who is this album for today?" Because like many of the emo kids of yore, I've moved onto the National / sad dad rock / queer indie pop / have fully given into Top 40 because it's just so easy. (And some of it is very, very good. Montero. I'm speaking specifically about Montero.)
Then it hit me. The whole emo thing is cycling back. We're at the near 20-year mark of its cultural impact (hahaha lololol I'm fine, I'm fine *pours collagen powder into coffee*). Why else would M*chine G*n K*lly even be here? He, after all, is a manufactured version of what us bleeding heart sad kids of the early 2000s once posed as in our MySpace and LiveJournal pages. This album belongs in both of those spaces—the try-hard imposters in what's happening now with emo and the earnest scene that was borne in YMCA basements and actual album liner notes.
Not to play the "I was there before it was popular card," but this album just lands so insincere. It's trying to do the metal-leaning Senses Fail / Glassjaw / Coheed of it all without the chords or lyrics that catch you off guard and make your heart sing when you're in the midst of a woeful singalong. Plus, "I'm Made of Wax" is ripping a chord / melody straight from Jimmy Eat World's "Bleed American." And this band started in that era.
I think that's why, as Cher Horowitz would say, "I'm totally buggin'." This album has the influence of, and was part of the same era as, so many of my former (and some still current) favorite bands... but none of it lands. Nor does it take me back to all of the good that came from that Manic Panic-ridden time. Nothing feels unique (title of my self-titled emo album) in a way that deserves a second listen.
Bands like you are a dime a dozen. *swings mic*
P.S. There are definite emo influences in Montero and it's done exactly right. It's what taking the ball and running with it sounds like.

No comments:
Post a Comment