Four days of reevaluating blog post ideas from the '00s. The original HERE.
~~~~~~~~~~~~
A couple weeks ago, I had to write a paper after taking an Implicit Association Test, a.k.a. a bias test. I had to take three, actually. The mandatory test was the racial bias test, which tested to see whether I had bias for/against white/black people. I did not have a bias, according to this test. The second test I took was a Sexuality IAT. It indicated I was not biased between gay/straight. The final test was the Disability IAT. The result: "slightly biased toward able people." Damn.
I understand that there are arguments against the validity of such tests, but for the purposes of this blog post, I'm going to take them at their word—I am slightly biased against the disabled. That doesn't make me feel very good. The ideal is equity, and this test is telling me that I'm not doing enough to strive for that ideal.
Is it true? Am I really biased? Took me a while to think of a good example, but as it turns out, all I had to do was dive into the PoYB archives.
Back in the day, there was a minor controversy in my hometown, Rockledge, a certifiable "small town" (there can't possibly be another town that shares a border with Philadelphia that is smaller than Rockledge's one square mile, right?). A sliver of the borough's budget was used in mid-2008 to paint the crosswalks with a fancy pattern. Here's a screenshot of Google street view from June 2012:
As documented on PoYB, there was a small group of Rockledge citizens who took issue with these patterns, claiming that it made certain individuals dizzy or sick. They were met—at least by me and the editors of PoYB and my other hometown friends—with mockery and contempt. The video didn't help:
It's been thirteen years since I've thought about this, but with the Disability IAT on my mind, I suddenly remembered how hard I came down on these anonymous Rockledge denizens (check out that video's comments if you don't believe me), and wondered whether, maybe, I was in the wrong after all. Was I biased?
Let's be clear here—the mockery came easy because of the ridiculous YouTube video with the farm animals and bad late-'00s internet graphics. At the time, my thoughts were: if you want to make an argument, don't do it with atrocious puns, do it with stats and fact sheets. The lips behind the sheep and cow were making purely anecdotal arguments. Where were the doctors? Where were the studies? And so on.
I don't know if those facts were ever provided, or if this really was the work of two people. But years later, I'm starting to consider the possibility that it might be a matter of asking: so what? So what if it was only a single-digit amount of people who wanted the crosswalks to change? Why wouldn't their opinion matter?
I've made this argument plenty of times, but as an example, let's think very briefly about the former Washington Redskins football team. It was a racist name, no question about it. Why was it racist? Because there are Native Americans who would take offense to the name, since "redskin" is a slur against indigenous people. I didn't need to hear firsthand testimony from any Native Americans in Maryland. I didn't need to see any poll research about whether Native Americans in MD cared enough about football to give a shit about a team name. My viewpoint was that if there was even a possibility that even one Native American was offended by the name of the team, then they had the moral obligation to change the name.
So why wouldn't this apply to Rockledge, PA? Should I need to have expert doctor opinions, or should I just consider the fact that there could be disabled people who get dizzy while crossing Blake Avenue? It is because of this possibility that we should take these arguments seriously. Sure, there's an effective way to make such an argument, and ClipArt barnyard animals is probably not the most effective way there is to make it, but fuck it. I'd be a hypocrite if I still held these beliefs that WE MUST PROTECT THE CROSSWALKS AT ALL COST BEACUSE IT'S A MATTER OF PRINCIPLE or whatever. In other words, I'd be biased toward the disabled.
(Sidenote: If we estimate that ten people in Rockledge cared about changing the crosswalks, then that percentage of the population (0.04%) is larger than the percentage of Maryland citizens who identify as fully Native American (0.03%). Food for thought!)
Writing on this blog sometimes feels like just one big project in categorizing every fault that I have ever seen in myself and every fucked up mistake that I've ever made and every regret that I've ever held as time goes by. Add this to the pile.
Because... well, I'm gonna tell you something that I've literally never told anyone else in my entire life. I swear to god this is true. There have been occasions—mostly walking home from McNally's, but occasionally other times—when I was walking past the intersection of Blake and Huntingdon Pike, and I swear to god, those crosswalks really did make me a little dizzy. Not puke-on-the-street dizzy, and never ever crash-my-car dizzy or anything like that, but yeah man, I'd stare into that funky design and get kind of lightheaded. It's true!
So I can imagine that there might be someone with actual physical or mental disabilities who might be crossing at this intersection and might legitimately feel nauseous or dizzy when they stare at the crosswalks.
To be completely transparent in this argument, I will say that it is much easier for me to make the anti-Rockledge argument these days, now that I've seen how many trump flags are in that shitty town and how thoroughly the Rockledge police prove that ACAB day in and day out, etc., etc. It's easy for me to piss on the next town over when I don't live in the town that's getting pissed on. But I hope that my argument here doesn't come off like that, like I'm reversing my opinion because I'm trying to carry out some grudge or whatever.
I really do want to work on myself and make myself a less-biased person in general, and if a test created by Harvard University is telling me that I'm biased against disabled people, even subconsciously, then it is my job to do a thorough examination of all my present and past actions and thought processes in order to figure out how to change that. The crosswalk debacle is one such incident from my past that I can definitively point to and say: I was wrong.
I'm not saying that the video isn't udderly ridiculous, because it absolutely is. I'm saying that I wish I would've just taken their side at the onset, if even to get straight answers as to whether this was actually a large-scale concern for Rockledge's citizens. I could've helped with collecting data. I could've polled neighbors. I could've raised funds so that we could redo the crosswalks and have our annual shitty Fourth of July parade. But instead, I chose to mock and degrade, which didn't help anyone at all.
It's a moot point, because by June 2019 (and still today, but I'm using that month because of Google street view again), the crosswalks were almost completely faded anyway:



No comments:
Post a Comment