After over two months of waiting since we last discussed it, Pitchfork has finally released the list of "our readers' chosen top 200 albums between 1996-2021" (not sure if there is a more succinct way to describe it). I always find it kind of interesting to compare my own personal list to the compiled list. How do my choices compare to the composite choices of my peers?
It's a game that is both frustrating (I think Radiohead is good, but not good enough to have THREE of the top FOUR albums of the past 25 years!!!!) and satisfying (fuck everyone else, I love my music). So let's play it really quickly. Here are my Top 25 again, and next to each album, I'll indicate how many spots higher or lower the album ended up on Pitchfork's list (or "N/A" if the album wasn't on their list at all).
25. Kids in Philly by Marah — N/A
24. Sleep Well Beast by the National — N/A
23. Everything Goes Numb by Streetlight Manifesto — N/A
22. The Black Parade by My Chemical Romance — N/A
21. Guitar Romantic by the Exploding Hearts — N/A
20. Twin Cinema by the New Pornographers — N/A
19. Stuck on Nothing by Free Energy — N/A
18. American Idiot by Green Day — N/A
17. Return to Cookie Mountain by TV on the Radio — #189 — 172 spots lower
16. Hold On Now, Youngster... by Los Campesinos! — N/A
15. The Lonesome Crowded West by Modest Mouse — #61 — 46 spots lower
14. Home, like Noplace Is There by the Hotelier — N/A
13. The Execution of All Things by Rilo Kiley — N/A
12. Vampire Weekend by Vampire Weekend — #72 — 60 spots lower
11. Pedestrian Verse by Frightened Rabbit — N/A
10. Clap Your Hands Say Yeah by Clap Your Hands Say Yeah — N/A
9. Cardinal by Pinegrove — N/A
8. Funeral by Arcade Fire — #7 — one spot HIGHER
7. Celebration Rock by Japandroids — #181 — 174 spots lower
6. In the Aeroplane over the Sea by Neutral Milk Hotel — #11 — five spots lower
5. Boxer by the National — #34 — 29 spots lower
4. Illinois by Sufjan Stevens — #12 — eight spots lower
3. Apologies to the Queen Mary by Wolf Parade — #149 — 146 spots lower
2. The Monitor by Titus Andronicus — #162 — 160 spots lower
1. Boys and Girls in America by the Hold Steady — N/A(!!!!!!!!!)
Insane: only ten of these 25 albums charting at all. Insane: how most of them are a triple-digit number of spots away from where I'd put them. Insane: how not even a #1 vote for Boys and Girls in America could push the album into contention at all. Not insane: how much of a monoculture Pitchfork is. Radiohead? Kanye? Psh. C'mon.
II.
XPN is doing something similar, but going bigger. With no time range to consider, they are asking for your top albums of all time, period. They are only asking for ten, but will by the end of 2021 compile the votes into a list of the top 2021 albums of all time. (Voting ends tomorrow! Get on it!)
This is a sequel to last year's top 2020 songs of all time, which I wrote about at the time. I was correct when I presumed that 2020 was enough leeway for my number 1 pick to get pushed into the running based on my vote alone (Spoon's "The Underdog" ended up at #1116). So I am confident I can get Boys and Girls in America onto this list. (Fuck Pitchfork.)
No, the most interesting thing to think about for this was whether the lack of a cut-off for years eligible would affect my Top Ten that I made for Pitchfork. Could someone like the Beatles, Bruce Springsteen, or Bob Dylan sneak an album into the Top Ten? I thought about it for a while.
Really, the question boils down to: "Besides the nine I already named, can I think of another album that is better than Clap Your Hands Say Yeah's self-titled debut?" And, surprisingly, I could not. Gun to my head, I would choose CYHSY over Born to Run, The White Album, Blood on the Tracks, Dark Side of the Moon, Led Zeppelin, pretty much any classic rock album I could think of. All of those named in the last sentence would probably bump into somewhere from #11-25, but not the top ten.
The biggest takeaway from this absolutely must be that the music you get into when you're seventeen years old is the music you will love for the rest of your life. A corollary takeaway is that I was artistically stunted at a very specific age. A takeaway that you might have too is that I am crazier than a shithouse rat for claiming that Clap Your Hands Say Yeah is better than Born to Run. To all those who claim this takeaway as their own, I say to you: fucking fight me.
III.
That I feel comfortable enough to challenge someone to a fight over a mostly forgotten blog rock touchstone of the mid-'00s says something about the big picture here: claiming something as your "favorite"—especially music, especially albums, especially "of all time"—is some tricky shit.
I've tested this out a few times in the past couple months, in a couple different bars around University City, mostly with people I barely know as a sort of icebreaker. I ask my new friends: what is your favorite album of all time? The response is generally something like, "I don't know! That's such a hard question!" and so on.
Here's what I propose. The difficult part of the question isn't being able to say what you like—that's easy, because liking something means remembering that thing. No, the difficult part is making such an answer as a statement and knowing that it is going to reflect on you as a person. You can't just like something the most; the thing you like most also has to say something about you. And during that precious time at the beginning of the semester when you don't know anyone and you're trying to parse through a large group of students to figure out who your friends are going to be, you want to say something about yourself that shows the You to strangers that is the same as the You you see yourself as, deep down inside.
(It's also possible that the very act of asking this question makes people so uncomfortable that they don't want to be friends with me, but that's a whole different issue.)
Now, when the question is inevitably mirrored back to me, I obviously have my answer at the ready: the Hold Steady's Boys and Girls in America. No one has yet heard of it, which then requires the whole explanation about it being America's premiere bar band singing about nostalgia for the blackout days of our youth, etc., etc. But I'm starting to wonder if maybe the fact that this answer of my favorite album all-time, despite my honesty, is not the answer that I should be giving, in this particular situation.
The very fact that I have to explain it to all non-Hold Steady fans blunts the answer's impact. I want it to say that I'm wistful, that I'm self-aware, that I'm fun-loving, that I'm always trying to stay positive. But if you don't know that about this band and this album, and can't get that from whatever one-sentence explanation I can come up with after two pitchers of Miller Lite, then the other person is learning absolutely nothing about me, save for the possible fact that I like "obscure" music (even though it's not obscure) and that I posed the original question in order to seem cooler than I am (even though I'm not cool and would never try to seem that way on purpose).
For the record, the first two new friends I posed the question to both said that a Kanye album was their favorite of all time, so maybe I should just throw the question right into the trash before any more social lives are ruined.

No comments:
Post a Comment