That's the first thing I have to notice, or else we're gonna do whatever I usually do on Saturdays when the "blind spot" is a particular spot on a known artist's discography—"this is how this album fits into the overall story of this musical artist." I don't know whether that's boring to others. I do know that it involves a lot of me talking out of my ass. As if I could truly know any artist's entire story. As if every artist even has to have an overarching narrative whose steps are defined by each album released. As if Fiona Apple, of all goddamn people, would give a shit about any of this, with her 90-word album titles and her persistent unobtainable coolness.
So the drums.
But hold up, this is important to the narrative though, isn't it? At least in a very narrow, PoYB sense. I already exalt Ms. Apple. I agree that her most recent magic trick is excellent. I jumped in about a year prior and found that it was accolade-worthy. Not noted in either piece was the fact that I knew "Criminal"—who doesn't know "Criminal"?!—but that's it. The realization that Fiona Apple was off in a thousand new direction since I last checked in with her circa 1996 was a thrilling one. She took one huge hit and morphed into an artist that operates almost exclusively in deep cuts. So with When the Pawn..., someone in my position might find it reasonable to find the midway point between "Criminal" and The Idler Wheel... / Fetch the Bolt Cutters. When the Pawn... is more grounded than the latter, and exponentially wilder than the former.
When I mention the drums, sure, I'm talking about "Limp" specifically, but I'm also talking about the fact that the drums being at the forefront of the mix for a lot of these songs gives agency to the overarching narrative that Fiona Apple is cool as fuck and no one can touch her. If this is the "let's take what we learned in in our nascent stage and get really crazy with it for the follow-up" album, then the drums are where we see the mindset in action. Fiona Apple isn't the drummer, and yet the percussion comes pretty fucking close to stealing the show. And, it hasn't gotten to the point where we are in Fetch the Bolt Cutters, where Fiona is literally just banging drum sticks on her kitchen table a lot of the time—which, yes, works well in that context, but it certainly isn't this. This is something else entirely. This is the good shit.
When I make such a conclusion—i.e. "Yup, Fiona Apple is still cool"—then I'm betraying the fact that this was never a blind spot at all. I learned nothing new. I wasn't blind. The drummer beat the blindness right out of me.

1 comment:
He said "It's all in your head,"
And I said, "So's everything"
But he didn't get it
Post a Comment