Thursday, September 2, 2021

A Rabid, Delirious PoYB Editor Starts Musing About Dolly Parton and Somehow Lands on a Blog Post About Cancel Culture


NPR is getting in on that clickbait game, and they got me. Here's an article they posted recently about Dolly Parton. I saw the headline, and my first reaction was: "Oh jeez, is there a reason I shouldn't like Dolly Parton anymore?" The answer is no, hence the clickbait.
 
As I explained last Christmas, I actually have somewhat of an issue taking celebrity's inherent "goodness" at face value. There's a natural mistrust, a implicit understanding that no one is—to use NPR's own words—a saint. But it was around Christmastime, and it was a lot easier to believe that Dolly Parton is a good person, especially when you consider the charity work, the money donated to causes I am aligned with, the courage to save a child from a impending car accident, and so on.

Nothing about this specific article is telling me anything that is going to make me change my mind about Dolly Parton. You know what the trick is? To believe that no one is perfect, and to appropriately compare the good with the bad, and to make judgments based on everything you know. In other words, the trick is to never assume that someone is a saint to begin with.
 
The fact that Dolly Parton basically used her money in an attempt to gentrify a majority-black neighborhood and then used that owned property as an attempt to add to her cred as a social justice icon? Not particularly great, and certainly not saint-like. But come on. Dolly Parton's social contributions are still net-positive, and to try to use gentrification as the basis of a hit piece is pretty fucking dumb.

If you never consider anyone a saint, or put any artist on a pedestal, then you'll never get burned. You don't have to necessarily kill your idols, but, like, maybe you just shouldn't have any idols in the first place? It's not worth it.

Now, that's not to say that someone who is exposed as having committed disgusting crimes shouldn't be outed as a creep or a criminal. If there is sufficient evidence to suggest that a celebrity or artist has committed an act such as sexual abuse, molestation, rape, child abuse, anything like that, then cutting them out of my life is easy. Even easier if they were never on a pedestal—the fall is a lot shorter, and it hurts less.

Y'all know how I feel about Jimmy Fallon. If you don't, then please go back and read that Dolly Parton review again. Note that I have disliked this dude for a long time, mostly for being a smug asshole, and somewhat for endearing a racist monster to an American public and giving implicit permission to those gullible enough to vote for him. But recently, there have been allegations that he aided and abetted in the rape and molestation of an underage teenager.

I don't mean to be flippant about Horatio Sanz, who actually performed the grooming and the sexual assaults, but I don't remember ever seeing anything he was ever in, and he was never featured on a Dolly Parton Christmas album that was reviewed by Record Club, so saying "I will never watch or support Sanz again" is an empty act of posturing. Let's concentrate on Fallon.

The alleging party notes that when she was fifteen years old, she operated a Jimmy Fallon Fan Club website. She further alleges that Jimmy Fallon and cohorts monitored this website, and, knowing full well that she was underage, invited her to post-SNL parties, where he knew full well that Horatio Sanz was abusing her, and didn't do jack shit about it except—and this is directly from the lawsuit—"ask her about her SATs."

If you believe this accuser—and there is ZERO reason to disbelieve her—then you now know that Jimmy Fallon purposefully contacted an underage fan and put her in a position where she was harmed, with his full consent and with no intervention. If we're ranking sexual abuse, this is but one step below the big ones, but it's STILL ABUSE. The only reason I bring up the "ranking" thing is that I have a sinking feeling that Jimmy Fallon is going to escape critique/cancellation/criminal charges yet again because he didn't directly abuse someone. As a child protection social worker guided by Pennsylvania state law, I can confirm for you that, under that state law, knowing about child abuse and not doing anything about it is STILL CRIMINAL, to say nothing of the sick twisted nature of it from a moral perspective.

(This is also saying nothing about the rest of the cast and crew of SNL around that time who did nothing about this, despite the fact that Sanz was raping a child in their literal presence. How many times was Amy Poehler present and silent? Will Ferrell? Tina Fey? Tracy Morgan? How about Lorne Michaels, whom the lawsuit specifically names as someone who met the victim, knew about her age, knew about her abuse at the hands of Sanz, and said nothing?)

Please don't mistake me, I take absolutely no pleasure in any sort of "I told you so" exercise. The fact of the matter is that an innocent child was abused. This makes me feel awful, as it should. I guess the point I was trying to make (before I started foaming at the mouth) is that it's easy to accept the fact that Jimmy Fallon is a child abuser when I never really held him personally in high regard anyway. Imagine considering Jimmy Fallon a saint, and then being blindsided with the truth.

That's why it did, and still does, make me a little uncomfortable when people like me revere people like Dolly Parton. We can appreciate the good that she does, but to call her a "saint" or whatever is a little too much. Be careful, Dolly Parton megafans! Who knows when the other shoe could drop!

But I also want to acknowledge that this NPR article is a blatant attempt to shoot for the queen's head, and it completely misses. It's some weak shit (and it's even propped up by a completely unrelated photo of asshole shitbirds Lady Antebellum drinking wine, as if we're supposed to make a connection between the two artists just because they both operate under the large, stuffy tent of country music). I think there is the idea of making a personal decision to dislike an artist based on your own chosen criteria, and then there is worrying what other people think about said artist during those moments when their own criteria doesn't match your own.

In other words, what would it take for you personally to dislike Dolly Parton? I have my own criteria, and I'm saying that nothing in this article meets that criteria. What would it take for you to dislike Jimmy Fallon? I have my own criteria, and Fallon reached it even before he was outed as a true criminal scumbag. But I also have to understand that other people have their own criteria. Maybe other people have their own criteria, and they are able to ignore the fact that Fallon facilitated the rape of a teenage girl. I don't agree with it, but to get into an argument with such a person is a losing game. That's why I will never stage a protest at a wedding when I hear "Ignition (Remix)," I'll just silently sit that one out.

That's also conversely why it's bizarre to me when people talk of "cancel culture" as if it's actually a thing. As if there is some overarching social tastemakers that are able to choose what entertainment millions of people can and cannot collectively participate in. It's simply not true.
 
When someone like Louis C.K. (who, by the way, was probably witness to a lot of Sanz raping a child, since he was an SNL writer at that time) is "canceled," what is really happening is that millions of people are individually making their own conscious decision to not support this man, financially or artistically, because each individual person decides that it is impossible to support someone who abuses women. Louis C.K. is probably still under the false impression that guns are held to our heads, that we aren't "allowed" to support him because of "what we were told." What I am told is the whole point. I don't like anyone who abuses women. I am told Louis C.K. abuses women. I believe it because of the evidence presented. I no longer participate in the art that Louis C.K. creates. I alone am making that choice. And millions of other people are making similar choices, similarly alone, based on what they individually believe. That it just so happens to be abuse bad enough that it meets millions of people's individual criteria for pulling their support of any artist has everything to do with Louis C.K.'s direct actions, and nothing to do with the "cancel culture" boogeyman that people just like Louis C.K. are perpetuating.

Okay, I'm letting my point getting away again, if I even knew what my point was to begin with. But I've settled on a final point, and it is this: there is always talk about whether we can "separate the art from the artist," and what I'm settling on now is that it is possible, and perhaps even necessary, do spin it both ways.
 
1) You cannot separate art from the artist when it is known definitively that the artist is a piece of shit, however you personally choose to define "piece of shit."

2) You can and probably should separate art from the artist when it seems like the artist is one of the "good ones," because everything you know about this artist is only what that artist has chosen to present themselves as, and who knows what is lurking behind the facade.

Additionally, remember that facts and opinions matter totally and in tandem. If something is true, then you must take it into account, but you must also have opinions about how to process those facts. I'm not denying that Dolly Parton may have misrepresented her real estate purchases, but my opinion is that this fact is not going to be enough for me to feel uncomfortable enjoying Dolly Parton's music. Though the fact that one of her songs features a sex criminal and child abuser will probably be enough to get me to delete A Holly Dolly Christmas from my iPod, to be honest.

No comments: