Way out front, you know I ain't frontin', hittin' home runs, I ain't about buntin'.
Friday, October 25, 2019
Everything Not Saved Will Be Lost — Part 2, Joe
Foals is probably at their best when their songs have this electric nervous energy about them. Sometimes they seem like a band that just has too many ideas and too many emotions, and they're just trying to pound them out and get to the next song. It's great when this happens. Nervous energy translates well in today's rock landscape.
In this regard, the first two (non-instrumental) songs are pretty great. "The Runner" has some fat guitar riffs, and sets the scene well for some desert theatrics. "Wash Off" is even more jittery, and obviously at this point we know that Foals can pretty easily translate that into capital-letters FUN.
But I dunno man, a lot of the album doesn't try to lean into my admittedly-personal and possibly-niche preferences, and from my vantage point, the other shit is not a good look for them. "Like Lightning" is garbage, and sounds like they are trying to crib from the Black Keys and failing (as if any even halfway-competent band could have trouble ripping off the fucking Black Keys?!).
The rest of the album is a bunch of passable, middling bullshit that you could hear on 104.5 I HEART RADIO if you wanted to.
Of course, I made those references a few months ago, so I guess it's time to turn our attention to the elephant in the room—this is a Part 2. Consider Everything Not Saved Will Be Lost to be a double album, with each disc released seven months apart. The question everyone asks of every double album in history, ever since The Beatles released The White Album, is this: Could this have been cut down and made into a single LP?
The answer when it comes to Foals' 2019 project—obviously—is fucking YES. Each of these two albums possesses some great songs! I really like some stuff on here. Imagine if Foals had self-reflected and just released the ten best songs. I dunno, I think that hypothetical album would get some hype as one of the best of the year. But as it stands now, there's so much filler and so much shit that just straight up doesn't work.
Can you imagine how badass "10,000 Ft." would've been if it came right after the surprisingly competent "Dreaming Of," instead of trying to squish some throwaway bullshit track in between (fuck you, "Ikaria," you're useless)? Can you imagine how impossibly badass "10,000 Ft." would've been as the closing track, instead of letting us suffer through the almost ten minutes of boredom that is "Neptune"? Foals could not imagine any of this, so I cannot either.
Look, I said it last March, and I'll say it again now—good on Foals for swinging for the fences. They tried to go big. It's like when Doug Pederson goes for it on 4th and 3. When it works, you're lauded, and when it doesn't, you look like an asshole for even trying.
As an ostensible concept album, ENSWBL does not work. I will perhaps stop short of calling Foals a bunch of assholes, though, because like I said, there are a handful of songs I like on here. But maybe Foals should dial down the ambition a little bit next time. Just write some high-energy rock songs that you're so good at. Stick with what you know. And please don't succumb to the desires of 104.5 FM's fraudulent music fans.
GRADE: 2.5 pukes out of 5
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)

No comments:
Post a Comment