Since Willow was born, we've put couple costumes to the side in lieu of a more complicated endeavor—the family costume (yeah, it could be considered icky to dress your infant child up for show, but have you seen Willow in her Marshmallow Man outfit yet?!).
So until the kids are old enough to go out on their own and me and Pam start going to Halloween parties again with just the two of us, here are our nine couples costumes, ranked.
That this is ranked dead last is not an indictment of Pam as Elmo. She pulls it off well. However, I absolutely half-assed my side of the costume, looking absolutely nothing like Katy Perry (to make matters worse, there was a legitimate Katy Perry costume at the Woodstock party). Also, the idea of Elmo/Katy Perry being a "couples costume" is a dated reference already, just nine years later.
Like Katy Perry, this costume drops low on the list because my half was totally half-assed. If you've seen Rosemary's Baby, then you'll recognize Pam immediately. A generic Party City devil costume? Not so much.
I'm a big fan of the Halloween doctrine "the simpler, the better." Can't get much simpler than bathing suits and wrapping paper in buckets. So call this a success. A success that seemed past its expiration date by the time Christmas was here.
Like Rosemary's Baby, the female costume from another classic Halloween film, Carrie, was accurate. Unlike the Rosemary's Baby costumes, the male side was accurate too (I even had the same long, wavy hair as Tommy!). But again, while Carrie is instantly recognizable, Tommy is not. It did me no favors that I had the exact same costume as our friend Maura, who was dressed as the dude from Dumb and Dumber.
I think there's merit in getting a simple reaction like: "That is so cool." Not everyone could put a name to exactly what we were dressed as, but everyone could recognize it, and everyone appreciated Pam's great makeup work.
A strong Halloween costume checks all three boxes: the characters are instantly familiar, and generally beloved; the costumes are accurate, even down to small details; there are creative touches to assure that the costumes are accurate. I wore cone-shaped party hats on each side of my head to emulate Arnold's football-shaped head; just like Helga had a heart-shaped locket with a picture of Arnold, Pam had a heart-shaped locket with a picture of me dressed as Arnold. And at the end of the day, who hasn't heard of Hey Arnold!? Who doesn't love Hey Arnold!? Not sure we'll ever top this one.
So until the kids are old enough to go out on their own and me and Pam start going to Halloween parties again with just the two of us, here are our nine couples costumes, ranked.
9) Elmo and Katy Perry (2010)
That this is ranked dead last is not an indictment of Pam as Elmo. She pulls it off well. However, I absolutely half-assed my side of the costume, looking absolutely nothing like Katy Perry (to make matters worse, there was a legitimate Katy Perry costume at the Woodstock party). Also, the idea of Elmo/Katy Perry being a "couples costume" is a dated reference already, just nine years later.
8) Little Pete and Artie, the Strongest Man in the World (2012)
I'll defend this costume forever, because I think it's accurate. But coming one year after dressing as another old school Nickelodeon pair, it reeked of diminishing returns. Plus, not a single person at the party knew who we were supposed to be (I got a lot of Where's Waldo guesses, ugh).
7) Rosemary and Satan (2017)
Like Katy Perry, this costume drops low on the list because my half was totally half-assed. If you've seen Rosemary's Baby, then you'll recognize Pam immediately. A generic Party City devil costume? Not so much.
6) The Ice Bucket Challenge (2014b)
I'm a big fan of the Halloween doctrine "the simpler, the better." Can't get much simpler than bathing suits and wrapping paper in buckets. So call this a success. A success that seemed past its expiration date by the time Christmas was here.
5) Carrie and Tommy (2016)
Like Rosemary's Baby, the female costume from another classic Halloween film, Carrie, was accurate. Unlike the Rosemary's Baby costumes, the male side was accurate too (I even had the same long, wavy hair as Tommy!). But again, while Carrie is instantly recognizable, Tommy is not. It did me no favors that I had the exact same costume as our friend Maura, who was dressed as the dude from Dumb and Dumber.
4) Khal Drogo and Khaleesi (2015)
Yeah, there were and are still plenty of people dressing as Game of Thrones characters. Doesn't make it any less fun.
3) The Guilty Remnant (2014a)
So much to like about these costumes. They were simple and comfortable. I've always thought I look so cool with a cigarette in my mouth. Pam looks sexy when she scowls. And we were way ahead of the game with showing love and tribute to what is possible the best show of the decade—The Leftovers.
2) Día de los Muertos (2013)
I think there's merit in getting a simple reaction like: "That is so cool." Not everyone could put a name to exactly what we were dressed as, but everyone could recognize it, and everyone appreciated Pam's great makeup work.
1) Arnold and Helga (2011)
A strong Halloween costume checks all three boxes: the characters are instantly familiar, and generally beloved; the costumes are accurate, even down to small details; there are creative touches to assure that the costumes are accurate. I wore cone-shaped party hats on each side of my head to emulate Arnold's football-shaped head; just like Helga had a heart-shaped locket with a picture of Arnold, Pam had a heart-shaped locket with a picture of me dressed as Arnold. And at the end of the day, who hasn't heard of Hey Arnold!? Who doesn't love Hey Arnold!? Not sure we'll ever top this one.







No comments:
Post a Comment