Saturday, October 19, 2019

Song of the Week: "Dancing on My Own"

There's a playlist somewhere of all the previous songs and that playlist is definitively HERE.


"Dancing on My Own"
Robyn
from Body Talk Pt. 1
2010

While it's late for me to talk about Pitchfork's Top 200 Songs of the Decade list—it was published like two weeks ago at this point—it was absolutely too early for Pitchfork to be talking about the top songs of the decade anyway. It's only October! There are three entire months left in the 2010s! Ah well. Fuck it. Let's talk about it.

We're talking specifically about Robyn's "Dancing on My Own," which landed at #3 on their list. At #1—spoiler alert!!—was Kendrick's "Alright," and at #2 was Grimes' "Oblivion," which means that the highest charting song that I had never heard before the list was published was this one. So here I am, listening to it on repeat.

Let's talk about the song first, and then we'll talk about where I stand, here in October 2019, at the very cusp of the 2020s.

The song—released by Swedish artist Robyn in June 2010 (if you think that is too early in the decade, just wait till you see when my number album of the decade was released). It didn't crack the Billboard 100 in the US, but hit #3 on Billboard's "Dance Club Songs" chart, and—probably more important to Robyn—hit #1 on Sweden's hit charts.

It's a pop song that pulls from electronica and is inspired by disco. There's a steady, propulsive beat, and there's a certain sense of longing that really gives the song a healthy dose of empathy. As I sit here, typing and listening to the song on repeat, I'm starting to really appreciate it. This is really fucking good!

Now, does this mean that "Dancing on My Own" is going to show up on Puke on Your Birthday's Top 100 Songs of the Decade list? Hell nah, brah. It's a good song, but I'm only listening to it because Pitchfork seems to think that I should. Which makes me curious...

What makes Pitchfork believe that there is no better song this decade (besides only two others)? The argument that they make is that this is an anthem for women (sure), and that it inspired other female artists like Lorde and Swift to make their own Frankensteins out of house/disco/pop/etc. (again, sure). But consider the song itself. What makes "Dancing on My Own" better than anything, say, Lorde or Swift came up with in the 9.25 years since? Unclear.

Am I going to rank my own list of Decade's Best Songs in any less weak or indefinable terms? Absolutely not.

And on top of all that, there's the issue of publishing this goddamn list three entire fucking months before the decade is over. Not that I think there are going to be any songs released in the next 70 days that are going to convince Pitchfork that it's better than "Dancing on My Own," but still. It's entire fucking decade. It's important. Let's relax and maybe wait till the actual end of the decade to talk about this shit?

But that's my own personal bugaboo. Whatever the case may be—and again, I'm still listening on repeat, as I'm still typing—I'm seeing the beauty in this song. I can see that maybe those who were in their early twenties in 2010 might've found this to be their own personal anthem, and now here in 2019 there's the whole nostalgia piece, like, "Oh fuck remember when I was so hurt about that petty ex-boyfriend bullshit and Robyn soothed my nerves and I remember that whole thing with rose-colored glasses?" Sure. I get it.

But that doesn't mean that I necessarily agree with it. That's not Robyn's fault. I had never heard this song till last week, when Pitchfork told me to listen to it. It's fine. It's good. It's not Top Three of 2010. That's on me. Every 2010s list is going to be personal, and thus, incredibly incomplete. So be it.

2 comments:

Rachel Semigran said...

JOE! Listen to the NPR feature on this song in their American Anthems series. I always, always loved this song and this piece really exemplifies why it's so special. Also, I now can't listen to the part of the song that goes "I just came to say goodbye" without crying:

https://www.npr.org/2019/06/10/730641583/robyn-dancing-on-my-own-alone-together-american-anthem

Joe K said...

I'm just seeing this comment now (I'm not used to seeing comments on the blog, haha), but WOW that was cool. I think maybe I came off as a little dismissive of this song in my write-up, which is probably unfair to those who have listened to it for more than one day. But I'm glad people find solace and joy in this tune. That's what music is for!