I did not watch Get Back. This wasn't because I thought I wouldn't like it. In fact, I know that I would like it. Maybe even love it. I love the idea of watching eight hours of footage of musicians just fucking around and creating music. This would've been my shit.
My argument against it is one of time management, which is definitely my fault, not the Beatles' or Peter Jackson's. On a superficial level, I'll say that eight hours of anything is not worth my time these days. I can barely pay attention for an entire 22-minute episode of Seinfeld, let alone imagine being able to commit eight hours of my week to one single documentary series.
On a deeper level, I feel uncomfortable with devoting even eight additional hours to the Beatles, who are definitely the most important band in music history, but who are also already the band that I know the most about. I know enough about the Beatles that I feel comfortable saying that I am "very familiar" with the Beatles. I've spent enough time with Beatles biographies and WMGK's Breakfast with the Beatles that I can speak knowledgeably on the Beatles. Not expertly, by any means, but close enough that I'm cool staying in this space. There's enough music documentaries out there about artists that I don't know as well as I do the Beatles. I'm gonna stick with those other documentaries for now (or, ya know, just listening to the fucking music).
As you can see, any associated bitterness that comes with having not watched the zeigesty Get Back was entirely by choice. I could've watched Get Back and joined in the online and family discussions. I chose not to. (I'm also gonna quit Twitter, I think, but that's another blog post for another week.)
Writing a list of my least favorite Beatles songs, then, is just a way to release some pent-up (and, again, entirely self-created) frustrations. The purpose of this list isn't to create some grand argument that the Beatles are secretly a bad band. They aren't. They are fucking great. They are close to fucking perfect. But let's not go overboard here. Let's not pretend that what Paul McCartney did when creating "Get Back"—noodling around on guitar until an idea made its way to the surface—isn't something that every other fucking professional musician on earth does every single day. Let's not pretend that there weren't shitty songs here and there. Close to perfect, but not perfect.
A note about "Revolution 9": I've long professed this to be my least favorite song of all time, period, beyond it just being my least favorite Beatles song, but my opinion on it has softened in recent years. I would've kept the song off the list anyway, since "beating a dead horse" and all, but I'm keeping it off the list now for a different reason. I've actually come to admire the song a little bit. I still think it's a garbage song, that it's not even really a song at all really, that it's almost completely unlistenable, but I also now think that maybe that's an interesting thing, how the Beatles were so big, and John Lennon was so beyond reproach, that they/he could just add a fucking sound college to the end of a double album and have no one say shit about it. I get a sense of awe when I am in the presence of someone/something so fucking untouchable.
A note about "Ob-La-Di, Ob-La-Da": I could probably make the same argument about this fucking dreck, as it is no doubt the second worst Beatles song, but also... yeah, kind of bizarrely courageous of Paul McCartney to drop something so sickly sweet and childish on an otherwise ostensibly grown-up endeavor. McCartney was 26 when he wrote this song; he might as well have been six. Lennon made a big deal about his primal scream therapy and how connecting with the horrors of his childhood trauma him to create darker art. McCartney didn't need primal scream—he was creating fresh childhood trauma in real time.
A note about "Hey Jude": I've already written about this song, and I've already committed to not hating on it, because it would be an absolutely horrible look for an uncle to hate on the song which also happens to be his nephew's namesake. You won't find it on this list. I'll hold it close to my chest as to whether you'd find it on this list without stipulations. I will say this: Jude, if you're reading this, and it's like 2035, and you're into the Beatles, hit up your Uncle Joe. Let's talk about it, man. I'm excited to hear what you have to say.
Top Five Worst Beatles Songs
5. "Honey Pie"
An insufferable take on late-19th century Victorian-style British music. I get that the point of the White Album was to encompass as many music styles as possible, but this is a bridge too far. At least its cousin "Wild Honey Pie" had the decency to get weird with it, and also come in and get out in 61 seconds.
4. "The Inner Light"
There are plenty of valid arguments that George Harrison's immense talent was unheralded because it had the unlucky fortune of existing in the shadow of Lennon and McCartney's comparable talents. But then you hear another Maharishi Mahesh Yogi dick sucking contest, and you start to think that Lennon and McCartney had a point.
3. "Maxwell's Silver Hammer"
On paper, I buy it: a murder mystery dressed up in classic cloying corny McCartney bullshittery. In practice, it falls apart, because, it's... well, it's cloying, corny, and McCartney-ish.
2. "The Word"
I realize this might be a stretch for some people. I'll hear arguments against this song's placement on the list. But something about the basic premise of this song—"the answer is love," basically—has made me cringe so hard that it's physically painful. I don't disagree with the theory, but the presentation does nothing to prove the theory correct. It in fact makes me want to puke. Maybe the answer is hate.
1. "Her Majesty"
Much to-do is made about the song cycle that ends Abbey Road, which was the last album the Beatles ever created together (but not released, long story—have you seen Get Back?). Rightly so, as the run from "Because" to "The End" is one of the greatest musical achievements in history. It's all there, really. Had the story of the Beatles ended with one last nonsense Beatles-esque sentiment ("The love you make...") and a fucking Ringo Starr drum solo, then it would've been the greatest sendoff ever laid down on tape. But they couldn't help themselves. They had to tack on the stupid, unnecessary "Her Majesty." It's an absolutely nothing of a track. In fact, it's less than nothing. It actively takes away from the power of Abbey Road's second side. It's one last wink at the audience, but comes off more like there's something stuck in their eye. I hate it. I hate all 23 seconds of it. I hate that it takes something perfect and then takes a hot piss on that otherwise perfect thing. Fuck "Her Majesty" forever.
