We construct our own realities. The hope is that these realities are built upon truth, verifiable facts, but that's not always the case. Sometimes, our reality is built upon opinions, which are subjective, and are, in turn, supported by things that aren't necessarily true. The problem occurs when someone then decides to test that reality by presenting you with facts that don't jibe with the foundation of that reality. You might react poorly, curse that person out, ignore them, cry because you don't want to acknowledge that you have built yourself a false reality. A person who is testing the reality you've constructed could be viewed as a threat. It's fight or flight. Someone shakes at the pillars that hold your reality up, and you're either tunnelling deeper into that reality, or lashing out. In other words, it's really fucking hard to consider what's true, like what's actually true, when we all live in our own realities, and when it's so easy to construct those realities from anything, even shit that's verifiably false.
I say all this because I want to make it clear that I am not an exception. I have constructed my own reality, and it, like anyone else's reality, is built on shaky ground. However, I like to view this space—Record Club album reviews—as an opportunity to examine the constructs of these realities, to safely test the foundations, to see if they hold. This is not the space for being a little pissant crybaby and whining and moaning when the truth of the art that is the album presents a crack in the foundation of your reality. Admitting flaws in your personally constructed reality takes courage, and I like to think that the album review is a helpful way of doing that, of being brave. But I also want to lay all this out now, because I don't want you to think that anything negative I have to say about Lana Del Rey is due to, ya know, hiding my eyes from the truth or anything like that. I've never liked this artist's craft, but I'm giving it a fair shot this week, as opposed to, like, burrowing even deeper into my own reality and talking mad shit as some sort of defense mechanism. What I say here—the negatives, and yes, maybe even some positives—is borne of the truth, in the real world, outside of my own constructed reality, and then used as mortar to strengthen the pillars.
In my reality, the one I started building when I heard those opening chords of Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band in the early aughts and continued to build through these last 400 arduous weeks of a music club, I have erected a pillar that has become load-bearing over time, and that pillar states that music should be hook-centric to be considered "exciting," with great emphasis on either speed or jauntiness or both. In my reality as I know it now, Lana Del Rey is considered, well, pretty fucking boring. No hooks, all slow piano dirges, the occasional orchestral flourish that buttresses the dirges, as opposed to improving them or cancelling them out. I have not ignored Del Rey's music; I have long been aware of what it sounds like. For the most part, I have opened my ears and found that, at least in my own reality, it is, certifiably, fucking booooooooring.
Were I to crack or injure the pillar that holds all this weight in this reality, I might chip away at it by saying that, well, maybe the music isn't the point here. Could we, if we were to rearrange this reality that I reside in, say that this is more designed to work like poetry, which doesn't traditionally even require music at all, but simply pretty or poignant or impactful words arranged in a meaningful way? Let us question our reality by saying that Lana Del Rey is a poet. Let us examine this book of poetry.
I know some bad lyricists. Rivers Cuomo and Taylor Swift both exist in this reality that I've constructed. So I'm telling you now that I think that a lot of what Lana Del Rey expresses is (comparatively) intriguing, and well-put, and enjoyable. All I want, in music but also in movies and TV and really any art that I engage with in this world, is for something to feel new. It's new if it doesn't feel like a trope or cliché. It's interesting if it's new. I think that a lot of the songs here are interesting. Perhaps, were I in fight or flight when considering my reality and Del Rey's place in it, I might find easy ways to dismiss, say the lyrics are bad, but they aren't. Not really. I am drawn to them.
But—and here's the but, as you knew it would be, but it's a soft but—I get the nagging sense sometimes, even when considering the truth as it exists and not as I choose to construct it, that these lyrics are not for me. And that it is because of me that I find that they lack depth. I'm not saying they aren't interesting, because they are. I'm saying that I find them interesting in the way they seem to be from another planet, and how confused I am about the ways other people connect to them, and I seem to be locked out. That's interesting. I like it because it's interesting. Because it's new to me. But I can't say with any sort of truth that I find them good.
These lyrics feel like a spin on the classic "I'm fourteen and this is deep." Stuff that people of a certain mindset and within a certain context would find enlightening, but which seems kinda silly to everyone else. Let's call it "I'm 29 and this is #deep." I am not a 20-something female and I'm not hyperactively on social media. I also don't buy into the thematic resonance of Found Drama in this brand of pop music, in which very boilerplate conflicts (both outer and inner) of adolescence and young adulthood are passed off as extraordinary. The album opens with the line "Goddamn, man-child / You fucked me so good that I almost said 'I love you.'" There are maybe two layers to that line, and neither layer applies to me, or exists in a language I can relate to or even comprehend. The act of "relating" is NOT what makes "good music," of course (despite what idiots may have claimed otherwise, over the years). But because of it, I am on the outside looking in. Intrigued, sure, but more in an anthropological way.
One way that you might be able to sneak this all by your discerning late-30-something straight male music critic is to say something along the lines of "well, she's just playing a character," which is definitely something I've considered in the past, and might still believe sometimes. Because if "Lana Del Rey" didn't exist, but was just an exaggerated character played by normal grounded human being Lizzy Grant, then you might be able to make excuses for the drawn-out characterization of a drunk 1920s socialite mumbling at a speakeasy as a CONSTRUCT, as opposed to a 2020s modern woman who is just acting weird and boring.
You see why it's easier to consider it a construct, a character, though, right? Because if that's the case, then she's doing the same thing I and everyone else does: she's creating her own reality. Because she's an artist, that means welcoming us into it as well, and as music critics and human beings, we can enter or not, that's up to us. Like maybe it has to do with whether our respective realities align. And maybe I'm choosing not to enter hers because it doesn't match up with the reality that I've built (i.e. the reality that music should be more exciting than this and should include lyrics that don't sound like the most annoying smart hot girl on your Instagram feed).
What is the most fascinating, I'd argue, is the way that we as a society have evolved over the past seven years or so. "The culture is lit, and if this is it‚ I had a ball" might be the most famous line from this album, and definitely the most telling. The assumption, at the time, was that something was ending, and maybe it was, but I think Norman Fucking Rockwell! was more of a precursor to what was coming, a beginning rather than an ending. We (generally, not necessarily me, but who's to say) have moved more toward Lana Del Rey's way of doing things. She presents herself as a character and a construct on this album, and in the time since, we have built that idea up as the way to do things. We're all constructs now. We're all characters. We're all building our own reality out of scotch tape and bullshit. This is the way we operate now.
I mean, look at this review itself, this attempt at sounding all erudite about music, all hoity-toity and such. Is this the truth, or something that I'm constructing right in front of your goddamn eyes? Does what I'm saying now fit into your own reality? Or does it conflict with how you see the world? Can any of us step outside of our own little fiefdoms of reality and find the real, true world that unites us? Or is that all fractured? And did Lana Del Rey help fracture it?
Of course not. Lana Del Rey isn't the mastermind. She's just a player in the game, same as we are. All we can do is do our best to break down our own pillars and find the courage to seek what is real and true from the resulting rubble.
And in the meantime, maybe listen to some better music than this. It's kinda boring.
GRADE: 2.5 pukes out of 5

No comments:
Post a Comment