1958
Alfred Hitchcock
Welcome back perennial Never Seen It guest expert Frank for another round of emailing about the next NSI film on the list. Much thanks and appreciation to my friend for adding so much of his insight to this movie blog.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
JOE: I would imagine that, with a lot of these films on the list—the well-renown, critically acclaimed ones, anyway—the first time I'd ever heard of them at all was perusing the AFI's Top 100 Movies list. I'll include Vertigo in that. The most recent version of the list has it at #9, which is up from #61 on the first version of the list. So between 1998 and 2007, it jumped 52 spots.
During a previous conversation we had, about the extremely Vertigo-esque Paddington 2, you mentioned the BFI Sight and Sound critics list, compiled every ten years. The 2012 version of that list had Vertigo at #1, after being #2 in 2002 and #4 in 1992 and not in the Top 10 prior to that.
The point I'm trying to make here, I think, is that our collective consensus about movies changes over long periods of time. Some films come in and out of fashion. For some movies, like Vertigo, contemporaneous reviews can be mixed, but then decades pass, and all of a sudden it's considered one of the best ever.
I'm interested in what you think about Vertigo, of course. But I'm also interested in your thoughts about why films like this evolve in that way. Our guiding light in this project, Roger Ebert, once said that movie magic happens in the conversations that occur after the film is over, and I sometimes wonder whether certain films just need some time—fifty years, in some cases—for those conversations to take place and build up steam and get to the point where we've all convinced ourselves that we have something special on our hands. I think that's why it can be jarring to watch a movie first and see the critical consensus for it second—when it doesn't align, then you have to readjust your thoughts, and try to place yourself within that global conversation about the film. E.g. "Okay, I loved it, everyone else hated it, how can I move the needle on this fucking thing?"
So that's two questions. One, what do you think about Vertigo? And two, why do you think we're at the point in America's history where Vertigo is easily a Top Ten Movie Ever, if not Top Three?
FRANK: What I think about Vertigo has evolved the same way the discourse has. The first time I saw it I think I was let down by all the high expectations. My favorite Hitchcock movie is Rear Window, so I assumed Vertigo must be leagues better for it to be the movie on the top of all those lists, and when it didn't instantly become my favorite movie of all time, it felt like a failure. The second time I saw it, I liked it a lot more, I think I was able to appreciate it without the weight of the crown. I just rewatched it and I loved it. Here's the thing: Rear Window is a blast. It's pulpy and soapy and Jimmy Stewart and Grace Kelly are movie stars and it's got a great technical framing device that really works. It's really funny at parts. It has a lot of what I love in great movies, and it's a masterpiece. No one I think has ever accused Vertigo of being a blast. It's going for something different. I think my appreciation for it, upon rewatching it, is my intended philosophy of trying to meet movies where they are instead of asking them to come to me. "Did they achieve what they were going for?" What do YOU think about Vertigo? How does it compare to Psycho?
Now a brief (too late) analysis of why Vertigo had to gestate to be recognized as great: Hitchcock had always been a popular director, but something important started to happen to film criticism: a French film magazine called Cahiers du CinĂ©ma had a group of young film critics (who would become the filmmakers of the French New Wave) who, in the mid-'50s, introduced the idea of auteur theory—that the director was the chief author of a film. And to the chagrin of the old guard, the examples of master auteurs that writers like Francois Truffaut offered as deserving critical reevaluation of their work as technical masterpieces was led by Alfred Hitchcock. (Sidebar: Hitchcock/Truffaut is an incredible book transcribing a series of interviews Truffaut did with Hitchcock in 1962 that is really insightful into his process. Highly recommend.) This view of film criticism is highly influential on the directors of the New Hollywood movement: Spielberg, Lucas, Scorsese, Coppola. And that becomes influential on the next generation, and so it goes. So what really happens is a group of foreign critics in the '50s influence HOW people are looking at movies critically, and put that in a pressure cooker for fifty or sixty years and voila, someone who's work was seen as all fluff no substance in his own time becomes one of the three most critically lauded directors of the 20th century (ironic that that list also includes equally contemporarily derided Orson Welles, and, if not derided, divisive Stanley Kubrick).
I think, in a lot of ways, Vertigo was WAY ahead of its time. It is a WEIRD movie. It's dark: its protagonist slowly becomes an obsessive maniac and is never really punished for it at a time where audiences expected everybody to get their just desserts. And not just any protagonist: Jimmy Freaking Stewart. It had to be so unsettling to see aww shucks Jimmy up there violently yelling. It is the culmination of a lot of "Hitchcockian" themes: deception, double identities, Freudian psychosexuality, voyeurism. A lot of pop psychologists have attributed it as being almost a hate letter from Hitch to himself: a self-aware mirror to his own voyeuristic obsessions as a director and his well-noted psychotic treatment of his blonde leading ladies. It feels like one of the first films to be more interested about the psychological effects on the characters than the plot: Consider that the first half of the movie is literally all bullshit! All the stuff about Carlotta, it's all a big red herring! Also consider the long stretches where no dialogue takes place, all Bernard Herman's killer score as Scottie follows Madeline around town. I checked: Kim Novak, the second-billed person in this movie, doesn't even speak a word of dialogue until 46 minutes into the movie. It's doing a lot of things contemporary audiences wouldn't have been used to, and honestly, even modern movies don't always do. It is uncomfortable and cold and bold and never lets you slip into the story. The filmmakers are always audaciously making themselves known.
I think, and I wonder your thoughts, a lot of the prestige it's gained is its influence in the technical realm: the way the movie plays with color and lighting, the work he's doing with editing and literally inventing the camera technique to show Scottie's vertigo.
Why are we ready for it now? It's a cynical movie, and maybe we are more jaded and cynical than ever. It shines a light on an underbelly of American conquest mentality that didn't get discussed at dinner parties for a long time and now can't be avoided. How resonant is the idea of molding our reality to what we wished it would be instead of what it is. Of course, Judy IS Madeleine but before that reveal... yikes.
JOE: See, here's what I was hoping would happen, and it did: I was hoping we could do our own little miniature version of the almost 70-year conversation that's been happening with Vertigo, where we talk about it and I find that I like it a lot more after the conversation than before because of what we talked about. Not that I need to be told what to like or why to like it, but I do sincerely think that some films just need to be processed first before they can be called "great." Your initial reaction to Vertigo a while ago—basically "hmmm, good, maybe not as good as promised"—is my initial reaction here too. I liked it, and I will list some reasons I liked it, but I can't imagine this being the type of movie, for anyone, where it's like "I instantly understand why it's great." This happens to me every time I come across a so-called "best of all time" film, so I could see it coming for Vertigo a mile away. It's all about setting expectations appropriately. Though it does make me wonder why I never seemed to be of this mindset during all those Your Favorite Movie interviews. Maybe it explains why a lot of those interviews are approached from a place of skepticism, I don't know. If someone personally told me that Vertigo was their favorite movie, I would get it. I wouldn't agree, but I would get it. And I would be willing to listen, just like I am now. Show me Vertigo, Frank.
I liked it for a lot of reasons. It definitely felt like one of those movies that could go anywhere, and there's a thrill in that. Like it's not playing by the rules. This feeling is more prominent for the older movies. Because the expectation is that they are writing the rules, not breaking them, ya know? So if something like Vertigo has sections that have me on the edge of my seat, it feels even more impressive that a film from 1958 was able to do it. How can something so old be so shocking? This is obviously a symptom of me still being a novice in film-watching. I just need to watch more older movies. But when Madeleine falls out of that tower the first time, it was a genuine OH SHIT moment. And then when Judy actually falls off the tower, it's afforded a lot more build-up, and that somehow felt even more shocking.
I think you hit the nail on the head regarding it being dark and cynical. When it comes to Scottie being creepy with Judy and trying to dress her like Madeleine, it's one of those things where I'm not really sure what I'm supposed to be thinking. The age of the film again affects it—is something that would be more acceptable in the 1950s? Or less acceptable? Or does the creepiness transcend era? Doesn't really matter what the answer is; asking the questions at all means that this is an intriguing film.
On a technical level, the thing that stood out for me was the brightness of the colors in the film. Early on in the film, after one green dress and one green car, Pam said (mostly sincerely, but with a dash of mock pretension, I think), "Okay, so what does the green symbolize?" So maybe that was just in my head when the ghostly green glow of the hotel sign permeated the room. The colors were a choice, though. Knowing nothing about this film besides its director, I probably even assumed it was a black-and-white film, so maybe the choice just felt more striking based on that. It just felt like the right choice, because of the juxtaposition of bright colors and dark themes.
The idea of "Hitchcock making a film about Hitchcock" is something that would appeal to my sensibilities as a film watcher. I think Ebert wrote about this too. I'm willing to buy it if Frank AND Roger are both on board, goddamn. I'm not quite there yet in being able to describe something like "what is Hitchcockian?" I'm at the point where I can feel it, but can't explain it. I would know this was a Hitchcock film in the same way I would know Bob Marley did reggae, and, like, I could say some shit like "it's reggae because the bass kick is on the 2 and 4 instead of the 1 and 3," but ultimately, reggae is a feeling. I like the idea of a director examining his own flaws and faults through his art, and if Alfred Hitchcock does that here, I think that's cool, or creepy in a cool way, something like that. I don't know anything about the man as a person. I guess I would assume the voyeurism / psychotic tx based on the films I've seen, but wouldn't be able to watch Vertigo and understand that it's a response to that. I am also skeptical that a director of Hitchcock's magnitude would be willing to give so much of himself away like that. But that could just be me being cynical.
I do like thinking about this kind of thing, though. I think it's a great discussion, the question of whether this is a self-reflective exercise. And I think asking the question in turns makes the movie better. If I watched Vertigo a second time, this would absolutely be on my mind, this thing about Hitchcock exposing himself like that. Even if it's marked as a "probably/maybe," I think that still adds depth to Vertigo. Which is what I'm ultimately seeking.
Something I no longer struggle with—and you touched on this regarding how the film is ahead of its time—is being patient with a film. Maybe a younger Joe would say "there is WAY too much of this film consisting of Jimmy Stewart just driving around!!" Not anymore. I love when that kind of shit happens, the quiet moments, the way we are forced to reckon with what each character is thinking about, as they themselves are choosing to think instead of speak out loud. And I can't imagine ever getting angry at a red herring ever again. Actually, that's probably how this film most resembles Psycho, right? How it's bifurcated into basically two different sections of the plot. Psycho is before and after the shower scene. This is before and after (the real) Madeleine's fall. That kinda shit thrills me to think about, even if I don't realize that it's happening in the moment. It feels like another one of those rule-breaks.
I think something I struggle with is the technical aspects, though. I'm still not at the point where I can marvel over a new type of camera shot. Which is frustrating to me, this far into this fucking thing. But maybe I would just need to do some extra work on it, extracurricular reading and whatnot. The "Vertigo zoom" is cool when I take five seconds to think about it, but the issue is having the capacity to think about it while I'm watching the film. Any tips on how to improve my experiences with film in this particular way? Or should I continue to bluff my way through it?
I asked Pam if she had any questions for you, and she wanted me to ask you specifically about the green (she didn't know that I already mentioned it, which means we're just on the same fucking wavelength tonight, me and her). Is it aesthetic? Does the green motif mean something?
We mentioned that contemporaneous reviews were mixed, generally. But we didn't mention yet that those same reviews often stated that Kim Novak's performance was often said to be "stilted." Agree or disagree?
Does the plot about the murder cover-up work, or are there too many holes? Like, why didn't this dude just bury his wife in the desert or something?
Here's a theory I hate: "the main narrative of the film is actually imagined by Scottie as he dangles from a building at the end of the opening rooftop chase." Boooooo!!!
Feels like we could talk about this movie for a long time.
FRANK: Thinking about the technical aspects / being introduced to discussions about it was something that I am currently getting through film school. I think it can only come through extracurricular exposure. It was pure kismet that I happen to be taking a class on film editing and reading a chapter on Hitchcock's techniques and his combination of two schools of thought: USSR's Sergei Eisenstein and his use of montage to elicit emotions and Germany's FW Murneau's moving camera. It is definitely interesting if you like knowing how the sausage gets made, but does feel ancillary to the viewing experience. It's like it's cool to know the production stuff that went into The Dark Side of the Moon (the first answer to my google of what albums are considered the best mixed productions of all time), but not really necessary to think or talk about it critically.
The green definitely means something. (As an aside, the thing that struck me the first time we see her in her dress is in this preposterously red room. Also, the red of the Golden Gate Bridge? Like it feels important that the movie is in San Francisco but maybe it was just cool architecture?) Another quick google suggests that ghosts presented on the stage in theatrical productions that used the Pepper's Ghost technique (like the ghosts in the Haunted Mansion ride at Disney parks) have a green hue from the effect. So theatrically, ghosts are associated with the color green. Take that one with a grain of salt, I can't find any confirmation of Hitch's intent. But it DOES feel intentional.
RE: Kim Novak's performance: I think she is given an impossible task as an actor and has to play icy aloof the whole time. It's also hard because she is personifying the objectification of women, right? Like Scottie is obsessed with literally the idea of her more than anything else, a 3D model of a portrait of a woman. She has to stand in contrast to the ignored Midge who is just as beautiful (maybe more? I was definitely crushing on Midge), but has a life and thoughts and opinions and an independent job: blurgh gross!! I actually think Kim Novak does a really great job here.
RE: the plot: this guy happens to read in the paper that his old school friend got in a rooftop accident and then builds all his plans for the future on: a) this man will fall in love with his "wife," b) this man will come up with the idea to take "wife" back to the place with a tall tower, c) this man having a serious enough condition that he will have a panic attack going upstairs. Yeah, you can't squint too closely at this one, but it's definitely not the point. Like of course there are coincidences and of course you need Scottie to behave a certain way for it all to work, but that is what makes it great: Scottie acts in exactly the insane sexually obsessed way the plot needs him to, his perversion ties the noose around his own neck.
BOOO that theory. It was all a dream worked exactly one time, and honestly the more people try to Owl Creek Bridge things, the more I think Owl Creek Bridge might be stupid too.
JOE: Final thoughts on Vertigo?
FRANK: If I had never seen a movie before, and Vertigo was the first one I saw, I'd be truly baffled. It definitely isn't a starter kit movie. I think you have to have a sophisticated palate and have your hand held by film experts to help explain the whole experience. You and I definitely need the Eberts and Truffauts of the world, which makes me glad for critics and curators. Whether a truly great movie should be able to just thrust its greatness in your heart upon one viewing is up to debate (I knew I loved Casablanca, It's a Wonderful Life, Raiders of the Lost Ark immediately) But great art can and should also challenge you and itself. The Citizen Kanes and Vertigos and 2001s of the world pushed the medium forward boldly and bravely, and pushed against conventional techniques and trends. I'm happy to continue to be challenged and have to refine my palate to taste the saffron or whatever Vertigo is being cooked with.
FRANK'S GRADE: 4 pukes out of 5
JOE'S GRADE: 4 pukes out of 5
NEXT TIME: We await the penis puns of Walk Hard: The Dewey Cox Story (since, you see, "Cox" is a homonym for "cocks," another word for "penis")

No comments:
Post a Comment