Converge made me wonder about the idea of chaos, and whether chaos could ever be a good fit for me in my life. Well, okay, it wasn't just Converge, though they are, truthfully, quite chaotic. I had a pretty crazy Friday night last week. I couldn't even begin to describe it to you on this public blog even if I wanted to (okay, fine, I do want to, but I won't attempt it). Falling asleep at two in the morning, I reflected on all the emotions, good and bad. Mostly good. I am familiar with the good feelings, I know them well, I don't need to examine 'em too closely. The bad feelings, though... they weren't bad bad, but they were different, and slightly mysterious. The conclusion I came to was that there was, maybe, a bit too much chaos in my life on this particular night. You meet a cute girl and a couple hours later she's rubbing cocaine on her gums, that kind of shit. I don't shy away from all that, but I definitely am self-aware enough to wonder whether this is something that I should regularly be inviting into my life. Long-term effects, I guess is what we're talking about here. Long-term chaos and what it does to the mind. I like it in short bursts. I am scared at the idea of it being sustained. It's a work in progress.
The stakes are way lower when it comes to music, so there is more room to explore safely without that fear. I could listen to the most bonkers, unintelligibly wacky noise—and have, occasionally, in this very music club we call home—and it might be disorienting, and at worst it might be unenjoyable, but it's never going to, ya know, make my life worse in any way. It's nothing to be scared of. Music gives you the safety net of: none of this actually matters. Out there, in the real world, there's plenty of shit that matters, plenty of high stakes that you need to be aware of, plenty of steps to take to make sure you live your best life. In here, with the music, it's all good no matter what. I can listen to Converge. I can try to understand the language. I can get turned around so many times by the metal-infused mathcore time signatures that I reach for the proverbial barf bag. But at the end of the day, it was just some fun little way to pass the time.
This is an album review and not a treatise on a life well-lived and so I will tell you that I like Love Is Not Enough even though I didn't quite understand it. I kind of liked it in the same way I kind of liked, e.g., Yambag, or Person(a), or even Tool. And I kind of liked it for the same exact reasons as I kind of liked those other albums—it's more about appreciating the experience of this music than appreciating the music itself. And I am thinking now that I think it's similar to the idea of experiences short-term brushes with chaos in the real world, how I can shake my head and laugh at the crazy things I've seen, and appreciate them for what they are, that they exist and that I saw them and was privy to them, but that they are in no way going to be enveloped into my own life in any real, tangible way. I have zero presumptions that I will be listening to Converge in any serious way after this week, but at the end of this week, on another Friday, as I sit down and reflect on how it all went down, I shake my head and smirk and marvel at having witnessed the chaos, and having survived to see another day.
The comparison of Fridays ends here, however, and that's due to that aforementioned safety net of music. With that safety net comes a responsibility to take even more risks. I know I don't need to surround myself constantly with the chaos that I was surrounded by last week, but I know that I do need to constantly surround myself with the chaos of music. It's the only way to continue to build these muscles that I've attempted to build over the past six or seven years. I listen to Converge and I recoil, but only at first. The next step is to turn back toward it, bravely face it, and then try to pull it into my life as close as I possibly can. At least for a little bit. It's the only way I'll learn.
So what have I learned this week, after listening to Love Is Not Enough enough times to get a sense of what it is and how it speaks? The first thing I learned came from the idea that this is a late-stage album for this particular hardcore-metalcore-whatever band, and the subsequent idea that this is late in their career and they are going this hard is something to marvel at. Within the last year (I don't remember when), I saw their seminal 2001 album Jane Doe on a list of "Best Albums of the 21st Century So Far," and, having never heard of this band before, decided to dip my toes in and give it a shot. Not for me, I thought at the time. It was gently removed from the "try it" list on my phone. So it was cool to almost immediately get another swing at it. 25 years separate Jane Doe and Love Is Not Enough. By all accounts, this new album is critically acclaimed, if not yet "Best of the Century"-level acclaimed at this quick juncture. I appreciate the fact that this is an older, experienced band still really, honestly going for it.
The second thing I learned came from the idea that I still find this music impenetrable, though the cracks in that outlook at starting to show a little bit. I had a noticeably better grasp on this album and this sound at the end of the week than I did at the beginning. Now I can hear something like "Gilden Cage" and at least understand its verse-chorus structure. And the wacky time signatures is something I should be able to lean into, no? Isn't the idea that non-4/4 shit is something to be embraced for all its unintelligible bafflement an idea that I've long espoused? Just because Converge has that plus the growling and screaming of metal music doesn't mean I gotta get rid of my core musical beliefs. This is some harsh shit, but you crack it open, and, I dunno, maybe you find something worth knowing.
I want to know this music so bad, and I can feel it, I'm right on the fucking cusp. But I'm not there yet. I just get frustrated because the whole "letting the music you don't understand wash over you" thing is absolutely a worthy concept but I have absolutely worn it out for myself. I am at the point that I'm leaning on this as a shortcut every time something "difficult" comes across my desk. But then on the other hand, I didn't reach the point where I liked Converge enough to want to explore this band and this genre any more than I already do. In other words, I fear that if I told myself that I was going to listen to nothing by mathmetalcore for an entire month, I would end that month knowing the genre and its language very well, but also feel worse for it. It would be like learning to speak Bulgarian. I could get really good at speaking in Bulgarian, but for what? When the fuck would I ever need to speak Bulgarian? What joy would that bring me? Especially if the whole point would be to connect to people and there's not really anyone I know who speaks Bulgarian so when the fuck would I be connecting?
Okay, now that I'm writing it out that way, I'm thinking that maybe it's a bad comparison, because I do know people who speak this language, the language that Converge speaks. Nate, for the most direct example, the blogger who chose this album and with whom I have connected specifically through music more than almost anyone else in my life in the last 20 years (almost exactly half of his life, and more than half of mine), a man who is no doubt crafting a positive, optimistic review of this album as we speak. Because he gets it. And I want that. I want to get it. I just fear that "getting it" will turn out to all be for naught. There are days when I think I should just do the easy thing and listen to Titus Andronicus or the National or Sufjan Stevens again, something known, a language I know already, can speak in my sleep. Isn't that what music is all about? Finding easy joy in the shit that you know?
Well, I don't know about that. It's been on my mind lately, all of that. Like, why we listen to music, and what the stakes are in terms of listening to new music or strange music or music that you probably won't like but then taking that music seriously anyway. But I think I needed a night like last Friday night to put things in perspective. There is joy in exploring the unknown, in experiencing the discomforting, in witnessing chaos firsthand. But there's also a fear that the chaos will be too much, and that you'll get too close and your knees will buckle and everything you've built will fall. That's all happening out there, but in here, it's just music. It sounds chaotic too sometimes, sure, but it's just music, man. You can do whatever you want with it, and it ain't nothing to be fearful of regardless. I am not afraid of Converge. They are chaotic, and I lived the chaos, at least for a little bit. I feel like I'm better for it.
GRADE: 3 pukes out of 5

No comments:
Post a Comment