Monday, April 13, 2026

Monday Morning Mixtape 067: Your Mixtape Summons in the Mail

Welcome to Monday Morning Mixtape, a PoYB Contributor-curated playlist of songs, made just for you at the start of each week.


"Your Mixtape Summons in the Mail"
Songs for jury duty
chosen by Gloria







"Jury Duty" by Joan of Arc
from Testimonium Songs, 2013

This is the first time I've picked a MMM theme without any song ideas in mind. I was summoned to jury duty last Monday and thought, "Sure, that's a mixtape theme." I ended up not even having to go. I got an email Sunday night that read, "You are no longer needed to report on 04/06/2026 for your Jury Service. You will be given credit for your service and will not be called again for at least one year from the date. You are instructed to go to work as you normally would. However, if you have already made arrangements for coverage at your place of employment, and cannot report to work, you MUST report to jury duty as scheduled at 8:15 AM." And I don't understand why you would have to go only if you've already arranged work coverage? It makes no sense to me. Either you want me there, or you don't.  —Gloria


"Waiting" by Green Day
from Warning, 2000

Here's my jury duty story: I've never been to jury duty. I got the letter maybe twelve years. They told me to take the online survey to see if I had to go. One of the questions was "Have you ever been convicted of a crime," and I selected "yes," even though I don't know if that's actually true. I wasn't lying, I was just being cautious—I didn't want them to be like "you lied on your pre-jury duty online survey, and selected 'no' even though you received multiple underage drinking citations in your youth?!" I suppose that's not really a "conviction." I don't know, man! I choked under the pressure! And now, I seem to have been removed from all jury duty lists. Even though I'm one of the few people who would get paid a full wage for jury duty. I'm a government worker. I would fucking LOVE to get sequestered. But alas, it doesn't seem to be in the cards.

I don't know how I'm going to fill five more blurbs.  —Joe


"I Don't Live Here Anymore" by the War on Drugs

I recently caught up with a family friend who just moved back to the area after living overseas for a few years. One topic that came up was how they still were getting jury duty notices from Philadelphia forwarded to this other country they were living in. There's not much more of a story there, just one of those moments that make you shake your head...  —Batts


"Garden Gnome" by Lebanon Hanover
from Sci-Fi Sky, 2020

Actually, no, scratch that, I have at least one more thing I could say about jury duty. But I've already said it a lot on the blog. Jury duty, as featured in the fifth season episode of Reba, called "Grannies Gone Wild." This song was featured on the GGW playlist at the end of that project. There's a whole story that came together over the course of that summer, how Barbara Jean is on the jury for a capital punishment trial, how Texas executes you if you are convicted of steal a garden gnome, how there's a garden gnome on the jury, how that garden gnome speaks exclusively in catchphrases about deli meats, how........... oh god, what am I doing with my life, oh god. I was watching Grease tonight, and remembered that one of the lawyers in the background of that scene is canonically Eddie Deezen, the actor who plays Eugene in Grease. The lore goes as deep as you wanna follow it. Come back to Puke on Your Birthday at some point to read more about Eddie. Maybe his thoughts about 'Til Death. Today is the 1714th day in a row that Puke on Your Birthday has published something, but what they don't tell you is that every single post in that time is ESSENTIAL.  —Joe


"Not Guilty" by George Harrison
from George Harrison, 1979

The first time I was summoned for jury duty, I had to request a reschedule because I had a work trip planned. That was easy enough, and they gave me a new date. I got to the courthouse on that date, and they separated everyone into different groups. They did not call me. Once everyone was gone and I was the only one left, I told the person who was assigning people that I had never called. They told me I "definitely was" and asked for my name. Then they said, "Oh, you’re not on my list. You can leave." Beautiful. I went to the Reading Public Museum afterward and saw an exhibit of famous buildings recreated in toothpicks.  —Gloria


"Green Typewriters IX" by the Olivia Tremor Control
from Music from the Unrealized Film Script: Dusk at Cubist Castle, 1996

"How much longer / can I wait?" I would imagine there is a lot of waiting at jury duties, no? I've never been. I'm pretty good at waiting, though. I can keep myself occupied. I can just sit there. I was in a bad mood last year at the beach and basically spent five hours a day for a whole week sitting in my beach chair and not doing anything but staring at the ocean. I would probably be pretty good at jury duty. One time in high school we did this "day of service" thing and me and a dozen other guys I didn't know and two teachers (probably in their early 20s at the time honestly) I didn't know were at retirement facility or something, and we ended like two hours early, and they put us in a room, and no one knew each other and no one was motivated to say anything, so we all just sat there in silence for two hours. I overheard one of the teachers remark to someone else on the bus ride that it was one of the most uncomfortable days of his life. I don't remember it that way. I was cool just twiddling my thumbs and waiting it out.  —Joe


"Myxomatosis (Judge, Jury & Executioner)" by Radiohead
from Hail to the Thief, 2003

I, like many of my peers, didn't really know anything about politics and "how it all works" until a disgusting pedophile successfully ran for president in the mid-'10s. But I recall being cognizant of at least some moral sticking points as early as 2004. I wasn't old enough to vote, but I was old enough to understand the disconnect between what was right and what people believed. My one friend's dad was handing out political material during the 2004 Presidential election, outside of church, and I grabbed one, and it had, among other Useful Facts, that we should vote for George W. Bush because he was pro-death penalty. Even as a dumbass teenager, I was like, hold up, what? How is executing people following the church's teachings? It doesn't follow the church's teachings, or Jesus's teachings, at the very least. Pretty sure the dude who was executed by the state wouldn't be pro-state-execution. But what the fuck do I know.  —Joe


"The Court of the Crimson King" by King Crimson
from In the Court of the Crimson King, 1969

I already know that Joe is going to say that this sounds too much like Jesus Christ Superstar. He says this as if Jesus Christ Superstar is not *quite literally* hit after hit. It's an outstanding soundtrack and the only musical soundtrack I'll listen to. As someone who used to do musical theater, there are four roles I would step back on stage for, no questions asked: 1) Judas in Jesus Christ Superstar, 2) Mary Magdalene in Jesus Christ Superstar, 3) The Leading Player in Pippin, and 4) Ms. Hannigan in Annie.  —Gloria


"Please, Judge" by Roky Erikson
from True Love Cast Out All Evil, 2010

Haven't listened to this song in a hot minute, but I know that written and sung by a dude (backed by Okkervil River, sidenote) who is intimately aware of how judges hold extraordinary power and can abuse that power. Roky spent a lot of time in mental health facilities for marijuana use, probably more than he should've been, but he was ordered there by a judge. He was also stealing people's mail, so there was some legit mental health worries. But it's crazy to me that a judge could just be like "you seem crazy, off to lock-up for you." I've had some bad run-ins with some shitty judges. I used to spend so much time in court. Oh shit, duh, I totally could've written about all that in one of these blurbs. But I never really had any contact with a jury. These weren't criminal trials. They were [censored].  —Joe


"Famous" by Jenn Champion
a single, 2023

Believe it or not, I've heard a story firsthand about a celebrity's experience being called in for jury duty. I'll avoid any identifying details, but I can say that they pointed out to the court that their status as a public figure made it difficult for them to act as a juror, in the event that the defendant recognized this celebrity. The judge allegedly tried to downplay this celebrity's level of fame, though that strategy might have been jeopardized by the claim that several employees at the courthouse asked for this celebrity's autograph. And, no, they were ultimately not chosen for the jury, but it's an amusing little tale.  —Batts


"The Number" by Woods
from Songs of Shame, 2009

You get your number called, and you're on the jury. That's how it works. I would know. I've seen jury duties on the television. That one show, right? With the guy who thought he was on a jury, even though it was all fake. Boy, that show really dropped the ball in the last episode, didn't it? Way too much pat-on-the-back bullshit. Let the dude understand that he was on a TV show, and then let him ride off into the distance. We don't need to see him get every single hidden camera pointed out to him. Oh god, what was the name of that show? Was it just Jury Duty? I forget. I fucking hate TV shows so goddamn much. Except New Girl. That was a good show. Remember when Jess was on jury duty, sequestered, and the smoking hot [whatever her name was, I forget and am not looking it up] replaced her for like six episodes? Shit, what's her name. Was she the one in Jennifer's Body? Oh wait, Megan Fox? I mix her up with someone else all the time. Olivia Munn, I think. Which one was on New Girl? I don't know. Honestly, I don't really care. I hate TV. I love music, though. This is a good song.  —Joe


"The Trial" by Pink Floyd
from The Wall, 1979

I told everyone that I had jury duty on the days leading up to it last week. It was my big piece of small talk. I was lowkey very excited for it and bummed that they didn't need me. Because how often do you get to be on a jury? Sure, maybe it will be boring, but maybe it will be really interesting? Maybe you'll get picked for an actual jury! You get to do your civic duty and hang out with random strangers, deliberating someone's fate—a wild way to spend a weekday. I also like how the jury commissioner can send you a letter like, "Hey, babe, I need you call off work on Monday. Maybe you can help us solve this crime?πŸ§πŸ˜‡πŸ€žπŸ’› Thankssss!!" In all honesty, I think it could be a really educational and interesting experience. There is a running joke that people want to get out of jury duty. If you are one of those people, have you actually sat on a jury? Is it really that bad of an experience?  —Gloria


NEXT WEEK: "The Mixtape" — Songs whose titles could be titles of a Seinfeld episode, i.e. they follow the format of "The _____" (chosen by Joe)

12 comments:

Joe K said...

There are some themes—including many that I come up with, for better or worse—where I'm like, "no way we're gonna be able to come up with many songs for this one." So even a dozen songs related to jury duty was an incredible achievement in blogging, in my opinion. A fun mixtape. Thanks to all those who contributed or are listening currently.

Joe K said...

I was aware of and liked King Crimson before my '70s prog rock "sounds like Jesus Christ Superstar" opinion was fully crystalized, so this song avoids that particular criticism. If I was hearing it for the first time? Hell yeah, this is absolutely something Judas would sing. "In the Court of Pontius Pilate."

Joe K said...

The Roky Erikson song in the YouTube playlist is not the one I intended. But I liked this one too, so I'm just gonna keep it. Definitely check out that album though, if you wanna hear some sad-ass music from the tail end of a rough life.

Joe K said...

My guess for Batts' celebrity blurb (and if someone gets it right, he is contractually obligated to confirm, under blog law): Sylvester Stallone.

Gloria said...

I had 5 more songs that didn’t make the final cut :

1. Judge Not- Bob Marley
2. Jury Judge and Executioner- Aaron’s for Peace
3. Jury Duty- the O.C. Supertones
4. Lawyers in Love- Jackson Browne
5. Sue Me- Sabrina Carpenter

I think this was one of the first themes where searching on something like Spotify/Apple music was be more helpful than scrolling through song titles on an iPod. If I had more time to write I could have got this mixtape to an hour

Gloria said...

Atoms for peace — autocorrect is working too hard this morning

Gloria said...

I ended up at a burlesque show on Saturday night with other random acts including an ventriloquist who’s puppet was telling dirty jokes and a magician who started his act by saying, “this is how I get out of jury duty.” He did a card trick where an audience member wrote her name on a card and it ended up in his pocket. I could not figure out the trick or how that would get him out of jury duty

Joe K said...

I've never listened to Atoms for Peace, but did see that one on a google search, and was wondering whether it was similar to the Radiohead song I chose here, since that's the subtitle. Or maybe Thom Yorke just really likes that phrase. I suppose I could've just listened to the Atoms song, but I didn't.

Joe K said...

Someone should make a movie called 12 Angry Magicians.

Batts said...

I can reveal who in private, but will confirm: NOT Stallone!

Batts said...

"Someone should make a movie called 12 Angry Magicians." Isn't that The Prestige, in a way?

Joe K said...

Okay, next guess: Frank Stallone.