Saturday, April 11, 2026

Book Club Review and Discussion: Five Decembers by James Kestrel

Four times per year, some dudes and/or non-female-identifying humans get together for book club. Because this is how my brain functions now, here on the blog, I find it helpful to gather my thoughts in blog post form, really about anything but especially about books. So I've taken to writing down brief thoughts and discussion questions here over the last couple years, just to get my shit in order before we sit down at whatever bar or eatery or public park or private house that quarter's captain has chosen for us to meet. Here are some thoughts. If you do not identify as a woman, and you're interested in joining a book club, hit me up!

spoilers for this book below!!!!

The cool thing about Five Decembers is that it sets you up at the beginning to think that this is gonna be your typical gumshoe detective mystery. By the end of the first section, it pulls the rug out from under you completely. It's not hard to guess as to how they do it, once you realize that the initial setting of the plot is late November 1941 in Hawaii. But the way that real history in that specific time and place is woven into the fabric of the who-done-it is... well, I think the best way to say it is that it's the opposite of Forrest Gump. The protagonist is deeply affected by the war in very specific ways, but he is, at the end of the day, more of a witness to its horrors than an active participant in it. This makes the stakes feel personal, and thus, there's an empathy here that is often missing in your typical detective story.

In terms of the actual bones of the writing, Kestrel does a great fucking job. The descriptions of that time and place are extremely vivid. Not that I've read too many detective novels, but I get the sense they are plot-first novels. We've read books in book club that were like this, where the words are at the service of telling a story. We've read other books where the words themselves are beautiful, regardless of whether the story is satisfying or not. I'm still leaning toward placing Five Decembers in the former category, but it's on the fence more than I would've expected. There are little moments throughout the book that I stopped and was like, damn that's beautiful. But overall, we're moving full-steam-ahead to the conclusion, and that's fun too.

GRADE: 4 pukes out of 5

Discussion Questions:

1. How about that ending? Was it necessary? And more importantly, what do we think the "basic principle" was? The answer may seem obvious, but maybe it's not.

2. Do you think the mystery / who-done-it was concluded satisfactorily? Did all the clues make sense?

3. Was there anything in the plot that felt like a good swerve, something unexpected? It's tough to read a book that doesn't surprise you at all. I felt like I was satisfactorily surprised by many of the developments here.

4. The title is beautiful, in my opinion. How it gives a sense of how things repeat, cycle, come back after being gone. How everything matters. Or am I reading into it too much?

5. What lessons can we take from this book, especially in the way that it was unequivocally anti-nazi, and especially as we live through the rise of nazism in America?

6. Did the connections between characters feel real and true? The cover of the book probably gives away what the author intended to be the truest relationship in Joe McGrady's life, but still.

7. Did you agree with how the author handled Pearl Harbor? The atom bomb? Does it matter?

8. Joe was pretty down on himself, saying that he made so many wrong choices. Do you agree with him? Or was it just humans expressing normal regret about how things turned out?

9. Did anyone else notice (or even keep track of) how many times Joe said "Okay."? It felt after a while like a koan, something to calm him as the world around him burned.

10. How does this compare to other detective novels, etc. etc. etc.

No comments: