Thursday, April 16, 2026

Never Seen It #304: Matchstick Men

I spent last Tuesday watching 500 movies I've never seen before. And the whole time I was watching my movies, I was worrying that I, I might vomit. And the whole time, I was thinking, "I'm a grown man. I should know what goes on my head." And the more I thought about it... the more I realized that I should just blog my brains out and end it all. But then I thought, well, if I thought more about blogging my brains out...


Matchstick Men
2003
Ridley Scott

Thanks to all those who conned me into thinking that they were going to blog about Matchstick Men.

~~~~~~~~~~~~

Allison

Matchstick Men is a fun film that reminds us that there is no honor amongst thieves and no friends amongst con men. Nicholas Cage and Sam Rockwell delightfully play the exact roles you would expect them to. Cage's Roy is an eccentric, neurotic head case, and Rockwell's Frank is a smarmy but affable sidekick. There are no surprises here. The familiarity in these characters lulls you into a sense of comfort and security. I know these guys, I see what they're doing here, I get what's going on. The film weaves a charming story, at times a bit saccharine and a bit boring. Then Matchstick Men pulls off a late third-act climax that catches you off guard. Misdirection. A classic switcharoo when you weren't looking. It hurts to admit, but I got got. It's a fun twist, albeit a bit implausible. There are just a few too many moving pieces in the final scam to make it wholly believable. But I was along for the ride. I would have liked to see Frank get his comeuppance, but maybe, just maybe, both men got what they wanted in the end.

3 stars
(One, two, three. One, two, three. One, two, three)

~~~~~~~~~~~~

Sam

I hadn't seen an unhinged Nick Cage performance in a while, so it took some time to settle into the more batshit line readings and decisions he made here. Usually, I would criticize an actor like Cage (or very much Cage specifically) for blending a bunch of weird decisions in the service of depicting what they view as "mentally handicapped" or neurodivergent. That frequently results in a messy soup of yelps and ticks. 

That is on display here. But the plotting productively undercuts Cage's character and doesn't indicate he is realistic. His behavior isn't the natural manifestation of chemical, genetic, or trauma induced outcomes—it's a psychosomatic result of his own guilt. Because he is proven to be full of shit by "Doctor" Bruce Altman, it actually kind of works. 

Credit to Ridley Scott for pulling that off.  Reminds me of Soderbergh's ability to elevate baseline trashy genre flicks. 

The movie itself is a sometimes fun, sometimes cringey con-artist thriller with Sam Rockwell trying a little too hard but Alison Lohman playing well off of Cage. It works enough where you feel for Cage as the plot unfolds and some of his coming to terms with shit were genuinely compelling—maybe at times in spite of himself. 

With twisty movies like this, you need to really be floored by the outcome to overlook some inconsistencies or lack of character development. Cage is fully realized but by the nature of the plot, no one else is. And the twist isn't good enough to overcome it. 

Better than I expected!

3 pukes

~~~~~~~~~~

Sunny

I remember seeing the trailer for this back in the day, but never getting around to the movie. Not exactly sure how it got made; the sort of early '00s film that is decently casted, perfectly competent, and totally forgettable. It was a glorious time for paperback novels and their optioners.

Ridley Scott is good enough of a movie-maker that it's competent, and he reaches for some loftier themes, but a little bit short. The attraction here is Nic Cage, who I know many decry, but I'll always go to the bat for. He's always the best thing in whatever he's in, and this is no exception. This is a role for him. Some unassembled thoughts:
  • I love Cage, I sort of like Rockwell, seeing him grinning about, and Lohman is perfectly competent. I enjoyed some of the character actors
  • The soundtrack was fun and easy, old timey, sort of Sting-like (movie, not artist)
  • Spearmint Rhino? Meh. New York Super Fudge Chunk? Meh.
  • We started to think it was a Con on Cage about halfway through, but then about 60% of the way through that thought would be too obvious. But then, of course, it was. That and the grocery store clerk love interest were the most 2003 things hanging around.
  • How did they orchestrate some of this con exactly? When did it happen? How much of it was planned vs. opportunistic? How did they know Cage would try to call his ex and Dr. Klein would get the number?
  • Cage gets to be literally mentally whatever in this movie and really let loose. We like that. He starts with some kind of mild OCD and then builds into full-on psychosis? How about that first scene with Klein? How about that scene at the drug store? Genius stuff.
  • There is some reach towards a morale here with the psychosomatic symptoms of criminality, conning only those who are looking to lose their money, etc., but none of it really ties together. Let the viewer do it I guess.
  • But I guess, by the end Cage sees it as "giving away the money" and he seems at peace at the mattress store or whatever. Maybe Dr. Klein was a good doctor after all.
Can anyone tell me why they're called "Matchstick Men"? Anyway, decent enough—give this 3.5 / 5 confidence pukes.

~~~~~~~~~~~

Joe

Yessss, I love getting conned by the conman movie. You can't just tell a story about matchstick men without lighting the match for the audience too. I'm really glad that Matchstick Men got us in on the action. Although I'll be curious to see how many people were able to guess the ruse before it was revealed at the end. Am I just an idiot? There's really only two choices here: either it was a really well-constructed movie that ably managed to pull one over on its audience, or I'm a fucking moron. I'd like to think it was the former. If it's the latter, then that's a pessimistic way of looking at the world. It lacks humility in a way. It's our responsibility to be open to surprises. You ever been to a surprise party and the person being surprised is actually not surprised and instead comes in the back door and yells "ha! tricks on you! I knew about this the whole time!"? The idea of that happening makes me uncomfortable. I liked watching Matchstick Men just taking it all in, allowing myself to get sucked into the twists and turns of its narrative, and, yes, feeling bamboozled in the last 20 minutes, in the best way possible.

The one thing that I was skeptical about was the characterization of Nicolas Cage's Roy Waller as someone with OCD and Tourette's. Not that I didn't think it was interesting—Cage does an incredible job hitting the right notes here, never overplaying it, never parodying it—but I wondered how it would tie into the flimflam narrative. An unfavorable scenario would be that his behavioral health disorders create added complications to the cons that he's trying to pull. But something better happened, as the film progressed. OCD and Tourette's became roadblocks, not for living his lies, but for living his truths. Despite getting royally fucked in the long con, Roy seems to have come out the other side all the better. He still has a connection to his fake daughter, his symptoms are minimal, and he's having a real child with his love interest. I know that's not how mental health actually works, but it felt right for this narrative—he is cured by forgoing his life of lies and succumbing to what is real and true.

But all that is perhaps secondary to the thrill ride of conning and being conned. It's just a fun fucking movie, ya know? I like those types of movies, the ones that zip by you, and land a few punches along the way. It's nice to forget about the world for a few hours, more specifically forget about the responsibilities we have as humans to be kind to one another, and slip for two hour or less into the role of cheerleader for criminals and liars. It's more fun down here, as it turns out. It's not the right thing to do, stealing $80,000 from anyone, but the movie wants you to forget what's right and wrong for a little bit (plus, hey, fuck that guy, he doesn't tip his valet!), and root for the bad guys. Take that dude's money! Pull off the scheme! Let's fucking go! And then the credits roll and you go back to your tiny little life and your legitimate job that doesn't pay enough to warrant a safety deposit box.

Should we bother pulling at the strings of the long con, to understand if it's legitimate? I don't know. The more I think about it, the more I'm leaning toward the fact that such a long con would only ever work in the movies. It just feels like a lot of people we in on it, ya know? Partner Frank, fake daughter Angela, fake therapist Dr. Klein, fake Chuck, two fake detectives. Who am I missing? Was the lady at the laundromat in on it? Probably not. But you can see how you might start questioning everything after such a scheme. This is the internal logic of Matchstick Men: the con man gets conned. I'm willing to buy into it, even if the logistics seem impossible. I'm willing to buy into it because that's what the movie is about, and if I were to deny that, then life would be a lot less fun. I don't want to be the guy who is spoiling his own surprise birthday party. I want to be surprised, and I'm going to hang onto those times when true surprise finds me.

GRADE: 3.5 pukes out of 5

~~~~~~~~~~~~

GROUP AVERAGE GRADE: 3.125 pukes out of 5

Switching a briefcase with $10,000 in it with a briefcase with 10,000 comments in it. See below.

(NEXT TIME: Quick pit stop in the '90s for Reality Bites.)

9 comments:

sunny said...

3.125? I'm triggered by the old math hanging out

I'm glad we all liked this (enough) and had fun (enough). Anything to help keep the Scott film empire chugging along.

Joe K said...

I think I would have originally given this a 4/5, but thought a little too much about the logistics of the twist ending, and bumped it down a half a puke. Still so much fun, though. Anyone who doesn't like Nicholas Cage in this one doesn't know how to enjoy movies!!!!

Sam Fran said...

"It was a glorious time for paperback novels and their optioners." -- good stuff, sunny

Sam Fran said...

Two related questions: How was the exchanging money scheme supposed to work? How were they purporting to con Chuck?

It was some sort of value of currency exchange but they were getting ahead of the banks, so they made money? And then they lied to Chuck about the value in the ultimate con? COULD NOT FOLLOW

Joe K said...

My interpretation, which has not been confirmed anywhere before typing this comment, so take it with a grain of salt:

Frank tells Chuck that Roy works at a bank and has a scheme. The scheme, as told to Chuck, is that Roy uses his powers at the bank to make money off of exchange-rate fuckery, e.g. if you give me $500 worth of American dollars, I can give you English pounds worth $600 American. Roy is saying that this is done through some power he has at the bank. Roy is lying. In the trust-building first step, Roy actually loses money, because he's giving (I don't remember the exact amount) $2000-worth English pounds to Chuck in exchange for $1500 American that Chuck gave him. Roy tells Frank at one point that it's worth losing money now because they are going to make more than that later.

Then the final step is that Chuck is going to do the same thing, but with a LOT more money. He's gonna give him $80k in American, and Roy is going to give him more than $80k American worth in British notes. They are going to exchange in the airport. Except, what Chuck doesn't know is that the briefcase with the British money is going to be swapped out when he's not looking. Roy walks away with both the briefcase of real British money and the bag of real American money, and Chuck only finds out the money in his briefcase is fake after Roy and Frank disappear from Chuck's life forever.

None of this takes into account that it's all fake, but Roy doesn't know this. I'm typing from Roy's perspective, as in what he is attempting to devise as his con.

Sam Fran said...

I think that's it! I was trying to hard to figure out the first fake con, but since that's a lie for Chuck, it doesn't have to totally work. Nick Cage just needs to look "busy" and "important."

Sam Fran said...

Also, I read this on Letterbox and really like it!

"I love how Alison Lohman looks about a decade older than 14. That's not a mistake. She and Frank knew that Roy would have no idea what a 14 year old looks like"

Just give her a skateboard and let it rip!

Sam Fran said...

https://www.reddit.com/r/TheSimpsons/comments/1l0w0da/simpsons_confession_i_cant_tell_hans_moleman_and/#lightbox

sunny said...

don't have a cow, roy!