Friday, April 24, 2026

Discussion — Week 377: "Pussy Cats" Starring the Walkmen by the Walkmen


Josie and the Pussycats unfortunately do not have any full-length albums. Trust me, I checked. I was hoping I could extend the joke past these two albums. But no one, as far as I know, not even Josie and the Pussycats, has covered "Pussy Cats" Starring the Walkmen by the Walkmen in full. I was telling Nate this last week, and I'll tell you now—I'm hoping that, in a couple years, to celebrate PoYB's 20th anniversary, we can put together our own album of music, to honor all the best music we've shared over this blog's long history. And you can bet your ass that we'll be covering "Loop de Loop" by Johnny Thunder by Harry Nilsson by the Walkmen.

For now, let's chat one last time about Pussy Cats / "Pussy Cats". How'd the reviews go the second time around? I'm very curious to hear final thoughts on this new gag for RC.

10 comments:

Joe K said...

Sitting here in the office, listening to Pussy Cat (the Walkmen version this time) for the final time in a while. It's been a good two weeks. Shout out to all those who didn't like the album in either form but listened to both dutifully. I hope your life is fuller now than it was two weeks ago.

Joe K said...

I think "Why would the Walkmen do this?!" is a fantastic question. I hope people found the answers they were looking for this week. The existence of the question makes me wonder if Record Club would benefit from some sort of mid-week check-in. I know such a thing would be logistically impossible, since we've been hanging on by a thread for seven years now and can't handle any further expansion, I'm speaking hypothetically. My pal Gene (who is choosing the album three Sundays from now) was telling me about a music club that he is a part of in which someone chooses two albums in one month, and they sporadically spend the entire month in a group chat, casually talking about the album. I liked that. I wonder what the month-long conversation would have looked like if we had chosen both versions of Pussy Cats for this month. Maybe the question of "Why?" could have been answered and informed opinions before they were etched in stone.

Joe K said...

Zach's review made me ponder this week. Ponder about RC. Worry, too. Worry that my four pals on this blog feel "pressured" or "obligated" to participate in RC every week. (These are concerns that I've voiced to Sunny many times over the years.)

I do emphatically believe that life is better if 1) you are listening to music and 2) are writing on a blog. But I don't want to create a space in which you NEED to listen to music in order to feel PRESSURE to write about that music. That's no fun either.

I will admit that I've been leaning on a trick that Zach alluded to in his review this week, and you can see it in my own review for this one. The idea of "writing about something else." I won't go back and count my own reviews and how many times I've done this in 2026, but there's this idea that there's "something else" I want to write about, and I write about it in an album review. The trick—that might be helpful to Zach—is to simply find a way to connect the "something else" with your opinion about the album. How does the "something else" inform what you think about the album? If you can bridge that gap, then you can write about whatever the fuck you want.

E.g. Zach seemed pretty sad about some of the family stuff he mentioned in the review. Seems like a pretty relevant emotion to such an album as this!

None of what I'm saying is instruction. I'm just typing just to type, like always. But I sincerely do hope only that people are having fun here, and if they aren't, that they find it within themselves to step away from the slimy tentacles of the blog for a bit, and come back refreshed.

Joe K said...

Oh yeah, one thing I thought we'd get more of is "what is my personal history with the Walkmen." Maybe none of us have listened to much of them before this. I know I haven't. My experience with the Walkmen began and ended with "The Rat," that is until this week. Now it begins with "The Rat" and ends in infinite repeats of "Loop de Loop."

sunny said...

Come for the music, stay for the blogging

I did laugh at the cat story, from the emotional distance of 15 odd miles. We definitely lost two full ass meatballs during a dinner party and a moment of lapsed attention. I love animals but they can be the worst.

sunny said...

It helped reading yours and Nate's writeups about the personal context for the band, their sadness, and how much that does/doesn't matter ultimately

Joe K said...

That's what I'm saying—sometimes I regret that the timeline of ~five days is probably too short for a mid-week check-in, like, hey, how's it going, what do we think of the album so far, what info can we share that would be mutually beneficial.

It might also be that this right here, the reviews on Friday, could be considered the "check-in," and then people can take the info and listen to the album more if they want to. But then there's another album just around the corner, so I figure that doesn't happen too often.

Just some spare thoughts during a rare two-week sojourn with the same songs in only slightly different form.

Zach said...

Been meaning to respond to this. I don't feel pressured to participate, and any "pressure" that exists is self-imposed, because I know you don't ever expect participation (although it's normal to hope for it, I think that's human). I do try to write about something else on the way, sometimes, and that is helpful.

For whatever reason the albums this year have been harder for me to connect to, but I'm hoping the summer opens things up for me.

And as for the family things - it's hard. It's hard living far away from my family. I don't know. An ongoing conversation, both with them and internally (but mostly internally).

Zach said...

"I prefer Hamilton Leithauser's vocals to Harry's" - I can relate in that I prefer Seth Avett/Jessica Lea Mayfield's covers of Elliot Smith to Elliot Smith himself.

Zach said...

Cat story is very relatable. I worry sometimes about my capacity for relationships. Like, everything will be going great, and I'm in, and then all of a sudden a comment like that is made, and I say to myself "this will never work." And then think about how I should just end it. Just because of one comment like that! When really - you build a foundation, and comments are made, and life happens, and that's the way it is. I don't know. What do I know? I've never lived with a partner, never shared an animal with one, never lived the day to day with children around too.