You ever hear of the Five-Albums Test? Made up by music critic and PoYB foil Steven Hyden, it's a theory that an artist is only one of the greats if their discography features, at any point, five near perfect albums in a row. This test exists for music geeks who get their rocks off arguing about this kind of shit. I am one of those geeks, and so I think about the Five-Albums Test a lot. You can argue about which bands pass the test. You can also argue about whether a band's failure of the test means that the test is flawed. Like, Wolf Parade is absolutely one of the all-time great bands in rock history, but according to the test, they aren't, because we can all agree that 2020's just okay Thin Mind halted the streak at four near perfect albums.
When I was reading about Hyden's takes on Spoon for that Blind Spot a few months ago, I came across this mention of Black Sabbath: "I personally feel like Black Sabbath made ten awesome LPs in a row, from 1970's Black Sabbath to 1981's Mob Rules. But am I prepared to enter a court of law and testify on the record that 1976's Technical Ecstasy and 1978's Never Say Die! are top-to-bottom perfect albums with no filler? No, I am not." Subtracting from there, we can deduce that Hyden believes that the first six Black Sabbath albums are near perfect. They pass the test.
I don't think I'm going to get there. Going slightly out of order, I'm now familiar with their first four. Paranoid came to me before blogging about every piece of music I listen to was a thing. Master of Reality was an early Blind Spot. Then the self-titled debut hit Record Club. Now we are considering Vol. 4, obviously their fourth LP. I have similar feelings about Sabbath but with much less commitment than Hyden: all four are awesome albums, but I'm unwilling to say any of them (maybe Paranoid at most) are near perfect.
My issue is that, after you do this enough times, the music starts to sound the same. Black Sabbath were pioneers in hard rock, I know that. This is a classic sound. But I think at a certain point, "near perfect" is gonna have to involve some intense improvements or adjustments. And while Black Sabbath stand far and above most of their peers when considering the discography at large, I don't think Vol. 4 does enough to distinguish itself from any of the three albums that came before it.
That's an extremely pessimistic way of describing this badass album. On top of the pessimism, it's borderline moronic, since Vol. 4 really does a lot of heavy lifting in terms of "adjusting" Black Sabbath's sound. That's what a fourth album should be, right? By the fourth, it's time to mix it up. One of the most famous Sabbath songs, "Changes," is on here, and I think that alone qualifies Vol. 4 to be "something new." A slow piano ballad? Absolutely new for these guys at this juncture. I don't know if I necessarily like it, but I appreciate the fact that the ballsiest thing that Black Sabbath could have done and did actually do on this fourth LP is slow it down and make it sappy.
"Changes," though different, remains an outlier (as does the nothing song "FX"). The rest are the standard heavy metal that you have come to expect from these guys. Not a bad thing, but nothing that's exciting me, four albums into this. It's not a good sign when the big headline in the story of the making of this album is "it's more of the same, plus a lot of drugs this time!" Just about the only noteworthy thing that can come from that is that a band is good enough to overcome the handicap of intoxication. I've never been on coke, but I'm assuming it's harder to make music when you're high on coke 24/7. It's mildly funny that they wanted to call the album Snowblind originally (making the excellent "Snowblind" a title track) but couldn't because no one wanted them to name their album after cocaine. I don't know if I'd go so far as to say that it makes the album "sadder" or whatever (maybe I just have more sympathy for the drinkers than I do the sniffers), but I could see the argument being made.
Whatever the case may be, I'm not here arguing that it's a bad album. I'm just saying that it's not much that I haven't heard from these guys before. Which is also not a bad thing, because Black Sabbath kick ass. But I cannot say that they pass the Five-Album Test. Down to argue some more about it, though, if you are.
2 comments:
SCENE REPORT
MJ Lenderman and Waxahatchee
Center for the Performing Arts, University of Buffalo
April 23, 2026, Buffalo, New York, America
1) The opener was young woman named Brennan and I am sure she was lovely but I did not bother to observe her performance. I instead stood in a very long line to buy a very room-temperature Labatt Blue only to be informed that no drinks would be allowed in the theater during the performance. This was my error; I assumed that this show, like every other live music show I have ever attended, would permit me to hold a beer on my knee while listening to the tunes. Perhaps this can be laid at the feet of the venue, which was a very nice seated amphitheater with posture-correcting seatbacks and a architectural style that had the seating go straight up rather than backwards. I ended up looking at the top of Lenderman and Crutchfield's heads for the entirety of their performance.
2) Regarding their performance: the idea here was "intimate." The stage was made up to look like a cozy living room, completed with a half-dozen throw rugs, damn near 12 lamps, a TV turned to static, and several end tables and book-cases. Our primaries sat their asses down in folding chairs and did not get up for the duration of the show, save to feint at an encour at the end. They also did not speak to the crowd or to each other. At one point, a hundered feet in the air and in a tuning moment between songs, I dropped my cell phone on a padded stair and you would have thought I took a shit on the stage for the reaction it garnered. This was a focused crowd. I found it hard to stay awake.
3) MJ Lenderman did not aid in wakfulness. His tunes are down-beat and thoughtful by design, but having a backing band at his heels turns those slowdowns into Neil Young tornadoes. When it's just Jake and a couple other guys on banjo or pedal steel, something like "TLC Cagematch" feel like a lullaby on ludes.
4) This make Waxahatchee by comparison sound like fucking Mogwai. By virtue of her songs being more propulsive and more rock-centered, as opposed to folk/country bones of Lenderman's jams, her pulled-back tracks felt like hearing the Ramones first four records. I walked away from the show with a new appriciation for her vocal work and her strucrual approach to her craft, and I'll be tacking a run back through the catalog to see where the gems are.
5) The closed with a cover of "Six O'Clock News" by Kathleen Edwards, which I had never heard before and which blew my dome straight off. If nothing else, the show gave me that song, and I wouldn't say it wasn't worth the $70 I paid for tickets, but it wasn't bad, either. Always nice to put some money back into the SUNY system.
Sounds like the MJ Lenderman show was fine.
Post a Comment