Saturday, February 10, 2024

Yearlong Song Challenge, Day 19: Joe

Prompt: "The most recent song you actually hate"

Selected by Joe


"Big Foot"
Nicki Minaj
single, 2024

Very few words need to be written about this. In fact, I'm probably doing the world a disservice by embedding this song on this blog and acknowledging its existence. I am very sorry about that. But I was committed to writing about a song I really fucking hated, and not, like, a new Green Day song that isn't bad and that I probably don't like just because it doesn't stack up to anything from Dookie or American Idiot. Leave be the artists who are trying their best. Remember there are famous musicians out there who are trying their worst.

I didn't need this song to convince me to not like Nicki Minaj. Yes, it's bad in a vacuum. If the worst disses you can think of about your rival is that she is ugly because of her height—which isn't true objectively or subjectively, in this case or in general—and that she was shot in the foot—which courts have determined, after hearing the evidence, did happen, and the perpetrator has thus been imprisoned—then it's probably clear to most people that you don't have much ground to stand on. (I was going to say "have a foot to stand on" but let's avoid terrible puns whenever we can.)

I didn't even need to learn the indisputable fact that started this whole rather dumb rivalry: that Nicki Minaj is married to a rapist. I don't like Nicki Minaj but I don't think that the choice to marry a rapist necessarily moves the needle one way or the other regarding my opinion of her. That whole thing is complicated. E.g. it would be different if it was the rapist's music we were talking about, e.g. it would be different if sex offenders were never in any circumstance worthy of forgiveness, e.g. it would be different if Minaj explicitly advocated for rape or public defended rape or something like that, and so on and nauseatingly so on. Megan Thee Stallion's line of "These hoes don't be mad at Megan / these hoes mad at Megan's Law" is a decent lyric, probably not her best. Also, as I said, the facts in that bar are indisputable. However, in terms of all that stuff about "the morality of the personal choice to listen to music" that I'm always yapping about on this blog, I don't think my feelings about Nicki Minaj and her actions necessarily apply there. Correct me if I'm wrong, though. I'm just trying to be fair and consistent.

The totality of what I know about this so-called hip-hop rivalry could fit on the tip of Tony Lanez's bullet that pierced Megan Pete's foot. I don't need to know who started it or why. I don't need to speculate who is winning it or why not. I don't even need to attempt to convince you that this is a bad song, and a bizarrely errant shot in a back-and-forth that bored me before I even found out about it. It's bad, and you already know it without reading this blog post. This is worse than any original rap I've ever heard lip-synced on an episode of RuPaul's Drag Race. The fact that it eventually devolves into what I can only describe as an ASMR-themed podcast, I mean... I don't even know what to say about that.

No, here is everything I needed to know about Nicki Minaj to dislike her: in 2018, a journalist named Wanna Thompson tweeted a very reasonable take about Nicki Minaj—"You know how dope it would be if Nicki put out mature content? No silly shit... She's touching 40 soon, a new direction is needed"—and Minaj's fans (I won't even debase myself in writing what they call themselves) started sending death threats. Nicki Minaj's reaction to this tension was to... send Thompson a personal message directly that read "Eat a dick, you hating ass hoe... Just say you jealous I'm rich, famous, intelligent, pretty, and go! But wait! Leave my balls! Tired of you sucking them." You know, instead of the reasonable response that might look something like "thanks to all my fans for defending me but I do not condone personal attacks on journalists" or some such like that.

I don't know exactly why that shit has stuck with me all these years, or why it upset me so much originally. It just felt like, I don't know, like a line was crossed here somehow. I know Minaj can't control her fans, just like Swift wouldn't be able to stop her hardcore fans from acting insane, or like Beyoncé wouldn't be able to stop her hardcore fans from acting insane, and so on and so on. BTS fans sent death threats to Stereogum writer Tom Brehein that one time, and I don't think for a second that BTS was condoning the behavior. So maybe that's the line? How Nicki Minaj not only encouraged the behavior, but gleefully participated in it? There should be some boundary between artist and the audience, no? How the fuck does Doja Cat, of all fucking people, have the most normal take here?!

The great irony, you can plainly see now, is that Wanna Thompson's legitimate critique obviously fell on deaf ears. How dope would it be if Nicki put out mature content? The world will never know how dope. Since the content she's putting out these days seems to be pretty, errrr, immature? That's probably the best way I can describe a diss track whose main thesis is that the rival's mom is dead and that she has big feet. Yikes.

No comments: