Saturday, February 3, 2024

Yearlong Song Challenge, Day 16: Sunny

Prompt: "The song you think of when you hear the word 'emo'"

Selected by Sunny


"Okay I Believe You, but My Tommy Gun Don't"
Brand New
Deja Entendu, 2003

Many songs click through the mental marquee on a queue like this. You have your Black Parades, your All I Wanteds, of course. But this Brand New track, when I first heard it, unveiled on someone's MySpace front page, was revelatory. The slow moody vocals, rhythmic guitar that layers into the drop, reverb chorus, the long song title reference to other media. Woah, those emo kids have like, a different kind of music going on. Or so I felt for quite some time. 

In the blinding light of retrospect, the song's alright. The genres got better. Did this song start a kind of craze? Likely no. But I'm not sure how ironically to take that lyric, wow so emo. I'd go on to, years later in the genius.com write-up, find out that the track is actually a drama-soaked brag song, that the c-c-controversial thing is a dig, that the singer would then, years later relative to him, have serious allegations brought forth towards him about serious misconduct, more of which in accordance to my policy of "not reading into things," I did not further read into. The whole mess sounds emo.

4 comments:

Joe K said...

NOTE: If you would like to further read into things, you can read this article, which details the ways in which the frontman of Brand New sexually abused and exploited minors.

I will repeat this as many times as I need to: listening to music is a personal choice. Just because I am choosing to not listen to this song that was posted on the blog for the third time today due to the fact that the frontman sexually abused children, does NOT mean that I have any right to tell YOU that you cannot listen to it.

Do I agree with it? No. Am I an authority on what people should or should not be able to listen to? Absolutely not. In fact, Sunny's final sentence here—"the whole mess sounds emo"—even though the word "mess" seems to be doing a lot of the work there—might even mean that this song choice was the perfect choice for this particular prompt.

You must know how I feel about it at this point, so I'll stop.

Boober said...

Is there a similar reason you hate Queen or?

Joe K said...

No way. I dislike Queen's music. I don't like or dislike or feel anything about Brand New's music, because I don't listen to them on purpose.

Liking or disliking art based on quality alone is one thing. Actively avoiding the artist because it's wrong to support them is a completely different thing.

Joe K said...

The word "wrong" in that last comment being totally subjective, though. There is a reasonable argument that it's not "wrong" to listen to Brand New. I just don't agree with it, personally.