Saturday, February 3, 2024

Yearlong Song Challenge, Day 16: Nick

Prompt: "The song you think of when you hear the word 'emo'"

Selected by Nick


The Blue Album, 1994

I don't mean to be one of those "Real Emo only consists of the DC Emotional Hardcore scene and the late-'90s Screamo scene" guys. First off, I don't believe it, and, second, it's not really everyone else's fault. It's just the nature of language. A word means something, until a bunch of grubby children hanging out in and around the Hot Topic at Neshaminy Mall start saying Hawthorne Heights, All Time Low, and (I shit you fucking not someone said this to me once) Linkin Park are "emo," and all of a sudden nothing means anything anymore. Call it whatever you want, I just wish that a lot of good music didn't end up getting derided because it got lumped into a word people didn't get, or because a lot of bad music got lumped in with it.

If you'd written off emo because you were under the impression that it’s one thing, or you like Three Cheers...-era My Chemical Romance (I do!) and aren't sure what else led to it or came out of it, I'm all for offering suggestions. There's a ton of really good and enjoyable music in the whole system of knotty roots that is emo.

Anyway, like I assume most of you will, I've picked a song from a band that is probably not actually emo, Weezer. But, like Andy Greenwald said, they could have been. Like Andy, one of the original scholars of emo, I think Weezer was an emo band, or at least were on their way to being one. The Green Album was an absolute departure from that, and we just sort of lost them after. For a while, I thought they were definitely going to come back through the door with those cigarettes they said they were going to get when they left, but instead we got "Beverly Hills."

All that said, they're still the band I think of when I think of emo, because so much of their early stuff clearly set me down the path I'd later walk. Had I never obsessed over The Blue Album and Pinkerton so much, I doubt I'd have dug as deep as I did into the music I did in 2003 and 2004, which was the gateway into the next set of musical obsessions which pushed me off the ledge into my next set of... You get the idea.

"Only in Dreams" is one of my favorite songs ever. Full stop. It's simple, with the light strokes of texture and timbre required to keep simple from fading away. At first listen, if you're unlucky enough to have never previously sat with it, it seems far too long. It's not. It's a perfect stroll through an open field that weaves its way through an ever-thickening forest filled with tension begging to be razed. When it is razed, in a frenzy and fracas you never predicted when it started, you'll be happy you spent each of those eight minutes listening, and, if you're me in 1999 considering his mortality in the face of the Y2K scare, you'll give it another eight minutes right away.

No comments: