Hi Kailyn. This is Joe from Philadelphia. Hope all is well. My apologies for hitting you up out of the blue again. I don't have an art request this time, though I do hope that you're still creating and finding joy in your art.I'm just doing my due diligence and following up on an email that we exchanged a few years ago. I told you in June 2021 that I was asking people about their favorite albums of all time, and you were nice enough to send me a list of albums that you said were your favorite. Over three years later, I have finally become acquainted with all of them, and wanted to share with you some of my thoughts. Like you are with your art, I have personally found that listening to and talking to friends about music is the thing that brings me peace and joy. So thanks for indulging me.Hybrid Theory by Linkin Park — I feel like I was pretty judgmental on the big hits by Linkin Park in my youth, so it was cool reconnecting with it and finding that the sound has aged real nicely. There's probably always room for a little teenage angst no matter how old we get.Masterpiece Theatre by Marianas Trench — Sometimes I get real down on pop music, but then I have Marianas Trench to remind me that sometimes pop music can masquerade as rock music. There were some catchy tunes on this thing. Maybe a little thin, but it's pop music! That's okay!Don't You Fake It by Red Jumpsuit Apparatus — Completely forgot about "Face Down" before you reminded me of it through this album. Holy hell... this is a good track. Like Linkin Park, it was interesting reexamining it as an adult. Kind of intense themes!Meteora by Linkin Park — Okay, so is it wrong to say that this is better than Hybrid Theory? I have no idea, and it's too late to get a sense online as to which album is generally considered their best. That one song with the flute was neat. I wasn't expecting that on a Linkin Park album.Red River Blue by Blake Shelton — Your country music picks were a cool challenge for me. I don't hate country music generally, but there is a certain substrain that I can't stand. I would probably include Blake Shelton in that category. But! I found some stuff to like here! That honey bee song was goofy fun!Boys Like Girls by BOYS LIKE GIRLS — Now emo and pop punk are a lot easier to get into than country music for me, and listening to this album was like putting on a warm pair of slippers. "Head over Heels" was a highlight. I know you had said that some of these albums had standout songs for you, so I listened to albums trying to pick out which were the best songs, wondering which ones you had on your playlist.Steal This Album! by System of a Down — Duuuuude... this might have been my favorite on your list. I was familiar with System of a Down, obviously, but the deep cuts were pretty wild on this album, and I wish I had gotten into this band earlier. The singer is nuts. I love it.Avenged Sevenfold by Avenged Sevenfold — I was not expecting this album to be so varied. It starts like weird nu-metal but ends with basically a Broadway showstopper in the same vein as Pink Floyd's The Wall? Absolutely fascinating album.American Tragedy by Hollywood Undead — Holy shit, this one made me laugh a lot. I don't know if it was supposed to be a parody of rap rock or the real thing, but I don't think it matters. Some of the lines that Charlie Scene drops are outrageous. Those lines have been stuck in my head ever since. The one about peeing the bed on a sleepover? A twisted genius.Stadium Arcadium by Red Hot Chili Peppers — Damn, two hours of RHCP is a lot for me. Lots of fluff here surrounding the big hits that we all know and love. "Torture Me" was my takeaway deep cut.Relapse by Eminem — Still not really sure what to make of this one. Eminem seems to be rapping in a fake Jamaican accent for most of it? I don't know if I like it... but I also could totally see how this album would be very influential for a new generation of shock rappers.Strummin' on Garth by Brooks Jefferson — What in the world? Does Brooks Jefferson not actually exist? I played this album and realized that it was all Garth Brooks covers, and that Brooks Jefferson was a shadow entity. I might need you to explain this one to me.You Get What You Give by Zac Brown Band — Like I said for the Shelton pick, this really isn't my cup of tea. But I've listened to the ten-minute "Who Knows" so many times. That's the one.Stand Up and Scream by Asking Alexandria — Can't say I'm too familiar with this type of music. Guttural metal noises? Mixed with twinkly EDM rave beats? I was more fascinated than enthralled. Or maybe enthralled with how fascinated I was. This felt comparable to Hollywood Undead, in that I was really happy exploring it, without actually liking it, if that makes sense.Me and My Gang by Rascal Flatts — Pretty good!Thanks again for the good picks. If you're still out there listening to music and exploring new favorites, feel free to hit me up any time and chat. If you are busy and/or think that it's weird that a stranger is reaching out to you years after you made recommendations, then feel free to ignore this email too! Regardless, thanks again. I hope life has been great for you the past few years. Take care.Joe
This is my final signal sent outward toward Pittsburgh and toward my once-internet-friend Kailyn. I don't know if it'll ever reach it's destination, but I still transmit with hope that she will one day hear me and wonder what I'm doing with my time. I will probably not tell her that I wrote twelve blog posts about her.
While it's disheartening to know that this short-lived blog feature will never gain the closure it deserves, I will still sleep soundly knowing that I at least made an attempt. I think sometimes about what happened here, and why she doesn't respond to emails. It could be anything, any reason, serious or petty. Maybe she got a new email address because her old one was hacked. Maybe she has a filter set for "art request" because she is actively trying to distance herself from her old hobby. Maybe she's dead! I know her last name and don't see anything about obituaries on google so probably not, bus still! How sad would that be?
Whatever the reason, we can now simply say that Kailyn no longer exists. With the ending of this blog column, she reverts back into the ether from which she originally came. A spirit who haunted the blog for three months with bizarre, nonsensically-arranged music, we now put the idea of her to rest. The Kailyn we know, the one constructed here with hot glue and felt, is gone. Unless she responds to my email, in which case, KAILYN'S DOZEN PART II!!!!
We have one more album from her list of favorite albums. I described the album as "pretty good" in the email because I hadn't heard it yet at the time I composed the email, but didn't want to leave it out. In the week since, I have of course listened to Me and My Gang the requisite number of times and am here to dutifully tell you about it briefly, while weakly tying its themes to the overarching theme of this blog series, which is... not really all that well-defined. But the beauty is in the attempt, so let us attempt, one last time.
Me and My Gang is not that good, and Rascal Flatts are not that good. I don't feel the knee-jerk reaction of needing to explain my thoughts on country music for this one like I did with Zac Brown Band, because Rascal Flatts are more pop than country. They follow the same format as early Taylor Swift—pop is the sheet cake, and country is just the food coloring. "Cool Thing" and "Stand" are especially Swiftian. Except they can't write hooks as strong as the young Swift, it seems. Too many sappy ballads. Too much bullshit.
Me and My Gang is not that good, and Rascal Flatts are not that good. I don't feel the knee-jerk reaction of needing to explain my thoughts on country music for this one like I did with Zac Brown Band, because Rascal Flatts are more pop than country. They follow the same format as early Taylor Swift—pop is the sheet cake, and country is just the food coloring. "Cool Thing" and "Stand" are especially Swiftian. Except they can't write hooks as strong as the young Swift, it seems. Too many sappy ballads. Too much bullshit.
Oh sure, there are stabs at country. I actually kind like the meta-country exercise of "Backwards," which attempts to describe a typical country song in reverse. I don't like the song but I appreciate the concept a lot. Most of this other shit is just boring. It's not offensive in any way, so I guess I can see how the more banal of your Average Music Listeners might be attracted to it. But it's definitely not my thing. Most of these albums have not been "my thing," but that often doesn't stop me from appreciating them on at least a sociological level. I can't even do that with Rascal Flatts. Too vague and generic.
As a reminder: I do not download or listen to bonus tracks, but I am usually aware of their existence, especially if one of those bonus tracks on any given album is objectively more popular than the songs on the album proper. So yes, I am aware of the existence of Rascal Flatts' cover of Tom Cochrane's "Life Is a Highway" for the Disney Pixar movie Cars. And no, I certainly did not listen to that shit this past week (heard enough of it while I was at Disney World this past April, to be honest). The fact that this is Rascal Flatts' most popular song by many metrics renders this band a fucking joke. I like a good joke, but I don't like contributing to it.
I only bring this up because, as we've discussed in prior weeks, Kailyn most likely put together her list of favorite albums based on choosing random songs that she likes and then writing down the album from which those random songs originally came from. There's enough evidence to support this theory, but now here is one more piece. Be honest with me: how likely is it that Kailyn really enjoys Rascal Flatts' 2006 cover version of an already dumb country-pop song crafted for a dumb kids movie about talking cars, and that's why this album was in her email and subsequently on my life of albums that I'm forcing myself to listen to? How likely? Very likely, would you say?
I would say extremely likely. And that just makes me shake my head in dismay. It makes the distance between me and Kailyn feel a lot longer than 300 miles. It makes me feel like we have nothing in common, me and her, besides, I don't know, a love of silly pictures of me riding a giant cat. And I start to wonder what the fuck I'm even trying to accomplish here, by pretending that there is not a huge gulch separating us and our respectively beliefs. I don't believe that Me and My Gang should be anywhere fucking near a Favorite Albums All-Time list. And if I don't believe that, then what else would we disagree about?
I don't meant to disparage the time I spent listening to the music that this column forced me to listen to. I actually cherish that time dearly. There is absolutely no other time and space in my life where I would be listening to an artist like Hollywood Undead or Blake Shelton or Avenge Sevenfold and attempting to be gracious and compassionate in my take on their music. This was a great opportunity to try to see some of my least favorite music from some fresh perspectives. As an amateur music critic, I am eternally grateful.
And I don't see why I can't apply that same mindset to another human being too. Of course someone who compiles such a list of favorite albums is not going to be someone with whom I see eye-to-eye regarding music. But there's still so much room for empathy here on a basic human level, even through the music I don't like.
For example, maybe I'm wrong about the Cars thing, and maybe the song that she liked from this album was "Ellsworth." It's actually kind of a touching song about a grandma with dementia whose passion for life only lights up when you mention the town she grew up in. Maybe Kailyn likes this song because she had a grandparent like that and can relate. It wouldn't matter if I think the song is less effective as sung by song grease-slick fraudster country-pop stars than it would've been from someone more authentic. It wouldn't matter in that case because I too had a grandparent like that, my own paternal grandpa who would get really excited toward the end of his life when you mentioned his old stomping grounds of Fishtown, Philadelphia. The music is important, you see, but the quality of the music isn't. It's what the music does to you, the listener.
I do seriously wonder if I'll ever cross paths with Kailyn again in my lifetime. I've done all I can do at this point to force it, so now it's up to fate and happenstance to do the work. In all likelihood, this is the end of the road for us as friends, internet friends or otherwise. But you never know, man. Life is fucking weird and wild. You just never fucking know.
Even if it doesn't happen, and even if this really is it and I never think about Kailyn ever again, I will still cherish this time with her ghost. I think she taught me a lot about what it means to interact with someone who likes the music you don't. It was good practice, anyway, for all those future real-life friends who also listen to Red Jumpsuit Apparatus and Eminem and phony Garth Brookses. Music is important because it brings people together. It shouldn't drive them apart. And even if you can't agree on what is good and what is bad, you can at least agree on the power of music in general, and use it as a tool to find that common ground.
I would say extremely likely. And that just makes me shake my head in dismay. It makes the distance between me and Kailyn feel a lot longer than 300 miles. It makes me feel like we have nothing in common, me and her, besides, I don't know, a love of silly pictures of me riding a giant cat. And I start to wonder what the fuck I'm even trying to accomplish here, by pretending that there is not a huge gulch separating us and our respectively beliefs. I don't believe that Me and My Gang should be anywhere fucking near a Favorite Albums All-Time list. And if I don't believe that, then what else would we disagree about?
I don't meant to disparage the time I spent listening to the music that this column forced me to listen to. I actually cherish that time dearly. There is absolutely no other time and space in my life where I would be listening to an artist like Hollywood Undead or Blake Shelton or Avenge Sevenfold and attempting to be gracious and compassionate in my take on their music. This was a great opportunity to try to see some of my least favorite music from some fresh perspectives. As an amateur music critic, I am eternally grateful.
And I don't see why I can't apply that same mindset to another human being too. Of course someone who compiles such a list of favorite albums is not going to be someone with whom I see eye-to-eye regarding music. But there's still so much room for empathy here on a basic human level, even through the music I don't like.
For example, maybe I'm wrong about the Cars thing, and maybe the song that she liked from this album was "Ellsworth." It's actually kind of a touching song about a grandma with dementia whose passion for life only lights up when you mention the town she grew up in. Maybe Kailyn likes this song because she had a grandparent like that and can relate. It wouldn't matter if I think the song is less effective as sung by song grease-slick fraudster country-pop stars than it would've been from someone more authentic. It wouldn't matter in that case because I too had a grandparent like that, my own paternal grandpa who would get really excited toward the end of his life when you mentioned his old stomping grounds of Fishtown, Philadelphia. The music is important, you see, but the quality of the music isn't. It's what the music does to you, the listener.
I do seriously wonder if I'll ever cross paths with Kailyn again in my lifetime. I've done all I can do at this point to force it, so now it's up to fate and happenstance to do the work. In all likelihood, this is the end of the road for us as friends, internet friends or otherwise. But you never know, man. Life is fucking weird and wild. You just never fucking know.
Even if it doesn't happen, and even if this really is it and I never think about Kailyn ever again, I will still cherish this time with her ghost. I think she taught me a lot about what it means to interact with someone who likes the music you don't. It was good practice, anyway, for all those future real-life friends who also listen to Red Jumpsuit Apparatus and Eminem and phony Garth Brookses. Music is important because it brings people together. It shouldn't drive them apart. And even if you can't agree on what is good and what is bad, you can at least agree on the power of music in general, and use it as a tool to find that common ground.
GRADE: 2 pukes out of 5
A PICTURE FROM KAILYN'S OLD INSTAGRAM THAT BEST ENCAPSULATES THE EXPERIENCE OF LISTENING TO THIS ALBUM:
A PICTURE FROM KAILYN'S OLD INSTAGRAM THAT BEST ENCAPSULATES THE EXPERIENCE OF LISTENING TO THIS ALBUM:
THE COMPLETED LIST, IN ORDER OF COVERAGE:
- Hybrid Theory by Linkin Park
- Masterpiece Theatre by Marianas Trench
- Don't You Fake It by Red Jumpsuit Apparatus
- Meteora by Linkin Park
- Red River Blue by Blake Shelton
- Boys Like Girls by BOYS LIKE GIRLS
- Steal This Album! by System of a Down
- Avenged Sevenfold by Avenged Sevenfold
- American Tragedy by Hollywood Undead
- Stadium Arcadium by Red Hot Chili Peppers
- Relapse by Eminem
- Strummin' On Garth by Brooks Jefferson
- You Get What You Give by Zac Brown Band
- Stand Up and Scream by Asking Alexandria
- Me and My Gang by Rascal Flatts















